DangerMouse
Member
Nice job.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Nice job.
You won't have to pause to notice Black Crush I can assure you of that because my TV has an issue with this very thing and it is very noticeable in some games though I do my best to keep it to a minimal.
This shot, clearly favors the xbone. Someone please find a zoom in spot where the ps4 looks better
bigboss370
Member
X1. Most people have their sharpness turned up and the colors on there tv jacked too. Honestly.
RealityPales
Member
Oh wow. Beautiful.
Digital Foundry/Eurogamer. Click the compare tool, then click the zoomed in parts for each console/PC. They weren't very clear that you could click them and get bigger versions.
Brain of J
Banned
Hmmm, they seem pretty damn close to me (PS4 a bit better), and in any case MUCH closer than we were led to believe.
everyday math
Banned
The cloud(lol!) disappears in the Xbox version. :/
ChawlieTheFair
pip pip cheerio you slags!
Okay, whats up with the dude hair on the left, looks totally blurred out like a photoshop filter on ps4. It can't be the XO increased contrast doing that right?
DF really needs to redo the gamma and compare again, im in love with PS4, and whilst the jaggies are really awful on XO, the colors look much better to me.
Edit: Just saw the jackfrags comparison, DF doing their own tinkering?
Pseudo judo
Member
Why would you jump to this assumption? Because you're not happy with what your eyes are telling you?
Beer Monkey
Member
Fewer players, less-destructable environments, smaller levels?
Alright here we go.
Here is the Jack upload vs. the DF upload screens
Top is the DF video, you can see the crushed blacks
Bottom is the Jack upload, same scene you can see the difference in the wheel black
DF did it on purpose from what I see
Yea it's clearly darker in the df videos
NullPointer
Member
VFX_Veteran
Banned
There is more to a game's graphics than higher resolution. You either want the game to "look" good and compromise the resolution, or run it at a high resolution 60fps and have it look like PS3 games.
GoofsterStud
Member
Alright here we go.
Here is the Jack upload vs. the DF upload screens
Top is the DF video, you can see the crushed blacks
Bottom is the Jack upload, same scene you can see the difference in the wheel black
DF did it on purpose from what I see
I was right the calibrated one to pop out! While keeping the other washed out...
DF is a joke.
DirgeExtinction
Member
The XB1 version looks super sharp...a bit too sharp. It kinda looks too...artificial? Like MS was trying to make it look crisper(with their upscaler), but instead sharpened it to hell.
they dont look the same
UnluckyKate
Member
So... Xbox version has higher contrast because it hides jaggies and default better. Cheap trick... Whoever did this
Holy shit. Best shot so far.
FinalStageBoss
Banned
Seriously, the dark areas on the X1 version look downright awful.
PopcornMegaphone
Banned
I haven't read the thread, but I think the XB1 looks better. Weird.
haha damn..the water will cut you in the xbone version lol
lolol
Alright here we go.
Here is the Jack upload vs. the DF upload screens
Top is the DF video, you can see the crushed blacks
Bottom is the Jack upload, same scene you can see the difference in the wheel black
DF did it on purpose from what I see
That's a good comparison to show how the images are coming out differently with different people capturing them.
krypt0nian
Banned
Rough generation ahead if they are single console owners and are buying mutiplats. Resolution, missing lighting, jaggies from Hades, crushed blacks (unless DF is actually fucking up and trying to hide xbox flaws in the darkness).
I imagine we shall be hearing the Nintendo Credo about how graphics don't matter more and more here.
Ok finallymade it to a PC holy hell did my phone lie to me, the gif above shows every thing you need to know I can spot 5 things at a glance missing from the XOne version compared to it's identical PS4 counterpart
Holy crap, I've never seen a sharpening image filter like this before. It looks horrid.
Wow
Read the thread.
You can't be serious...
Welp those differences
GetemMa
Member
playing on PC. Looks fantastic.
From I can tell on the console versions, the Xbone looks oddly dim and the textures are using some sort of filter that is giving them an outlined look.
Resolution is noticeable. If the framerate is actually worse than the 900p PS4 version, well then holy shit, not that hard of a choice for console gamers now is it?
Framerate is king. Higher res is just clinches it.
From I can tell on the console versions, the Xbone looks oddly dim and the textures are using some sort of filter that is giving them an outlined look.
Resolution is noticeable. If the framerate is actually worse than the 900p PS4 version, well then holy shit, not that hard of a choice for console gamers now is it?
Framerate is king. Higher res is just clinches it.
ChiliManiac
Banned
GillianSeed79
Member
Okay, okay. I'm not a tech-head. I don't care which console is better. I can always get both. Why did the PS4 version look like someone jacked the brightness level up to 100 and it looked all, you know, foggy. Just as lay person who knows nothing about tech, the XO version looked better to me. I have a PS4 pre-ordered. I'm not blind. I honestly thought for a second, based on everything I've read the last few weeks, they mislabeled the images or something.
You'd think after the past three or four days the sky was falling for the Xbox One, but after seeing that where is this supposed Xbox One supposedly being permanently gimped or something? Someone explain that to me as a consumer? Is it just EA being EA siding with one console over the other is everything I have been reading the past week been complete bullshit?
You'd think after the past three or four days the sky was falling for the Xbox One, but after seeing that where is this supposed Xbox One supposedly being permanently gimped or something? Someone explain that to me as a consumer? Is it just EA being EA siding with one console over the other is everything I have been reading the past week been complete bullshit?
2 people looking at the exact same .gif. This is pointless everyone
All I want to know now (aside from the huge disparity in the DF and JF footage) is why the fuck the PS4 multiplayer was crashing, and why the X1 multiplayer wasn't shown at all. Both are concerning. Let's face it, just about no one gives a shit about the Campaign.
Idk why u guys keep saying microsoft microsoft, sony sony. When DICE developed the games.
You guys don't think they play these on the dev units or something, when they are making the games? They know.
Why don't u guys ask DICE why the xbox one looks so dark and why some shots of the xbone looks sharper, but yet ps4 has higher frame rate and resolution.
Also this is near final build is what digital foundry said, anything else is just small tweaks so they can still tweak it before launch.
You guys don't think they play these on the dev units or something, when they are making the games? They know.
Why don't u guys ask DICE why the xbox one looks so dark and why some shots of the xbone looks sharper, but yet ps4 has higher frame rate and resolution.
Also this is near final build is what digital foundry said, anything else is just small tweaks so they can still tweak it before launch.
this
Pseudo judo
Member
Please, for God sake, read the article that this comparison comes from and stop casting blame in ignorance.