My answer really depends on whether or not this sequel could be kept safe from modern gaming bullshit.
Yes, I'd like a sequel if they were left to their own devices to make something beautiful with infinite budget, all the time they needed, and no pressure from Sony.
No if they tried to implement monetization, DLC, or multiplayer. Or tried to rEiNvEnT the original.
But like even in a perfect world, do we really need to revisit SoTC? It was such a wonderful story/experience, maybe we should just leave it be.