Arhal_Katarn
Junior Member
Yea i decided against it a put a stupid poem up instead.
RumpledForeskin said:(thanks mash)
Yeah, the list is just a direct link to your post anyways.
Mike Works said:i've got a good idea for a story, but honest to god, i'm not sure if i can write it because it's so damn depressing
i've been working over the plot in my mind, and after like a minute of doing it, i just don't even want to think about it anymore
I'm not sure I get yours, but I can tell you this for sure. Change those to "have!" Those are key sentences, so you want to be sure they're right.RevenantKioku said:I should never had visited her.
I should never had left her.
D'oh, I had 'have' before but then changed them for some reason. THE TIME IS NOT RIPE FOR GRAMMAR.Cyan said:I'm not sure I get yours, but I can tell you this for sure. Change those to "have!" Those are key sentences, so you want to be sure they're right.
{Mike} said:Guilty Pleasure
Heh, I can imagine. It was hard to keep from posting an immediate reaction to that myself.LunaClover said:edit- sorry, that was initial reaction.
This is the final day for submissions. Voting starts tomorrow and goes for a few days, and the new challenge will start shortly thereafter.Davedough said:Thanks everyone for the positive words and constructive criticism. I know I have some work to do to tailor my writing style, but I wanted to at least try something.
Great stories throughout everyone. I really like some of them and cant wait for another round of this. Isn't voting today?
You've heard me complain about disclaimers at the beginning, so I won't do that again here. I will note, though, that it was really interesting to read the rationale for some of your choices, as well as the follow-up post on lessons learned. Still, I think you would have been better served putting the disclaimer stuff in your follow-up. And of course, some of us are unfamiliar with the specifics of the bit of Roman history you cover (at least, I sure am!), so the disclaimer is lost on us anyway.ronito said:Gratus and Claudius
Disclaimers bad. Rawr.Mash said:Sotto Voce
Very good criticism. You're right about taking too long. Like I said I in my lessons learned I was married to my idea too soon. I got stuck on the idea of telling how Claudius came to power and it didn't really add too much. While it would've been important in a full fledged story it didn't really work. Thanks again for the criticism.Cyan said:You've heard me complain about disclaimers at the beginning, so I won't do that again here. I will note, though, that it was really interesting to read the rationale for some of your choices, as well as the follow-up post on lessons learned. Still, I think you would have been better served putting the disclaimer stuff in your follow-up. And of course, some of us are unfamiliar with the specifics of the bit of Roman history you cover (at least, I sure am!), so the disclaimer is lost on us anyway.
More specific criticism: the first person present works fine, at least the way you use it here. What doesn't quite work is the change between tenses--it's a bit jarring. When you go from the narration of past events to the present, it feels a bit awkward. My other main criticism is the exposition at the beginning. It takes a long time before we get to the meat of the story--what's happening right now. You might consider doing the whole thing in first person past tense, and having scene changes to get between events. Of course that could turn out awkward too; it's hard to say.
I like the voice of the character and his stoicism--the whole "brother" thing really works. And I like the opening and closing coming full circle. Good story overall.
thanx. the abruptness is my style, i switch very quickly. the italics in parts are another stylistic choice...i started writing by writing memoirs. and i'd describe things...like a drink, or a jamaican bartender's dreadlocks, very abruptly with one word sentences. sometimes in italics for extra emphasis. it has become a part of my style.ronito said:nitewulf: I like this story of momentary redemption. At first the disjointedness got to me but I got used to it. I really like it nonetheless. The only think I didn't get was the italics didn't seem to add much. In the end I know that it was about him getting over the ice cream girl, but part of me wonders if his victory was a pyrric one, as he is still a bit of a sattelite.
Sure thing. And likewise.ronito said:Thanks again for the criticism.
An interesting and unusual choice. I applaud you for that. I like the concept. But like ronito, I'm left wanting more. Maybe this is because you give us the end, and a tiny bit of the beginning, but not the middle of the journey. Maybe a bit more description is what is needed--what's it like to travel through nebulae and dust clouds, to blaze a path between alien suns of blue and red, to be bent off course by a black hole, to nearly impact on and be absorbed by an asteroid? Just a thought.Solaros said:From Birth to Death
I like it. I dig your writing style. I particularly like the line about losing the friend, and the closing line about the CD. The first for it's resonance, the second because it was a great closer. However, the story feels very slightly off--I can't put my finger on why (the italicized fruit?). I'd like to give more useful feedback than that, but I really can't. :/nitewulf said:Contentment, a la Zen
I might follow ronito's lead a bit later, and comment on my own. Later.Cyan said:Old Ma Meg
Iceman? Icemaaaaaaaaaaan!Iceman said:I'm working on a terrific story that I'll be sure to marr by Sunday evening.
Based on a true story!nitewulf said:revenant - you will have to explain this one. i was trying hard to get it but couldnt follow. good intro and conclusion.
I... don't get it.RevenantKioku said:The Jumbled Heap of Thoughts and Freshly Made Scrap Metal
You're right--this was a bit messy, particularly compared to your tightly written previous entries. It was still interesting and clever though. The setting was too Matrix-y for my taste, although the feeling was completely different.Aaron said:Up Above is Where the Devil Dwells
Yikes. Just going for pure shock value?{Mike} said:Guilty Pleasure
I like the subtlety of this one. Still, could definitely use some fleshing out. Why did he leave his home? What sort of dreams of the "other side" did he have? What was his home like? These things are all very vague, which gives the story a sort of generic feel. Or maybe he doesn't remember the answers to these questions--how does that make him feel? Asking these sorts of questions would really strengthen this piece.John Dunbar said:Dinghy
A nice take on the theme. The transformation doesn't quite feel justified--I think you would've needed more words to really do it justice--and too much of the story is taken up in exposition. But it's nicely done. I do like the beginning and end coming full circle. Oh, also I'm not sure what "my ruthless plight to be happy" means. I think I know what you intended, but "plight" isn't the right word.Scribble said:
First Step, Mother
Ouch. Ice cold. An odd style, but it was interesting to see something different. My only complaint was being unable to tell who was speaking at the beginning--only towards the end do they develop different voices.Oldschoolgamer said:Memories and Delusions of a Deranged Lover
You know, I like this one, but it just feels too easy! He doesn't really do anything to help himself, and he doesn't say anything particularly interesting to the woman. I dunno... I guess I just want to see more challenge for the main character.Speschal K said:The Writer
So awesome. Love the metaphors and imagery--"an octupus's worth of flailing arms" "headlights... scattered them like cockroaches." Great. My only criticism is that the voice is slightly inconsistent--mostly it feels like a tight third person viewpoint (i.e. Daniel narrating), but in one or two spots, it kind of breaks from that as words are used that Daniel probably wouldn't use (e.g. "the boy" in a couple places).DumbNameD said:Along the Rails
Great idea, but the execution is lacking. With the viewpoint switches and the kind of similar names, it quickly confused me. I had to go back and reread bits several times just to figure out what was going on.Azih said:The Case
Very nice. And I'm glad I actually got this one, unlike the Luc story. :lolMike Works said:Ruby Lake
No worries, there's a day and a half yet. A lot of people will come in and vote at the last second. Anyway, I think a pattern in the voting has established that will probably continue.Davedough said:Instead of editing my post, I should have just replied to bump this back up to the top so people can see this thread and remember voting is almost up.
Davedough said:Mike Works: Good story, but the ending confused me. I may be a dolt, but am I correct in assuming she was using the green bag to do something horrible to her daughter, or was she just grabbing it out of comfort?