Let me know what roles you intend to use and I can help iron out any potential problems.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
GAF Mafia/Werewolf |OT| A forum game of secrets and treachery - sign up to play!
Let me know what roles you intend to use and I can help iron out any potential problems.
God damn @ the Cthulu game.
OK, starting to put together ONUW 3. Sorian, you in? You know, since you aren't doing anything?
I think we're going to run the same setup as last game for this one. I see where I messed up the Doppelganger, so I want to do it right before I add more craziness.
OK, starting to put together ONUW 3. Sorian, you in? You know, since you aren't doing anything?
I think we're going to run the same setup as last game for this one. I see where I messed up the Doppelganger, so I want to do it right before I add more craziness.
Hyperactivity
Banned
cthulhu driving me nuts just watching, can't imagine what it is like for the players right now
It's too bad all the games filled up. Wish you could have joined us. Maybe next season.
Yeah, it's ok though. Crab said I get to be right at the top of the list for next season so that's pretty cool!
Lord of Castamere
Member
I still don't understand why we started with 2 less players. I get that Traube disrespected Crab when he requested more players than the other games, but removing 2 more hurt us more than Traube.
Crab is cold blooded. ):
Crab is cold blooded. ):
You were even quite high on the priority list as a new player! I guess the same thing happened to you now as what happened to me last season: I was on top of the replacement list for a month, but I kept getting skipped for some reason. Something similar would have probably happened here too, crab just sucks at using lists!
ONUW Game Three has Begun!
Roles have been generated for the current players and will be sent out shortly. Night phase will end in 24 hours.
Roles have been generated for the current players and will be sent out shortly. Night phase will end in 24 hours.
Spoiled Milk
Banned
Darryl is DDOSing gaf so that I have a hard time contributing to the thread.
It's the only explanation.
It's the only explanation.
Hey there Kristoffer! I was really looking forward to playing with you, but alas, it was not to be
Spoiled Milk
Banned
It's okay. Some other game! Your death will be avenged, I swear it.Hey there Kristoffer! I was really looking forward to playing with you, but alas, it was not to be
Lord of Castamere
Member
): I wish CzarTim had made it in our game. Maybe another super active player will emerge next season.
Not every game can have an active player, you guys just got unlucky.
Yeah, I mean, you're on day 3 already and the thread only has 4 pages. Kind of underwhelming.
Blargonaut
Banned
Aren't you still alive in Archer?
No, you'll just erase everyone in the dead thread too XD
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
you fool
darryl was being super sleuth agency like
now see what you have done
all that planning. all that secret missions. all for naught.
FOOL.
You're just jealous
Of our
Unmatched
Skills in the
Ultimate game of mafia with
Cool people
Kangaroo.
nailed it
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
oh well. cant expect much from a happy corgi
i wants a dogs-breed mafia
the cats are the mafia
german shepherd is cop
st bernard is doctor
corgi is traitor. therefore haly is automatically sent to the pound on D1
i wants a dogs-breed mafia
the cats are the mafia
german shepherd is cop
st bernard is doctor
corgi is traitor. therefore haly is automatically sent to the pound on D1
At best, it's a cheap tactic to give a flimsy position the illusion of credibility. It's like a crazy person insisting that they got married because they carved two initials and a heart in a tree last week. If anything, this type of bullshit is the last thing that should be trusted.
Worst of all, it's borderline cheating and against the spirit of the game. I wont overstep gamerunner boundaries and scold people directly, but I'll complain about it here.
I'm just an observer but I notice that tactic was used by Palmer in SW and nobody raises any complain there.
In fact, I think it's an ingenious maneuver, it made raindoc trusts him and lead them to victory.
Wa-wait I wanted to sign up too
. Missed it because was sleeping because it was night.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
I agree. Like, what's the point? The odds are basically just as even town will find it as they are mafia will. In fact, if *only* mafia find it and don't tell anyone, it is even worse than if you hadn't said anything at all. I don't think it is cheating or anything, I just think it sucks as a strategy.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Sorry for the short notice, but I'm moving today. If I'm not back by the next day phase replace me. I should be back, but I'm not sure.
I agree that codes are stupid, but you're talking about an active game in the recruitment thread, I don't think you should be making comments like the bolded.
It applies to almost every game of Mafia we've had on GAF, and it's not necessarily characteristic of any alignment.
The general problem I see is that there are players who seem wired to look for ways to 'break' the rules, find loopholes, be sneaky, etc. As a game runner, I'm wary of people who break the game, or play it in a way that is against what I think the spirit of the game is. Not that I'm trying to condemn or shame anyone - I believe there might be a natural difference between people who see rules as "these are the only things you are allowed to do" VS those who see rules as "you can do anything except for these things". The latter is probably going to try to get away with a lot of things that the gamerunners perhaps didn't think of covering the bases for.
I do believe that it's important to let players be creative in how they problem-solve, and make the rules flexible enough to support that. I think every game runner has given that opportunity, but maybe in varying amounts. However, I think stuff like breadcrumbing and encrypted messages is against the basic tenet of Mafia/Werewolf - all the daytime, "Main Thread" talk should be public and able to be weighed. Encoding messages is a deliberate attempt to subvert that.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Still. Put a lid on it.
Blargonaut
Banned
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
I just want to set the record straight:
That was my idea.
That was my idea.
What's going on?
The "Erased from existence" bit.
Which game did that happen in? I must have missed it. A part of me is glad I got to watch some games before actually participating. I think it would have been tough for my first time.
I assume because Crab helps with the rules as our Mafia lord and this was a very unusual rule