I got this game as a gift for my birthday and have been playing it for the past days, and I gotta say...Its really not that bad. It doesn't have the same magic as previous titles, but the core game still feels like a Tony Hawk title, and I haven't experienced any glitches yet.
I think the games biggest fault was the graphics style, and some of the maps so far feel pretty void of life. But I was expecting much worse with what i saw online.
From what I saw of the game, the biggest offense was the loading/challenge selection method.
Original Tony Hawk games were very fast paced, with fun challenges that you could try, and then quickly retry if you failed.
Getting from lobby to challenge in THPS5 looked like such a laborious chore for next to no good reason and really turned me off the game.