• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

45 Toronto officers facing charges over actions in 2010 G20 summit.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Divvy

Canadians burned my passport
gDrOD.jpg


http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2012/05/17/g20-officers-discipline.html


Not quoting the whole article, but here are some choice bits:

Misconduct charges are expected against 45 Toronto police officers involved in the G20 summit two years ago, including five senior officers, one of them the commander who gave the notorious order to "kettle" protesters.

The report says some of the responsibility for detaining several hundred people for four hours in the rain goes all the way to the top, to Toronto police Chief Bill Blair and Deputy Chief Tony Warr, though it falls short of mandating charges against them.

But the report says operational responsibility lies with Supt. Mark Fenton, one of two Toronto officers who served as "incident commanders" during the G20 and had control of officers in streets. He is expected to face two charges.

Fenton's order to keep the group of protesters, bystanders and even some journalists boxed in at Queen Street West and Spadina Avenue "in a severe rain storm that included thunder and lightning was unreasonable, unnecessary and unlawful," according to the document. It violated the detainees' constitutional right against arbitrary detention and was negligent, the 276-page report says

The charges under the Police Services Act are not criminal and amount to internal discipline, which can result in docking of pay to outright dismissal. None of the out-of-town police officers brought in to help Toronto police was charged.

OIPRD director Gerry McNeilly says that following those instructions the Major Incident Command Centre (MICC) structure broke down, as the night incident commander (Fenton) launched an "autocratic" and "dysfunctional" crackdown ordering mass arrests of protesters.

Some front-line officers, according to McNeilly, ultimately disregarded Fenton’s orders at the kettling and let some people out of the ring of riot squad officers, including those with medical emergencies. He noted records of one officer stating of Fenton, "He’s maniacal this MICC, he's maniacal."

In addition, criminal charges were laid against two Toronto constables by Ontario's Special Investigations Unit, which probes serious injuries or deaths involving police.

The SIU charged Const. Babak Andalib-Goortani with assault with a weapon in connection with an incident at Queen's Park in which protester Adam Nobody suffered a broken cheekbone in a violent takedown captured on video. He faces a second count of assault with a weapon stemming from another incident at the same protest in which a woman was hit with a baton.

And Const. Glenn Weddell stands accused of assault causing bodily harm after 30-year-old Dorian Barton's arm was broken while he was photographing police during a protest.
 
Are all 45 specifically Toronto officers, or does that include cops they brought in from around the country for the G20? If they're all from TPS, any charges coming in from the outsourced officers?

But yeah, G20 was out of control and we should have learned from previous G20s that having it downtown in a city like Toronto was a poor idea. But Harper doesn't give two shits about the city.

Those holding cells on the east end are nightmarish when people talked about them. My blood sugar would probably kill me if I were stuck with mustard and bread for 24 hours. Scary.
 
Are all 45 specifically Toronto officers, or does that include cops they brought in from around the country for the G20?

But yeah, G20 was out of control and we should have learned from previous G20s that having it downtown in a city like Toronto was a poor idea. But Harper doesn't give two shits about the city.

Those holding cells on the east end are nightmarish when people talked about them. My blood sugar would probably kill me if I were stuck with mustard and bread for 24 hours. Scary.

They are all Toronto officers. And yeah, what they did was asinine, and I'm pretty sure a lot of officers are getting away with what they did because it was not caught on camera.
 
Good! That was an atrocious over-reaction to a bunch of mostly harmless protestors. I was riding my bike through the downtown and there were always more cops standing around than protestors. It was over-kill all the way and the police attempt to justify there massive presence backfired.

Thing is I think the police won't be convicted and if they do it will be minor. The charge is supposed to make the citizens happy but the lack of punishment will serve the cops as well.
 
Good on you Canada, we shouldn't ignore the issue of bad police conduct.

It does only take the Toronto Police Department to task though. The OPP/RCMP/etc are left off the hook for their actions for the moment. Step in the right direction I suppose, but small one.
 
Wasn't the general consensus on GAF at the time "don't protest you stupid hippies (and journalists and residents)/those people are wanna-be-rioters anyway"?
 
Wasn't the general consensus on GAF at the time "don't protest you stupid hippies (and journalists and residents)/those people are wanna-be-rioters anyway"?

I don't think so. I think most people were just shocked at what happened from both sides.
 
thanks. I remember getting into an argument about the G20 security set up with a cop who posts on here and it got ugly.

edit: rereading that thread, it seems that poster was arguing against the army being used because they werent trained for riot control like the police.
 
Boogie? He does certainly post from a certain perspective, but I appreciate some insight from his side of things.
 
Honestly the whole G20 meeting should have never happened in the busiest few streets of the largest city in the country.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom