• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

From a Million Miles Away, NASA Camera Shows Moon Crossing Face of Earth

Status
Not open for further replies.
But it doesn't look like it moves in this gif. From left to right it's the same look as if moving a flat coin from left to right on a table.

The distance the moon actually is from the Earth, this is a sliver of it's horizontal movement. Like 3 degrees or smaller.

Remember the moon is 238,900 miles away from the Earth, so imagine the moon traveling another 30 earth-widths in each direction.
 

Ziffles

Member
But it doesn't look like it moves in this gif. From left to right it's the same look as if moving a flat coin from left to right on a table.

It's a five hour time lapse, and with that camera angle of view you're not going to see much moon rotation.
 

jediyoshi

Member
bUmRKfr.gif
 

Bold One

Member
so odd, the earth from the surface of the moon looks far away, if youre familiar with the iconic Earth-rise image
 
That looks fake. It might be an optical illusion but the Moon looks too close to Earth.

Telephoto lens effect. The camera is a million miles away.

Also, what is the green edge on the leading edge of the Moon:-

From the article "Combining three images taken about 30 seconds apart as the moon moves produces a slight but noticeable camera artifact on the right side of the moon. Because the moon has moved in relation to the Earth between the time the first (red) and last (green) exposures were made, a thin green offset appears on the right side of the moon when the three exposures are combined. This natural lunar movement also produces a slight red and blue offset on the left side of the moon in these unaltered images."
 
That looks fake. It might be an optical illusion but the Moon looks too close to Earth.

Also, what is the green edge on the leading edge of the Moon:-

That's the green channel overlapping the edge of the Moon. The natural color image was built up using different exposures taken close together :

EPIC’s “natural color” images of Earth are generated by combining three separate monochrome exposures taken by the camera in quick succession. EPIC takes a series of 10 images using different narrowband spectral filters -- from ultraviolet to near infrared -- to produce a variety of science products. The red, green and blue channel images are used in these color images.

Its a result of imperfectly matching up the exposures.

The moon looks close because this is an image from a million miles away taken with a 30cm telescope.

Why would it even be fake anyway? If you believe that the images of the Earth from this satellite are real and if you believe that the moon is real then its inevitable that the moon at times passes between the satellite and the earth. What would be the need to fake it?
 

Ziffles

Member
Good point, why??? is it a camera setting like Field of View or something....

0A2C232A-1E73-497D-BBC990D98F9AD53B.jpg

Yep, like it was said earlier, it's all about perspective and camera angle. Here's my rough Space Engine simulation of earthrise:
earthrise.jpg


and here's my rough approximation of the DSCOVR image:
DSCOVR.jpg


Note the extremely narrow camera angle in the bottom right, and the distance indicated from earth.
 

Kysen

Member
It looks close but cant you fit like every other planet in the solar system in the gap between earth and the moon?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom