1. Darkest Dungeon ; I loved the combat. I loved managing perks and diseases. I loved being an evil HR manager. Everything about this game is exactly what I was hoping for. Sorry to do this, but I don't play a lot of indie games and normally I would just gloss this thread over, but I picked Darkest Dungeon as my GOTY in the pinned GOTY thread, so I wouldn't be able to live with myself if I didn't give it a vote in this thread too.