Support NeoGAF

[FranXico]

Executive editor at IGN and Xbox guru Ryan McCaffrey said that he is dissapointed and letdown by Xbox Series X|S launch line up, when this was brought into discussion in the latest Unlocked podcast.

Xbox Series X Launch Lineup Reactions – Unlocked 466 - IGN

Say hi to special guest Cam 'The Cinephile Guy' Hawkins!

www.ign.com

Link to streamable:


Edit: linking to source instead of twitter.

Edit 2: added a poll, as someone requested.

Edit 3: tweet confirming the statement, along with further elaboration.

 

[Tschumi]

Salient point. They seem to be intent on disseminating their games to every possible console.. i imagine some people are just gonna want good games on a good system.. when i realised that I'll be able to play every xBox game on my computer, any residual interest i ever held in getting an xsx just vanished in smoke~

 

[FranXico]

I was surprised by this opinion coming from him. He has always been very hyped about all things Xbox.

 

[Ar¢tos]

It is a weird launch for both consoles, but we are in a weird year, so it is fitting.

 

[Blood Borne]

Absolutely. No exclusive launch game is mind-boggling.

 

[Pinktaco]

Different people have different opinions ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Some people wants to play the new FIFA/COD/BF/whatever on the newest console of their prefered brand and others are mainly concerned about the exclusives.

 

[Bonfires Down]

”What am I gonna do on this thing?” Play games on it.

”How am I gonna show it off?” Play games on it.

I’m sure Phil Spencer is even more disappointed than we are that there are no big launch exclusives, but it is what it is. Series X will still play all cross gen games better than XB1 and it will play next gen multiplats. If you want the new gen excitement then buy a PS5 now and check back with Xbox in a year or two. That’s all there is to it.

 

[DonJimbo]

Hey Ryan you forgot to name the ps5 aswell you scumbag the ps5 has no games aswell to spend 500 fucking bucks on it aswell asshole

 

[Blood Borne]

It is a weird launch for both consoles, but we are in a weird year, so it is fitting.

Not true. PS5 launch ain’t the best but it’s still decent. Demons Soul, Godfall, Sackboy Adventures, Destruction All Stars, Ratchet & Clank and Spider-Man are good launch games . XSX has nothing

 

[bitbydeath]

It is a weird launch for both consoles, but we are in a weird year, so it is fitting.

Both consoles? Sony is having one of the best gaming launches of all time.

 

[Bankai]

I think it's great that he doesn't kiss Xbox's ass, just because he runs a Xbox centric podcast.

There are WAY more reasons to get excited about Xbox Series X, when you didn't get into Xbox One. I didn't get a Xbox One, got everything on PS4. Therefor I missed out on some great games like Gears 5, Forza series and something like Sunset Overdrive.

Though, I still won't be getting a new Xbox day one. First I want to see new AAA first party titles, like the new Fable. Then I'm in!

 

[Deleted member 775630]

Does he only play exclusives and never plays 3rd party titles?

 

[Neko Mimi Mode]

Why yes, Xbox Series games can be played on One X, this has been known and well publicised by Microsoft for over a year - yet somehow Ryan has a Eureka moment reading the lineup list that Xbox doesn't believe in generations.

If he can't see the difference between playing a game in 1080p/30 and 4k/60, or in 120hz, then that's his issue.

On another note, quoting straight Twitter warriors like The Red Dragon is poor form and you're better than it OP.

 

[Aceofspades]

It is a weird launch for both consoles, but we are in a weird year, so it is fitting.

PS5 launch is fantastic, DS, SM, Sackboy, Godfall, shortly followed by Rachet and God of War

 

[DonJimbo]

Both consoles? Sony is having one of the best gaming launches of all time.

You're joking imirite don't bring up a remake of a PS3 game because I don't care about souls games and their niche
Spiderman and sackboy are cross gen
There's only Godfall and the third parties are cross gen aswell so what's left for this great launch lmao

 

[BlackProdigy]

Salient point. They seem to be intent on disseminating their games to every possible console.. i imagine some people are just gonna want good games on a good system.. when i realised that I'll be able to play every xBox game on my computer, any residual interest i ever held in getting an xsx just vanished in smoke~

You missed the entire point. Has nothing to do with if a Microsoft game is on a computer but more there isn't really anything "nextgen" on the console at the moment. I would argue NBA2k21 but I think many people in these circles are ignoring this game.

 

[THE DUCK]

Not true. PS5 launch ain’t the best but it’s still decent. Demons Soul, Godfall, Ratchet & Clank and Spider-Man are good launch games . XSX has nothing

A remake that looks decent, a game thats also on pc, and a game that has no release date, and an add on game? Hardly brimming with exclusive launch content in ps5 land either.

 

[Knitted Knight]

I made a thread on the industry implications of this.

It's bad. An Xbox lover like Ryan isn't hard to please and won over by MS - he's as hardcore to the brand as they come. So you know it's extremely bad when even he can't sugar coat it. It's laughably bad compared to previous Xbox launches according to this:

https://kotaku.com/let-s-compare-every-xbox-consoles-launch-lineup-1845097753

Obviously I get that casuals will buy it to play COD, Madden, NBA2K21 etc but for the hardcore, the likes which frequent Gaf to make excuses (they know better).... ooofff. Phil had 6 years to prepare and is asking for 2-3 more. Close to a decade. Biggest pimp to ever grace gaming. Then all he talks about is Gamepass. Where the damn AAA exclusive games?

 

[93xfan]

May as well trade in your old console now while it’s at its highest value. I don’t expect price drops for years

 

[freefornow]

And yet, cant pick a Series X up anywhere!

 

[Tulipanzo]

But but MS says it's the greatest lineup in XBox history!

 

[killatopak]

Anakin no!

 

[DonJimbo]

PS5 launch is fantastic, DS, SM, Sackboy, Godfall, shortly followed by Rachet and God of War

Yeah but not 500 bucks worthy

 

[DeeDogg_]

And yet, cant pick a Series X up anywhere!

Checkmate, Ryan!
muh Xbox sold out!

 

[MrS]

Not true. PS5 launch ain’t the best but it’s still decent. Demons Soul, Godfall, Ratchet & Clank and Spider-Man are good launch games . XSX has nothing

This is easily Sony’s best launch line up ever. Xbox has absolutely nothing. If people weren’t such fanboys and were actually looking for games to play on November 19th, PS absolutely smokes Xbox. MFs writing off Demon’s as ‘just a remaster’ are on drugs. The game looks absolutely unreal and unlike anything we’ve seen before in relation to console graphics.

Yeah but not 500 bucks worthy

i disagree. I’m getting 5 launch games. The lineup is absolutely worth the entry fee.

 

[playXray]

At this point, going from X1X to XSX is basically a PC upgrade for me. The good news is, I love PC upgrades!

 

[Neko Mimi Mode]

if people weren’t such fanboys and were actually looking for games to play on November 19th,

Everyone is going to be playing Cyberpunk 2077 on November 19th, let's be honest.

 

[BaneIsPain]

Fairplay to Ryan. That’s why no worries about getting a Xbox series x, you should wait next year or 2022 to get the best of it (hopefully)

 

[MrS]

Everyone is going to be playing Cyberpunk 2077 on November 19th, let's be honest.

They’re going to be playing Demon’s Souls. PC gamers and Xbox players will be playing CP2077 as they’ll have fuck all else to do.

 

[DonJimbo]

This is easily Sony’s best launch line up ever. Xbox has absolutely nothing. If people weren’t such fanboys and were actually looking for games to play on November 19th, PS absolutely smokes Xbox. MFs writing off Demon’s as ‘just a remaster’ are on drugs. The game looks absolutely unreal and unlike anything we’ve seen before in relation to console graphics.

i disagree. I’m getting 5 launch games. The lineup is absolutely worth the entry fee.

And I disagree with you
When I can play the games that I interest on the PS4 pro aswell why should I spent 500 bucks on a new machine that makes no fucking sense

 

[Ar¢tos]

Not true. PS5 launch ain’t the best but it’s still decent. Demons Soul, Godfall, Ratchet & Clank and Spider-Man are good launch games . XSX has nothing

Both consoles? Sony is having one of the best gaming launches of all time.

PS5 launch is fantastic, DS, SM, Sackboy, Godfall, shortly followed by Rachet and God of War

I didn't mean based on a single thing (games).
Sony showed [launch] games, but was very silent most of the time giving info with a drip feeder, while MS did the opposite.

 

[Grinchy]

There's a reason no one, including MS, has ever launched a new generation console without software showing at least some early version of what it can do.

MS just really screwed up their scheduling.

 

[Rentahamster]

There's still going to be a lot of games to play even if there aren't as many exclusives as PS5. Those who care about it, like that guy, care. Many others don't care. It's not that big a deal. Different strokes.

 

[Neko Mimi Mode]

They’re going to be playing Demon’s Souls.

It looks great for sure, but Cyberpunk 2077 is one of the most anticipated games ever.

Since I, and many others, already beat DS on the PS3, I think Cyberpunk is the obvious choice for game time there

 

[DonJimbo]

I didn't mean based on a single thing (games).
Sony showed [launch] games, but was very silent most of the time giving info with a drip feeder, while MS did the opposite.

MS had the balls Jimbo didn't that monkey face

 

[DonJuanSchlong]

They’re going to be playing Demon’s Souls. PC gamers and Xbox players will be playing CP2077 as they’ll have fuck all else to do.

Do you honestly think PC gamers have nothing to play?


Because....

 

[Michael Hawk]

Genuinely surprised to hear him being honest about Xbox's horrible launch lineup. Come to think of it, this is the second time in 2020 that he's commented on Xbox's launch games -- or lack thereof.

Supporting oldass games is neat, but your new console can't rely on nostalgia. You need new stuff for your new thing. Sales will be strong at launch, but if the millions of people who buy your console find themselves with nothing new to play not even a month after launch then you've got a real problem on your hands.

 

[Hudo]

He's correct but this criticism also extends to the PS5 lineup. Both console launches are one of the weakest I have seen.

 

[MrS]

Since I, and many others, already beat DS on the PS3, I think Cyberpunk is the obvious choice for game time there

i beat RE2 in 98. Still played Remake2 on launch day as it’s a brand new experience. DS will be the same imho.

 

[DonJimbo]

Genuinely surprised to hear him being honest about Xbox's horrible launch lineup. Come to think of it, this is the second time in 2020 that he's commented on Xbox's launch games -- or lack thereof.

Supporting oldass games is neat, but your new console can't rely on nostalgia. You need new stuff for your new thing. Sales will be strong at launch, but if the millions of people who buy your console find themselves with nothing new to play not even a month after launch then you've got a real problem on your hands.

Theyre compensating the lack of new games with Gamepass

 

[ToadMan]

I was surprised by this opinion coming from him. He has always been very hyped about all things Xbox.

I think the Geoff Keighley interview really spun him around.

You could see in that interview he really identified with Keighley and maybe even idolised him - at the end when Keighley wasn’t impressed with the direction MS had taken, I think it started McCaffrey questioning things too.

https://www.ign.com/articles/geoff-...kojima-xbox-vs-ps5-and-more-ign-unfiltered-53

 

[Knitted Knight]

They’re going to be playing Demon’s Souls. PC gamers and Xbox players will be playing CP2077 as they’ll have fuck all else to do.

Pretty much. I'm playing Demon Souls first, Sackboy second, then Godfall, then Spider-man.... and hopefully by the time I'm done with those CP2077 next-gen versions would have released and the game is at discount.

People are putting sooo much stock on a single game. If it doesn't deliver on a personal level.... what then? The whole narrative crumbles - whether they admit to it or not online for face saving reasons.

 

[Neko Mimi Mode]

i beat RE2 in 98. Still played Remake2 on launch day as it’s a brand new experience. DS will be the same imho.

Remake2 was indeed fantastic, loved every second, but it didn't have Cyberpunk 2077 as competition when it launched.

Again, this is one of the most highly anticipated games ever.

 

[Kumomeme]

i guess original plan they rely on Halo Infinite that gonna be their 'botw' of launch title. but we see how it happened. the recent acquisition also dont have anything ready for launch.

meanwhile we can see that sony's decision to buy insomniac is pay off.

 

[MrS]

Do you honestly think PC gamers have nothing to play?


Because....

If you enjoy shitty games like Legion and Ass Creed, good luck to you

Remake2 was indeed fantastic, loved every second, but it didn't have Cyberpunk 2077 as competition when it launched.

Again, this is one of the most highly anticipated games ever.

Agreed. I’m looking forward to it but not until I’m done with actual next gen games. Looks phenomenal.

 

[Rhazer Fusion]

Does he only play exclusives and never plays 3rd party titles?

He can experience those third party games on the PS5 which will be close visually or even his OneX or PS4 Pro(or regular versions) with slightly reduced graphics and performance. He’s most likely talking about games that are only on the Series X that justifies his $500.

 

[Hawking Radiation]

Does he only play exclusives and never plays 3rd party titles?

PS5 has both bases covered. Series X/S doesn't. Don't you guys get it?

You're spending $500 on a Game pass console with nothing on offer that takes real advantage of the new hardware. That's a tough sell to everyone but the hard core Xbox crowd.

 

[klosos]

I can see his point about the lack of Day one exclusive content , However both Consoles are impressing me right now TBH , and i am looking for ward to see what they both bring in the next couple of years.

Lets not kid our self Xbox have gone the complete wrong way for the last 8 or so years but slowly they are turning it around. I mean Gamepass is excellent and Phil Spencer was left with a Train wreck by the previous head of Xbox ( i cant remember his name , a smug arsehole) and is doing a good job as far as i can tell.

 

[TrebleShot]

I have to say I'm sat here with my XSX pre order and I'm wondering why I need to keep it...

I was genuinely hyped to play the new Halo, I got myself a one s with the hope to relive the memories of Halo 1,2, 3 and the later entries.

I feel completely deflated by the launch and can't get excited about playing games I'm currently playing on my one s....I mean I guess forza horizon 4 will look nice but its 500 that I could commit to PS5 launch games.

Cant decide. Maybe I just keep it? Tide me over until the PS5 arrives.

 

[Calverz]

I think the most impressive thing about the video is some sad bastard has watched the entire stream and edited it to focus on the negatives.