• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Half of Trump Voters Would be Okay if He Shot a Random Person on Fifth Avenue

It's a horrifying thought: A man walks down to Fifth Avenue in Manhattan—a bustling street full of New Yorkers and tourists alike—and fires a round at a passer-by.

But in the eyes of many American voters, as long as the shooter was President Donald Trump, that act would be just fine. At least that's what the findings indicate in a new poll released Tuesday by Public Policy Polling, a company that does polling for public surveys as well as for Democratic candidates.

The survey results hark back to a now-infamous claim Trump made on the campaign trail last January, when he raised his hand like a gun and said he could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and his supporters would still love him.

He made the boast during an Iowa rally: "My people are so smart. And you know what else they say about my people, the polls? They say I have the most loyal people. Did you ever see that? Where I could stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot somebody and I wouldn't lose any voters, OK? It's like incredible."

Public Policy Polling put that claim to the test, and it mostly held up. Forty-five percent of Trump voters said they would approve of the president shooting someone on Fifth Avenue, while just 29 percent disapproved. Twenty-six percent, somehow, were unsure about their thoughts about whether it would be OK for Trump to shoot a random person on the street.

Pretty predictably, 90 percent of Hillary Clinton voters said they disapproved of the president shooting someone. But, perhaps surprisingly, 17 percent of those who voted for Independent candidate Gary Johnson approved of Trump shooting someone, according to Public Policy Polling.

More Republicans (which presumably includes some #NeverTrumpers) approved of Trump shooting someone than disapproved. Forty-two percent approved, 34 percent disapproved, and 25 percent weren't sure.

Overall, when asked the question "If Donald Trump shot someone on Fifth Avenue, would you approve or disapprove of the job he's doing as president?," 22 percent of voters approved and 62 percent disapproved.

Public Policy Polling summed up the results: "Trump's right about one thing, though—he could shoot someone in the middle of Fifth Avenue and not lose most of his support."

The poll surveyed 836 registered voters from July 14 through July 17. It had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.4 percentage points.

It's worth noting, however, that while a portion of Trump voters might be fanatical in their devotion to the president, his overall support across the country is extremely low. The weighted average from data-focused website FiveThirtyEight pegged his approval rating at just 38.7 percent Tuesday. As Trump approaches the six-month mark, that's the lowest-ever approval figure for a president at this point in his tenure.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-voters-republicans-overall-actually-200200054.html

This comes after a poll showing that over half of Trump voters don't believe that Trump Jr. met with the Russians...even though he admitted he did and showed the emails detailing the time before the meeting. So, Hillary was absolutely right about the basket of deplorables, except 1) half was probably too low of a number and 2) while correct, it was still dumb to attack the voters and rile them up (just ask Romney about his "47 percent" comment and how that worked out).

What do we do about this? This is a huge chunk of our country that would defend Trump even if he killed an innocent person, and they would probably chant, "something something fake news," "something something, It's Clinton and Obama's fault," and "something something CNN!" when confronted on their President killing someone for sport.
 

RPGCrazied

Member
And this is why Hillary never should have apologized for that deplorable comment. There are people out there that just can't be helped.

Basically trash.
 

Toth

Member
The question is misleading because it's not asking whether he is right to shoot someone. rather his role as the president is being questioned .
 

Brandon F

Well congratulations! You got yourself caught!
This isn't at all likely. We all know Trump would fumble and end up shooting his own foot instead.
 

Jakten

Member
Lotta people support Duterte too, turns out America isn't as immune to this stuff as we imagined.

My girlfriend used to play Overwatch with a guy from Canada whose family loves Duterte and think hes just the most hilarious guy ever. So neither is Canada!
 

DarkKyo

Member
What do we do about this?

Sit back and watch the sun set on our civilization? I don't know what there is to do. The people that govern us helped mold these warped perspectives that ultimately just endanger the safety of normal, caring people. Unless there's some way to get these monsters out and change what type of discourse our leaders engage in, there's no way out. The head of the country spreads this cancer daily and there's no built-in mechanism in our laws to get him out when most of the government right now still supports his garbage.
 

Malreyn

Member
"To just be grossly generalistic, you can put half of Trump supporters into what I call the 'basket of deplorables."
 
If Donald Trump shot someone on Fifth Avenue, would you approve or disapprove of the job he's doing as president?

Possibly due to a poorly worded question? Would the shooting be his attempt at fulfilling his Presidential duties? Also, how would you take this question seriously if someone called and asked you this?
 
The kind of person who strongly supports Donald Trump is the same kind of person who thinks these questions are hilarious and dumb and would answer yes just to get this headline.
 

ringlord

Member
"If Donald Trump shot someone on Fifth Avenue, would you approve or disapprove of the job he's doing as president?"

One could imagine that he had a reason to shoot. Since the reason is not specified as "random", like the story purports.

Trump Supporter mindset: "He probably had a reason to shoot the person. Maybe it was an illegal trying to commit a crime! Yeah! MAGA!"
 

DonShula

Member
This isn't at all likely. We all know Trump would fumble and end up shooting his own foot instead.

Trump: [shoots self in foot]

Media: The president has shot himself in the foot.

White House: The president has never shot himself in the foot and talking about feet is a distraction when we should be focusing on health care.

Trump: I MEANT TO SHOOT MYSELF IN THE FOOT.

White House: Shooting yourself in the foot isn't illegal.

Media: Shooting yourself in the foot is illegal in New York City.

White House: The Clinton Foundation has been around a lot of feet and yet the media never questions this.
 

Yoshi

Headmaster of Console Warrior Jugendstrafanstalt
An additional 25% weren't sure? Must be a really difficult question.

I wonder how this poll would go in Germany, replacing Trump with Merkel. Also, do democrats approve of Trump shooting people at random as well?
 
"If Donald Trump shot someone on Fifth Avenue, would you approve or disapprove of the job he's doing as president?"

I think they worded it to get as many "yes" as possible. Like, what does him shooting someone on fifth avenue have to do with the job he's doing as President?
 

AlStrong

Member
hm.

KBcenEF.jpg
 
Trump: [shoots self in foot]

Media: The president has shot himself in the foot.

White House: The president has never shot himself in the foot and talking about feet is a distraction when we should be focusing on health care.

Trump: I MEANT TO SHOOT MYSELF IN THE FOOT.

White House: Shooting yourself in the foot isn't illegal.

Media: Shooting yourself in the foot is illegal in New York City.

White House: The Clinton Foundation has been around a lot of feet and yet the media never questions this.

bowdown.gif
bowdown.gif
bowdown.gif
 

Plywood

NeoGAF's smiling token!
Trump: [shoots self in foot]

Media: The president has shot himself in the foot.

White House: The president has never shot himself in the foot and talking about feet is a distraction when we should be focusing on health care.

Trump: I MEANT TO SHOOT MYSELF IN THE FOOT.

White House: Shooting yourself in the foot isn't illegal.

Media: Shooting yourself in the foot is illegal in New York City.

White House: The Clinton Foundation has been around a lot of feet and yet the media never questions this.
Are you from the future?
 

subrock

Member
The same 20-25% of people show up in surveys all the time. Basically any survey conducting in the US will have 1 in 5 claiming something crazy.
 
As has been said a billion times before, people view it as a sport. They don't give a fuck about anything other than the fact their team won the big game. Just about nothing will change that.
 
Top Bottom