• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

FaceApp apparently now has race filters. I never got the humor in these.

Two Words

Member
is it wrong to say that most black people have big noses. and most south east asians have no crease in their eyelids? or women generally have long hair and wear makeup?

oh yeah it is. Damn. It was fun while it lasted
Notice how you said "black people" but said "South East Asians". Why not make a similar distinction for black people? If you don't know that distinction, either look it up or avoid spanning that trait to black people as a whole.
 

wandering

Banned
is it wrong to say that most black people have big noses. and most south east asians have no crease in their eyelids? or women generally have long hair and wear makeup?

oh yeah it is. Damn. It was fun while it lasted

Well, considering that the majority of South East Asians and around half of East Asians generally do have double eyelids... yeah, it is.
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
Update: Goncharov just emailed Engadget with the following: "The new controversial filters will be removed in the next few hours."

From the article in OP.

Oh.
Everyone hurry and make all the celebrities all of the races!
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
Notice how you said "black people" but said "South East Asians". Why not make a similar distinction for black people? If you don't know that distinction, either look it up or avoid spanning that trait to black people as a whole.
Thank you for this post.

Seriously Faceapp is the Theon Greyjoy of digital editing apps.
 

Myriadis

Member
Huh, the indian version is almost 100% identical to the original, while the causican is pretty different. A little bit surprised since none of my relatives are of indian heritage.
 
no-fun-allowed.jpg
 

ponpo

( ≖‿≖)
Thank god it was pulled. Divine retribution for praising any form of Lightning.

Devs knew they did something wrong.
 

conpfreak

Member
I admit that some of these results are fascinating and amusing, but who the fuck approved this? There are really no people of color in positions of power at the devs to allow this to happen.
 

Fuchsdh

Member
Holy shit, this one is good.

God damn.

Yeah thus far this is by far the best. The way it successfully changes to the darker skin tone but manages to not turn the skin highlights into a mess at the same time is some nifty wizardry in particular. At this resolution they could definitely all be real people.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
man, people are too easily offended.
The people offended by the idea that not all minorities look the same or have the same features and thus, it's probably a really stupid move to have a feature in an app that implies the opposite are indeed too easily offended.
 
From a cultural standpoint, it could be insensitive, but it actually has some convincing results so far in this thread.

So far, I'm struck with how all the filters and the original show someone who is clearly a unique individual shared between the 4 shots, just with existing features modified slightly. Hopefully it communicates to others how we're all human and that even becoming a different race, you'd still appear be you. Hopefully it bridges that lack of understanding that exists between races.

Except that Trump one. That guy can't be human, so it's no wonder the filters don't work.
 
I dont think the versions presented were too racially insensitive but the potential for abuse was far too high with this sort of thing so I understand pulling it before things got out of hand
 

Kalentan

Member
So how did this work? Was there some sort of photoshop program that ran off of looking for points on a face or did it look for similar looking faces and then apply those faces on top?
 

MUnited83

For you.
Huh, the indian version is almost 100% identical to the original, while the causican is pretty different. A little bit surprised since none of my relatives are of indian heritage.

Yeah, indian me looks more like me (white), than me with the white filter applied.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
keanureaveswhat.jpeg
They pulled it as a result of backlash, people should do more thinking about why that backlash occurred in the first place. Not all minorities have the exact same features so to have a "black filter" makes no sense. It only serves to perpetuate stereotypes. So if someone has an issue with them pulling a stupid feature due to the backlash then those people need more perspective instead of saying "nofunallowed" as if digital blackface is supposed to be fun. Rather, it's better to acknowledge why people had a problem with it in a first place.
 

Orbis

Member
Is it because people were already abusing it and being racist?
There were a lot of complaints basically. Like I said earlier in the thread I didn't see anything wrong with it initially but I will have to admit defeat on this one. Makes me feel a bit of an idiot as I like to think I'm usually on the good side of these debates, but now I just feel like I've participated in racism by supporting it.

I think they probably made the right decision pulling it in the end.
 
It's OK to admit that you were having fun with something that's also problematic. You don't have to pretend it's not problematic

That said can someone please do Selena Gomez I need it for a thing
 
Top Bottom