I wont ramble off on a tangent but it is physically impossible.
What I will say though is that the simpler the game the easier it is to hit that marker. So as someone already said, Tetris, is technically perfect. It does everything it is supposed to be perfectly. No future game will be perfect.
I adore the original Broken Sword, play it at least once a year. Is it perfect? Hell no... doesn't matter though.
The only game that has come close to being perfect for me is The Witcher 3. It's not my absolute favourite game (that would go to Planescape Torment, Life is Strange or maybe What Remains of Edith Finch), but it is up there and it is the one where I have the hardest time finding flaws.
Diablo 3 in loot (after 800 patches)
Mario 64 in 3d platforming
Sonic 1 2d platformer physics based
Super mario world 2d platforming.
Destiny 2 (gunplay)
Zelda botw (open world exploring)
Minecraft (3d building)
Terraria (2d building)
Need for speed underground 2 (best arcade racer)
Breath of fire 2 (best jrpg)
Mario kart ds (best kart racing game)
Gta 5 (best complex open world)
Super hot (best vr game)
Tetris (best puzzle game)