-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Freddie Mercury is still the best rock vocalist
- Thread starter fluffydelusions
- Start date
MrS
Banned
Haven't you ever listened to Ten Years Gone, Please Read The Letter, Tangerine or The Rain Song? His voice is incredible and he can do delicate, he isn't just about 'wailing'. Plant has the Midas touch.
Just realised it's pointless trying to reason with you because you don't have a clue.
tekumseh
a mass of phermones, hormones and adrenaline just waiting to explode
Freddie Mercury had an absolutely beautiful voice. Axl Rose sounded like a car caught in the fan belt of a car when singing. Steve Perry from Journey would be my second choice.
A special note I would add about Queen. While Mercury is unparalleled, both Brian May and, particularly, Roger Taylor, had spectacular voices as well. I believe in terms of the greatest GROUP of vocalists, Queen was unrivaled as a band, and by a substantial margin...
A special note I would add about Queen. While Mercury is unparalleled, both Brian May and, particularly, Roger Taylor, had spectacular voices as well. I believe in terms of the greatest GROUP of vocalists, Queen was unrivaled as a band, and by a substantial margin...
Patrick Bateman
Member
Corey Taylor from Slipknot and Stone Sour has a range of 5.5. That always impresses me.
Mercury is still the king, though.
ManUnkindH
Member
He is the absolute king, yes.
Icedburden
Member
Hahahahahaha no.
Halford, Tate, dio, singer from steel heart. All contend, they just sing styles that suits their music.
dragonchild
Banned
Historically speaking Freddie's da best but, "is still"?
Um, you may want to be sitting down for this but Freddie ain't singing much these days.
Um, you may want to be sitting down for this but Freddie ain't singing much these days.
Insane Metal
Gold Member
LoL.
This has to be a joke.
GeordieMark
Member
HR is the frontman of Bad Brains and he is awesome.
ZedLeppelin006
Banned
I love Plant's vocals on Zeppelin's studio albums but he was pretty inconsistent live, especially in the mid 70's which was pretty jarring at times as Page, JPJ & Bonzo were incredible in a live setting.
That aside, I'm good with Mercury as the best vocalist in rock.
Little Monser
Banned
Kiiiiii
Well fuck. Nothing to discuss here really.
Bloodporne
Member
old manatee
Banned
I imagine his voice is a little creakier these days.
cpp_is_king
Member
You really don't know much about vocalists if you lol at Axl Rose being included
Hmm. That would be a very bold claim. I like Mike Mills as much as the next man, but his Beach Boys-esque voice doesn't really have the gravitas or variety Stipe's does.
BennyBlanco
aka IMurRIVAL69
yeah, the guy was amazing.
yeah props to mercury, cornell and I will give layne stalley a mention as he was siiick especially in his early years.
but cmon people, nobody... NOBODY in any rock band EVER can sing better than Mike Patton.
i'm not starting a joke, it's that easy... no evidence required.
I was waiting for Patton to pop up in this thread.
C
Contica
Unconfirmed Member
No one compares.
cpp_is_king
Member
Lane is easily my all time personal favorite from an aesthetic standpoint, but from a purely technical standpoint, Rose and Mercury are definitely ahead
BreezyLimbo
Banned
Resurgence
Buddy Queen has been in "Resurgence" for the past 30 years, then. Queen bypasses time at this point.
Patrick Bateman
Member
With that yodeling goat Thom Yorke? Get outta here..
Insane Metal
Gold Member
Axl Rose has never had a decent live performance. He's always been bad at it, worse nowadays.
Freddie though... I mean... there's no comparison here.
No one else comes close. Lennon has an iconic voice but not a patch of Freddie, McCartney comes way closer in terms of technique, power & range. Dylan - you've got to be kidding. Anyone mentioned Van Morrison? He's a phenomenal vocalist.
If you're throwing R&B heavyweights in the ring and looking at the bigger picture then for me Marvin Gaye (and maybe even Otis Reading beat Freddie.
And shout-out to Daryl Hall from Hall & Oates if you want to hear someone so pitch-perfect that they sound like an Autotuned vocal 20 year before it was invented.
If you're throwing R&B heavyweights in the ring and looking at the bigger picture then for me Marvin Gaye (and maybe even Otis Reading beat Freddie.
And shout-out to Daryl Hall from Hall & Oates if you want to hear someone so pitch-perfect that they sound like an Autotuned vocal 20 year before it was invented.
adamsappel
Member
Jim Morrison is not a good singer.
It's amazing in clips like these how young everyone in the front of the crowd is. Even into the '90s big arena rock act tickets were in the $20 range. Now all I see in the front rows are older people who can afford the $100's of dollars those seats command.
He forgot Neil Young and Jerry Garcia!
It seems like when judging a great vocalist, most of you are going by the American idol standard. I view it by how the singing has emotional weight behind it as well as how the singing fits the music being played.
John Lennon's vocals in the ending of Mother is a good example of what I mean.
Then you have people like Bob Dylan or Roger Waters. Many people consider them to have bad voices. It's true they don't have that American Idol voice, but that doesn't stop them from singing with passion. They never let their "bad" voices stop them from singing their emotions and complimenting the music being played.
Passion in a voice is far greater than hitting those high notes is all I'm trying to say. Don't get me wrong I think Freddy has a great voice. The vocalists I listed earlier just moved me in a way that no other singers have.
John Lennon's vocals in the ending of Mother is a good example of what I mean.
Then you have people like Bob Dylan or Roger Waters. Many people consider them to have bad voices. It's true they don't have that American Idol voice, but that doesn't stop them from singing with passion. They never let their "bad" voices stop them from singing their emotions and complimenting the music being played.
Passion in a voice is far greater than hitting those high notes is all I'm trying to say. Don't get me wrong I think Freddy has a great voice. The vocalists I listed earlier just moved me in a way that no other singers have.
Sir Abacus
Member
Not only is Freddie Mercury the best rock vocalist of all time, Queen have the best live performance of all time, Live Aid '85.
Suck on that, haters.
Suck on that, haters.
Jon Armdog
Member
I'm glad I didn't have to scroll very long to find Mike Patton. Mike Patton is your answer, OP.
C
Contica
Unconfirmed Member
Honestly, I'm so biased it's hard to say. It would be interesting to see these giants of rock being put head to head in a song competition with lesser known singers.
Patrick Bateman
Member
My parents saw Queen, MJ, Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin in each their prime live. I'm so envious..
Me too.
Can't believe some people are putting Thom fucking Yorke as a comparison to Freddie.
In terms of showmanship and range, Freddie is unmatched.
I love Cornell and Staley but it's Mercury.
Also Devin Townsend really is amazing in terms of range. He, like Freddie, could be an opera singer. If you've never heard him please take the time to listen to the opening of this live performance (the first verse). It made me a fan instantly.
I time stamped it but it may not work (on mobile)
In terms of showmanship and range, Freddie is unmatched.
I love Cornell and Staley but it's Mercury.
Also Devin Townsend really is amazing in terms of range. He, like Freddie, could be an opera singer. If you've never heard him please take the time to listen to the opening of this live performance (the first verse). It made me a fan instantly.
I time stamped it but it may not work (on mobile)
I don't have a favourite singer, but Freddie is most definitely up there.
Fantastic performer.
Also to see Plant be hated on by some is incredibly sad:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYnyVe2GKa0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LynX_3ve6BI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8ma1_gyXVE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YAtbROFfqU (The whole performance is brilliant, but the call and response at 5:00 in is insane)
He had a truly fantastic set of pipes.
Phenomenal singer.
Fantastic performer.
Also to see Plant be hated on by some is incredibly sad:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYnyVe2GKa0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LynX_3ve6BI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8ma1_gyXVE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YAtbROFfqU (The whole performance is brilliant, but the call and response at 5:00 in is insane)
He had a truly fantastic set of pipes.
Reid is far too under-appreciated.
Phenomenal singer.
I guess that's why many of his more recent performances sound like a GnR cover band with Mickey Mouse doing vocals