-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Should Aquaman be Polynesian?
- Thread starter Frog-fu
- Start date
- Status
Since when is Aquaman B tier? Also reinvention especially when moving to different forms of media is what comics survive on. They don't seem to be making a big deal of the casting decision so I don't get the gimmick comment. Being Caucasian and American isn't vital to Aquaman so this works perfectly. Its a case by case thing with superheros.
What did he mean by this?
Member
I'm glad since this means Manu Bennet can play Ocean Master
Don't they just look like brothers
Don't they just look like brothers
I'm glad since this means Manu Bennet can play Ocean Master
Don't they just look like brothers
So you going to race swap a Native american for a Maori? Sounds like hustling backwards.
Ocean Master is Native American(Inupiat)
Seriously do people not read the source?
That's more or less what I'm getting at. Though it would certainly make more sense if his human half was Polynesian and if the Atlantean culture was borrowed from it.
It's only a gimmick if WB tears it like one. If they treat Polynesian culture with respect it won't be.
Dat pinky hold. Dapper as fuck.Should be, yes. Aquaman being white was always weird and just part of institutional history. 1940s was when it was 90% white in USA and before civil rights, so there was no fight for minority representation. Either way, pacific islanders make more sense for the character than this comic version who looks like a fucking joke.
Skellig Gra
Member
Polynesians are one of many great mariner traditions. It fits perfectly well but not any better than other sea faring cultures of the past.
teruterubozu
Member
Most seafaring cultures of the past never went swimming.
Skellig Gra
Member
Like the Greeks?
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
Well the blonde hair is part of his origin, but that could be replaced with something else if they even want to go in that direction.
Exactly, it looks like awesome casting and a good fit for a modern cinema Aquaman.
Exactly, it looks like awesome casting and a good fit for a modern cinema Aquaman.
teruterubozu
Member
Polynesians would have swam circles around them. Then knock 'em out with surfboards.
Nostremitus
Member
A blonde Solomon Islander would be cool. That's Melanesia, though.
jackissocool
Member
That's actually a good point. There are lots of examples of peoples of all races with mariner cultures. I think, though, that the specifically island nature of Polynesian culture makes it a great fit for Atlantis.
LegendofDragoonLives
Member
I can't tell if you're being sarcastic, but that sounds like a really terrible idea.
Momoa is a beast, he's going to change the perception of lame Aquaman that a lot of people have. The man is a beast.
teruterubozu
Member
No, I actually own a shark tooth sword.
He's not boring do you read his comics?
Also this is a comic book movie In comic books there are an infinite number of universes, so any character can be any race or gender as they all exist in separate dimensions.
That trident can kill supes. But i think he might have a sword two i can't remember.
Like anyone would notice, who reads Aquaman anyway?
Schweinehund
Member
I'm sure extraordinarily popular elements will make it into comics, like burton's batsuit did. They did try to make arrow like the tv show and it failed pretty badly, so they've backed off on that sort of thing. I'd wager a big push behind new 52 was streamlining the DCU for movies.
Stupid move, goes totally against what Ollie is about.
In the Green Arrow comics did they try to just make him bow Batman again? I keep watching Arrow hoping eventually i'll get fun witty Oliver.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
That cover should go right next to the encyclopedia article for "Why Comics Are Stupid"
Who would think a pitch that started with "Lets turn OG Aquaman into Cthulhu, then have another guy that looks just like him with the same exact name take his place" might not be good?
Should he be? Sure. It makes perfect sense for the character to be of a culture with strong ties to the water.
Current rumors say Mera will also be non-white. I'm guessing she will be Polynesian as well, but I wonder if there are other seafaring peoples she could come from. Obviously, I'm the typical ignorant American on this, so I'll read up on it.
Current rumors say Mera will also be non-white. I'm guessing she will be Polynesian as well, but I wonder if there are other seafaring peoples she could come from. Obviously, I'm the typical ignorant American on this, so I'll read up on it.
Union Carbine
Member
I think the change is great but I have zero investment in the comic or the lore.
Yeah i thought i've seen something like that. Also with in the "other's" book i think one of the Alchemist weapons was a sword . Also his mom has one.
Angelus Errare
Banned
I know a girl who's Melanesian, she's hilarious and absolutely hates being in the US lol.
His new 52 comics are pretty good, This over-arching story line he's been having has been really good.
He doesn't have to be blonde some people just don't know how comic universes work, some just don't like the changes, and some can just be racist (See some* Some! not all of the wally west new 52 reactions) even though wally's change was random as hell but i'm not gonna complain. I do absolutely hate bat girls change and i refuse to read her books.
He doesn't have to be blonde some people just don't know how comic universes work, some just don't like the changes, and some can just be racist (See some* Some! not all of the wally west new 52 reactions) even though wally's change was random as hell but i'm not gonna complain. I do absolutely hate bat girls change and i refuse to read her books.
Who would think a pitch that started with "Lets turn OG Aquaman into Cthulhu, then have another guy that looks just like him with the same exact name take his place" might not be good?
Fuck I blocked this from my memory. As least the design is alright.
For some reason this reminds me Dick Grayson was obviously the better Batman.
If I have to put up with the slightly dull but still perfectly fine Aquaman to get Mera who is GOAT tier its an alright trade off.
What did he mean by this?
Member
In the New 52, Orm is pure Atlantean. Maybe YOU should read the comics my man. if you gotta problem with that, take it up with DC.
And following source material has never been the requirement to make a great movie.
Being born blonde in Atlantis is a major sign of being cursed and you will bring about bad things.
The last blond Atlantian tried to eat the entire population
It's DC give them five minutes
Being born blonde in Atlantis is a major sign of being cursed and you will bring about bad things.
The last blond Atlantian tried to eat the entire population
That's not much of an excuse not to change Aquaman though. They could easily replace blond hair with any number of other signs. Colour of his eyes, birthmark, event at birth etc. Pretty much whatever they want.
Napoleonthechimp
Member
Going with a Polynesian influence for Aquaman seems like an attempt to make use of the subconscious connection the general public have with regard to that culture and the sea.
It certainly doesn't seem like an intentional attempt to be more diverse for diversity's sake.
It certainly doesn't seem like an intentional attempt to be more diverse for diversity's sake.
Yeah they could, not that i ahve a dog in the fight
It is like the "Ironfist does kung fu so he must be asian" thing.
If anything, the Atlanteans being of Polynesian descent would make Arthur's blond hair even more offputting to them.
she wishes her supporting cast was as good as Arthur's. Sure, I'm down for Donna and Cassie and Hippolyta, but the rest of her crew is so damn neglected they may as well not exist.
It pains me to say this because you know Diana is my girl, but....
she wishes her supporting cast was as good as Arthur's. Sure, I'm down for Donna and Cassie and Hippolyta, but the rest of her crew is so damn neglected they may as well not exist.
Per the DC wiki, after one or the other of the crisis reboots they made it so his blond hair is how his mom's husband knew he was being cheated on, which is why he was left out to die and got raised by dolphins or whatever.
Edit: Or yeah, what gaf's only Aquaman fan said above.
Hey there's at least 2 of us XD
Union Carbine
Member
That's a much better argument for it than just diversity for diversity sake. It's really how it should be: this guy lives in the desert? Let's model him after people's who live in deserts. It makes sense.
There is Artemis........and I got nothing
But I just remembered that King Shark was a member of Superboy's squad for the minute
Arrowgigantic
Member
Based on the tagline, he should be a boycrazy Japanese teenage girl:
There is Artemis........and I got nothing
But I just remembered that King Shark was a member of Superboy's squad for the minute
Circe kinda counts and yeah thats about it.
- Status