• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Anyone else read The Lost City of Z by David Grann?

Status
Not open for further replies.
The-lost-city-z.jpg

The Lost City of Z: A Tale of Deadly Obsession in the Amazon (2009) is a non-fiction book by American author David Grann. It tells the story of the legendary British explorer Percy Fawcett who, in 1925, disappeared with his son in the Amazon while looking for an ancient lost city. For decades, explorers and scientists have tried to find evidence of his party and the Lost City of Z. Perhaps as many as 100 people perished or disappeared searching for Fawcett over the years.

Bought the book late last year and made some headway till I couldn't stand reading on a Phone. So I started reading today after getting my Kindle. I've really enjoyed the book a lot so far (despite the gap in when reading the book). I'm up the part where Fawcett has just finished his map surveying commission in South America (which I think is Chapter 8 or 9).
 
Fantastic book, and I landed up reading parts of it to my (then) 3 year old son at bed time.

The Amazon is a terrifying place.
 
puck1337 said:
Fantastic book, and I landed up reading parts of it to my (then) 3 year old son at bed time.

The Amazon is a terrifying place.
Especially if even before you've read the book you have a ton of Italian Cannibal movies in the back of your head (inaccuracies notwithstanding).
 
I just PMed this to Manos, but thought I'd bump the thread just the same to drum up more interest:

I read The Lost City of Z cover to cover. I thought it was great. A good biography distills what makes a singular person so singular, and for Fawcett I got a very strong sense of what that was--an unusually strong constitution; a slight antisocial tendency; reverence for nature and "natural" (conveyed too in his love for "Indians" and their culture).

The portion near the end of the book where the author catalogues the graveyard of people chasing after Fawcett and meeting doom was very shocking. The author's journey was less exciting, although the way the book pivoted naturally from biography to ethnographic/anthropological study was great.

I had already been familiar with some of the advanced development in the Central/South American area from a nonfiction book I read around 10-15 years ago called the "Ancient Sun Kingdoms of the Americas".

I have only two quibbles:
- When the author introduces the idea that Fawcett may have become a quack occultist, it is dealt with very very quickly and in no detail at all. Given the exhaustiveness of his research, he was clearly equipped to deal with this subject in greater detail. If the remainder of the author's biography omitted this info intentionally in order to give a more inspirational portrait of Fawcett, that would be doing a disservice to the truth.

- The index/notes are so long that I was only 70% of the way through according to my Kindle when the book ended, so I got caught off guard. The book's ending is by necessity kind of abrupt, but the ending combined with there being no indication I was near the end was unfortunate.

Thanks for the recommendation all that time ago.
 
I read a really long excerpt of it (or maybe it was an essay that turned into the book?) and felt like I got enough from that.

I'll try to find what I'm talking about.

EDIT: here it is, a 21 page (!) New Yorker article from 2005

I just skimmed the piece. It covers the back third of the book fairly well, but the bulk of the book is a life and career spanning biography of Fawcett. It's actually the part of the book I liked the best. So if you felt like you had enough of Z and the author's search for Fawcett, but wanted to know more about Fawcett as a younger man, I'd really advise the book.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom