CassidyIzABeast
Member
Downgrade total. Preorder legit cancelled.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Uncharted 4 Trailer runs in-engine, in-game, in realtime on a single PS4 at 1080p60
- Thread starter viveks86
- Start date
- Status
platina
Member
uncompressed gameplay png vs a jpeg screenshot from the e3 2014 trailer from Frank Tzeng's portfolio.
There is visible hair dithering.
The gameplay shot is closer to the camera than the 2014 one. In theory it should have better iq but look at the hair, look at the micro details.
In regards to skin shading
Which honestly looks better and more realistic to you?
edit:
arm hair in reveal trailer:
So the scar got better? lol
OverBlood 3
Banned
Hahaha ^
Platina needs to join Drake for a nap.
Platina needs to join Drake for a nap.
Another terrible comparison.
Portugeezer
Member
Same lighting and camera angles. Great comparison.
I love it when trolling backfires. It's the same level of detail but with different lighting. Seems like they wanted him less wet for reason in the final too. People can't seem to discern the difference between creative changes and actuall detail removal. It's like those people that buy TVs in Best Buy because it's in torch mode and the sharpness it cranked up.
platina
Member
what does lighting have anything to do with hair dithering?
Portugeezer
Member
Do you have screens under similar lighting?
xenorevlis
Member
I personally think the release version looks better in terms of sub-surface scattering on the skin. In the OG one more detail is visible on his face but his skin looks more like drywall than human skin.
As for people thinking it was impossible for the reveal to be realtime at 60fps, the scene was 90% Drake by himself and some water and sand in a very dark scene. Absolutely doable, but the actual game also has a full environment and gives you gameplay control over Drake in the similar scene.\
We've already seen screenshots from cutscenes with the lighting and shaders looking as good or better than the reveal.
As for people thinking it was impossible for the reveal to be realtime at 60fps, the scene was 90% Drake by himself and some water and sand in a very dark scene. Absolutely doable, but the actual game also has a full environment and gives you gameplay control over Drake in the similar scene.\
We've already seen screenshots from cutscenes with the lighting and shaders looking as good or better than the reveal.
platina
Member
i only have the close up shot's from slasher.
CyberPunked
Member
I love reading the posts fr the first few pages of this thread. So it turned out, ND can't actually achieve the impossible.
OfTheOverflow
Member
Preorder cancelled x 1,000.
fluxanimator
Banned
Hair dithering?! Preorder cancelled.
hyped as fuck for this game
PLASTICA-MAN
Member
I hope ND this reading this thread after this "awesome" necrobump.
Uncharted looks incredible and is possibly one of the most stunning, if not the best looking title out there.
But FFS, at least acknowledge that people were misled here and actually believed that this was in game.
I've got some kid PM'ing me on another gaming site in complete denial about it all.
Ultimately, its not really a big deal because the game looks great but yeah, not like the e3 2014 teaser. That much is obvious.
But FFS, at least acknowledge that people were misled here and actually believed that this was in game.
I've got some kid PM'ing me on another gaming site in complete denial about it all.
Ultimately, its not really a big deal because the game looks great but yeah, not like the e3 2014 teaser. That much is obvious.
Tatsumi Oga
Banned
To me the E3 2014 pic is clearly better but holy crap, are we seriously doing this? We have a shitload of reviews saying this is the best looking game ever, one even said it's as if ND had access to next gen hardware already and the gameplay videos released so far look absolutely fabulous.
Plenty of games end up being slightly downgraded and if it happened here too, it really won't ruin your experience I'm sure. Personally I've always thought the first trailer looked too good to be true, but even then, judging by these pics they got it quite close.
Plenty of games end up being slightly downgraded and if it happened here too, it really won't ruin your experience I'm sure. Personally I've always thought the first trailer looked too good to be true, but even then, judging by these pics they got it quite close.
Yeesh.
Thing is though, I suspect the downgrade is actually because they're now using the same model in cutscenes as gameplay, when instead back then, they likely had a separate model for cutscene and gameplay, the former being the one showed off in the reveal snippet, which after all was a cutscene.
Lys Skygge
Member
I honestly think the skin looks better on the retail version. The hair does look a bit downgraded, and its still a shame about the framerate (perhaps NEO will fix it?) but overall it looks pretty damn close to reveal!
Insane Metal
Member
uncompressed gameplay png vs a jpeg screenshot from the e3 2014 trailer from Frank Tzeng's portfolio.
There is visible hair dithering.
The gameplay shot is closer to the camera than the 2014 one. In theory it should have better iq but look at the hair, look at the micro details.
In regards to skin shading
Which honestly looks better and more realistic to you?
We all know which one looks better:
See? I can do this too!
GravityInsanity
Member
uncompressed gameplay png vs a jpeg screenshot from the e3 2014 trailer from Frank Tzeng's portfolio.
There is visible hair dithering.
The gameplay shot is closer to the camera than the 2014 one. In theory it should have better iq but look at the hair, look at the micro details.
In regards to skin shading
Which honestly looks better and more realistic to you?
Darkangel
Member
The Naughty Gods must have really overestimated the PS4 considering the top pic was also at 60FPS.
Ricky Ricardo
Member
We all know which one looks better:
See? I can do this too!
I think you messed up somewhere, but I can't quite put my finger on it ...
WordsintheWater
Member
This one if the worst comparisons I've seen in a while. How the heck are you even comparing them? Makes no dang sense.
He should also stop posting pictures from a game that is not in many people's hands yet.
Necro900
Member
uncompressed gameplay png vs a jpeg screenshot from the e3 2014 trailer from Frank Tzeng's portfolio.
There is visible hair dithering.
The gameplay shot is closer to the camera than the 2014 one. In theory it should have better iq but look at the hair, look at the micro details.
In regards to skin shading
Which honestly looks better and more realistic to you?
edit:
arm hair in reveal trailer:
3rdamention
Member
This is a ridiculous bump,
Then he even has some back up "comparisons" ready.....weird stuff
Then he even has some back up "comparisons" ready.....weird stuff
PLASTICA-MAN
Member
You nailed it. PERIOD
Not saying they matched it, I don't think they did. But even in worse lighting, with worse highlights, no wet shader etc, the gameplay model (not cutscene like with the reveal) is still incredible.
It does look good, is this really the in game model?
PLASTICA-MAN
Member
Yes it is.
Also:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=202357543&postcount=4997
Also I don't know from the necrobumper got that pic with hair dithering in his post, the pics in that article were taken from SlasherJPC posts and they don't show any hair dithering.
Most definitely looks like in-game model to me. A pretty damn good one at that but in-game model no less. Playable CGI characters or bust now. We need to elevate.
1.21Gigawatts
Banned
If anything they overestimated their time budget.
What happened here is that they polished a short part of the game to have it running at 1080p 60FPS on Ps4 and later noticed that they don't have the time to optimize every last segment of the game to that level, so they decided on 30FPS.
Its neither a lie nor a downgrade, its just that they didn't have the ressources to make every part of the look and run as good as the teaser.
Not weird. Just someone prepared for a "fight".
Modern slang is baiting but I got a chuckle out of it.
WickedLaharl
Member
Lol it's not that serious and that goes to anyone getting bent out of shape over that users post.
OdysseusVA
Banned
Damn
That downgrade
That downgrade
- Status