• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Jim Sterling: An industry that needs Xbox One DRM is a failed industry

Steam games get pirated like right when they get released. I don't have a problem with other companies adding more as long as it doesn't inconvenience me.

Day 0 piracy on the PC has been all but eliminated thanks to Steam. I think that was his point.

On the other hand, consoles still have tonnes of games pirated prior to the release date. 360 games are especially vulnerable to this. Publishers didn't give two shits either.
 
cliffyb1twosy.png


Bravo jim and joe!

Poor Cliffy.

How can he live knowing he only owns one Lamborghini. If they kill used games he could get at least 3.
 
Good read. That's pretty much what anyone who gets it has been saying. You can't force this on the consumers; if you can't survive without the DRM then the ends don't meet and it's over.
 

Hasney

Member
The moment he enters the ring to celebrate with Jack Tretton, he pulls out a Microsoft-branded sledgehammer and beats Tretton to death while giving the belt to Don Mattrick?

Oh god, now I can't get the image of Jim Sterling yelling 'THAT'S WHAT I DO' to Tretton ala Mark Henry out of my head.
 

Azull

Member
Holy balls Jim, you are on a roll. I found nothing I could disagree with here. I own a business myself and I don't expect the customers to bend over backwards just for me. They are the ones with the money last time I checked. Survival of the fittest as they say.
 

Kade

Member
Jim Sterling is a less annoying, well spoken and intelligent version of Angry Joe that doesn't rely on that shitty I'M A PISSED OFF GAMER SHIT FUCK BUTT POOP gimmick. I used to dislike the dude but he's done some really great work recently. You've got yourself a new fan.
 

Ghost

Chili Con Carnage!
Retail is the pointy spear on top of the broken market, its the biggest barrier to 'the little trees getting some light' MS didn't offer a fair deal and that's why its good that they backtracked, but it would have hastened the death of retail and been a quicker way to the exact change Jim wants.
 

LAA

Member
This was an incredible article, my respect for Jim skyrockets with articles like this. Brilliantly said Jim.

It just baffles me when he posted that he believed Modern Warfare 3 was innovative and Mario Kart 7 wasnt...
 

Bad7667

Member
Steam games get pirated like right when they get released. I don't have a problem with other companies adding more as long as it doesn't inconvenience me.

I think it is false to say it is about as protect from piracy as it can get.
I think what he was saying was the extra DRM adds nothing. It's no more lasting than the DRM Steam uses, and its no more harder to crack. Usually.

Games will always be pirated, and when there is a new DRM, it will be cracked. Adding 4 different types of DRM doesn't stop piracy.
 
It's been kind of weird being called "entitled" for a corporate decision I don't agree with, with corporate apologists spitting out the "businesses make money; deal with it" mantra as if it were an inherently noble thing. Companies really seem to think they're entitled to my cash without earning it, and when Bleszinski spits out what he spits out, I'm never certain how much of it is trolling and how much he believes in it, because rarely is there any substance behind it.

The funny thing is, as Sterling references, had Microsoft helped ease into a digital-only (or digital-heavy) platform with consumer enticement, rather than telling us to throw our discs out after 35+ years of cartridges and discs with vague ideas, I'd probably have an Xbox One order already.

I'd really like to think though that as this generation went on, people got wiser to this kind of stupid shit.
 
The past few months have definitely made me a fan of Sterling. Can't say I agree with his reviews still, but people are allowed their opinions. The dude knows what is up.
 

Wozman23

Member
Good read.

I've always thought the industry, like all great institutions, would eventually collapse in on itself. Thanks to the advancement of tech and popularity of gaming, AAA games have become incredibly expensive to make. With studio closure and all these strong-arm tactics, the event horizon seems incredibly close.

He makes a lot of good points as to why I love indie games and their developers. They don't often focus on making a blockbuster title. They just make awesomely fun games, at a fraction of the cost of their counterparts. They harken back to the early years of gaming.

That's the way to drive innovation and change, instead of watering every big game down to appease the masses.

And that's why I'm really excited for the PS4. While the PS3 had its struggles, these last couple years have been great for indies. It's still hard for them to be profitable, but putting them in the limelight in the coming generation may just set them up for success and trigger a massive shift in game development.

Plus, as Cerny has stated, the easy to design for architecture streamlines the process. If the AAA studios can increase efficiency, reduce development times, and cheapen the entire process, we could see a healthier industry where people aren't as harshly punished for taking risks.
 
When the crash happened after the Atari, Nintendo rose up and things were good again. If the industry crashes again, someone will rise to the occasion. There will always be demand for video games and someone will find a way to make profit from it.
 
Jim keep doing what you do, you're in the zone lately. This industry seems to have such contempt and disrespect for its audience they look for every opportunity to exploit, lie and scheme for profit. Gamers finally spoke up loud enough with the DRM thing and long needed change occurred.

Because Sony is a mega corporation I'm skeptical about how long this new down-to-earth, folksy PR and consumer first attitude is going to last, but at least it's step in the right direction.
 
Cliff trolling on Twitter nonstop makes it really hard to give him the respect he wants when he tries to write serious blog posts. He can't have it both ways.
 
Microsoft failed in their gambit of the prisoner's dilemma; they realized what they wanted to do with DRM would only work if the platform holders collude.

I honestly wish they had pushed ahead full speed. I wanted to see the results of going it alone against their customers.
 

GK86

Homeland Security Fail
That was a fantastic read. I agree with all of his points. I will definitely be reading more from him in the future.
 
Even if the very worst of dooms befalls the so-called "AAA" console industry, I'm not worried. If this past E3 of buzz words and brown games taught me anything, it's that old companies and shriveled executives need to be cut down to make way for new blood.

A friend of mine and I have been talking about this for awhile. Even some forest fires are done by nature itself. Let it burn so the something else could rise up.
 

Croyles

Member
I didn't know much about Jim until about a year ago, but he has been constantly hitting the nail on the head while I've been following him.

This guy is extremely smart, funny and pretty much right about everything throughout this whole DRM debacle.

Thank God for Jim, and thank Jim for God.
 

LQX

Member
Xbox One tried to leap to step five without doing steps one, two, three, and four. It wanted to rush us from physical media to digital media, without clearly communicating its goals, or producing a console that gave direct and tangible benefits to the consumer, or proving it could withstand the demands of a product so reliant on the Internet, or without even ensuring there was a big enough audience for it. You can ask Sony how well that worked with the PSPgo (it didn't work very well).

Beautiful.
 

Mononoke

Banned
Why did people ever hate him?

Sterling has a very.....abrasive persona. When he actually writes, or gets into his thesis/argument, he's pretty damn brilliant. One of the more articulate members of the gaming press. But his persona can rub people the wrong way. Also, Sterling's views on games have always been kind of extreme. For instance, he'll give Call of Duty a 10/10 because it's fun. But then he'll turn around and hammer a game that went for much more on an artistic level, because it failed to do what it achieved.

Not saying he's wrong for doing that, but it certainly would rub people the wrong way.

Anyways, I've always thought that Sterling's think pieces (his essays/videos) have always been brilliant. So his reviews never meant much to me, even if it would rile others up. But I feel that some thought of him as a troll, trying to get a rise out of the gaming community.

Honestly, Sterling has also grown a lot as a writer and a person in the last two years. And even he himself will admit that. So I have a feeling that the community will start to embrace him from now on.
 
Top Bottom