Maybe because you have to zoom in on a still shot to notice? It just drives home the point that 1080p vs. 720p doesn't matter enough to really matter. This whole debate just drives home the point that resolution isn't as important as the feature set of your rendering engine.I'm wondering why there isn't any journalist that noticed the resolutions differences between the game and the capture.
Why didn't the reviewers question the weird visual similarity between Xbox One and PS4?
Who?
Polygon did. It went really well for them around here.
One reviewer did didn't they? lol
Why didn't the reviewers question the weird visual similarity between Xbox One and PS4? Because there's no way a 1080p video will look like 720p videoupscaled to 1080p
Who?
I thought it does. But if so, they should judge on what you see on an actual TV, not what is captured and shared to Facebook...
Even if the video is captured at 720p, the game should still internally be being rendered at 1080p, and thus not have the same level of aliasing. Or at least that's how I understand it.
Polygon did. It went really well for them around here.
Shit, I totally forget Polygon.I'll give you one guess what website questioned there being any real difference.
We'll just say that it's not so popular here.
I assume it is 1080p and there's a mistake somewhere. If not, why did so many sites say there's a difference?
Maybe because you have to zoom in on a still shot to notice? It just drives home the point that 1080p vs. 720p doesn't matter enough to really matter. This whole debate just drives home the point that resolution isn't as important as the feature set of your rendering engine.
In this image from the OP:
I MUCH prefer the XONE screenshot. It looks way better. Clearer, brighter ... the lighting looks better. It's just my opinion but I am suprised that the PS4 doesn't really 'pop' after all the hype.
Posted yet?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyeYnmad5VM&feature=c4-overview&list=UUizuJo-T9_NG926jVz3aTMA
He invites people to try and guess which version is which at one point. I certainly could not.
PS4 and XBO are both 720p upscaled to 1080p in those screens.I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
It wouldn't be the first time a reviewer has talked up a bullet point from the PR.IGN stated multiple times during their comparison that the ps4 was the clear winner graphically due to the higher resolution :/
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
You sit too close to your TV.I guess we'll find out Friday what the real deal is when I throw in my PS4 copy of Ghosts and will be able to tell instantly
I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
720p Native said:
1080p Scaled to 720p said:
720p Scaled to 1080p said:
1080p Native said:
*snip*
I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
I feel sorry for the general public who have even less clue of what's happening resolution wise [than GAF] and are at the mercy of company mouth pieces.
Interesting. The truth will be known very soon regardless. If it turns out that it's 720p in SP that would be very strange that he wouldn't know.
But did you honestly just take a cell phone screenshot of your computer? lol
Could the "Open" be pre-rendered? Cause I see the same aliasing on the building on the left in both screenshots.
I found some high bitrate png's uploaded by Sixthaxis from their PS4 vs Xbox One comparison:
http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2013/11/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-xbox-one-comparison-video/
Open PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-PS4.png
Open Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Open-X1.png
Stab PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-PS4.png
Stab Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Stab-X1.png
Drop PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-PS4.png
Drop Xbox One:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Drop-X1.png
Explosion PS4:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-PS4.png
Explosion Xbone:
http://ghosts-comparison.s3.amazonaws.com/Explosion-X1.png
Can someone analyse these PS4 screengrabs?
If both were same resolution, this is going to explode all over the faces of people who clearly could tell the difference of it.
It's obvious from these that the PS4 version is not native 1080p. No need to analyse.
Really?
...
Really?
Something is very wrong in all this. Never seen Quaz wrong once, but I suppose we shall see. IW would have to be dumb as could be if they think they could get away with it.
You sit too close to your TV.
In some of those comparison shots the Xbone version actually looks better.
In some of those comparison shots the Xbone version actually looks better.
WHOA... cool your jets people. I understand that we are very passionate about games but it seems like we're letting our passion override our judgement by expressing anger/frustration towards developers. I don't think they're intentionally trying to deceive anyone. At least I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Resolutiongate will take on a whole new meaning if this is true.
Because they played the multiplayer which is for sure 1080p, and saw the difference. Those who were playing the single player, presumably wouldn't be seeing any difference because there wouldn't be any if PS4 version is really 720p during single player.I assume it is 1080p and there's a mistake somewhere. If not, why did so many sites say there's a difference?
1080 down-sampled would look better but there is like no reason to do that.
Eurogamer - Day one patch makes Call of Duty: Ghosts single-player 1080p on PS4
New thread or already posted?
Gaf =/= America.
Europeans and other Gaffers probably would never know of Lucille Ball.