Windom Earle
Member
lol, so much anger
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry vs GTAV on XONE - performance analysis
- Thread starter mocoworm
- Start date
lol, so much anger
Not needs to be a God spec machine to beat xone messed design. Time to accept this thing. Xone can't handle 1080p like the ps4, because ps4 it's more optimized compared to the xone. MS hardware had half the rops, almost half of bandwith and bottleneck esram. There is not black magic which works here.Don't think even that 10 % of overheated cpu will solve something because it doesn't.
Blame MS to spend their money in the kinect bullshit, when they can easily beat the ps4 specs if they wanted, just spending the tons of more money they have compared to Sony, working in a better hardware. It's not the PS4 fans the real enemies here, looks better. Sorry for the ot.
That's pretty significant.
Ok yea, so either the PS4 and XB1 versions have the same general foliage density, just placed differently(possible, but maybe not likely) or the XB1 version still has a fair bit of foliage density, just not as much as PS4 version. Which would make sense.
Thanks.
Warriors.
Makes sense DF got the XBO version - it runs fine and looks good, seems to be 'parity' - get the goods news out the door, then tomorrow do a proper comparison which highlights the things missing from the XBO version and the damage is already done.
Looking like Black Flag day one patch all over again...these comparisons are a double edged sword - we want them ASAP so we can make our purchasing descions, but with patches giving upgrades (or better versions being held back a little as in this case) the 'analsyis' is pointless.
Looking like Black Flag day one patch all over again...these comparisons are a double edged sword - we want them ASAP so we can make our purchasing descions, but with patches giving upgrades (or better versions being held back a little as in this case) the 'analsyis' is pointless.
Windom Earle
Member
DF picked up the XBO version themselves, it seems they did not receive review copies.
Lol, are we supposed to appreciate someone posting an out-of-context benchmark chart then?
psn
Member
Explain me, how much out of context was it?
Miles Quaritch
Member
TheAdmiester
Member
Good grief,
What's wrong with the second one?
Hopefully the PS4 version will be good too.
Are you saying they don't because they do.
Are you saying they don't because they do.
Vroadstar
Member
Ouch...
MilkyJoe
Member
I dunno if people have seen this yet, but it's PS4 Xbox One sid e by side... Make up your own minds graphics wise
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5GVTwWTaGs
Performance we're going to have to wait on DF
Nothing imho. Different lighting condition.
Windom Earle
Member
Let's start with not throwing a hissy fit over "Sony fans". That benchmark seems legit, but I would prefer to talk about GTA here.
lol
justsomeguy
Member
TheAdmiester
Member
Exactly what I thought. Franklin's shadow is gone in the Xbox picture because he's in a shadow already, nothing else stands out.
Bigger install base, makes sense.
PS4 has subtitles? Definite edition.
Well, that's expected. At least for me.Good grief,
All PS4 users on GAF? Yes, makes sense.
funkystudent
Member
Looks like the XB1 might have a lower quality motion blur as well?
I guess some sacrifices had to be made to get to resolution parity. If they are cutting back on stuff like foliage, motion blur and I wouldnt be shocked if alpha effects take a knock as well. That was always the PS3 stuff that got toned down.
Also its hard to get a exact comparison because of how dynamic weather and stuff is but is there a HDR difference between the 2 as well? I swear the XB1 version looks a little different lighting tone wise from the trailers and PS4 footage but maybe the footage I see is just captured weirdly.
Holy crap that's a big difference.
Keep up with the good fight lol.
smh
Watch the whole video. It's just a shitty recording and motion blur is all over the place on both systems.
Huh? Roughly twice as many people have PS4's than have XBO, obviously they're not all on GAF, but proportionately that difference would still be present.
Nope because in the PS4 screen the tree is cut out of the camera
Difficult to tell what's happening in the second comparison, there seems to be a different lighting condition and either the capture was not good on the XB1 or there's motion blur in the scene and the XB1 has a more rough type of it. Honestly I wouldn't read too much in the second comparison at this point.
The difference in foliage/grass density seems confirmed instead.
Miles Quaritch
Member
My bad, that was supposed to be another shot of the foliage.
Here's a webm instead,
http://a.pomf.se/rahkwc.webm
OsirisBlack
Banned
The games do seem to be pretty much the same outside of the PS4 having more foliage which seems about right given the gpu differences. As others have said its just the RDR situation from last gen just reversed.
In the past page you suspected it was the 360 version. Now it's miniscule? Well, ok.
Kazuma Kiryu
Member
Well, that's....quite the difference.
lol, where's a mod to give the man a new title!?
ambar_hitman
Member
I can confirm that PS4 version has better grass. Those mountains are also more grassier.
However, there are quite a few FPS drops on PS4 when huge architecture is in your view, initial loading stutter kinda thing. Not sure if same on Xbone.
Cornbread78
Member
If DF has to buy the game why wouldn't they buy bought?
He should be juniored if anything.
He should be juniored if anything.
I think just the idea to give some money to sony give them some stomachache. But MS is more like a sexy lady. You can't resist.
That's not the same place on the road. The XBox One screen-shot is nearer to the crossroads.
maybe it was bought for them...
Miles Quaritch
Member
We can laugh about the lack of grass, but that shit was brought up non-stop when it was an issue in RDR PS3.
Pretty sure it was the verge of becoming a meme at one point too...
Pretty sure it was the verge of becoming a meme at one point too...
I just love this useless speculation. Thanks for the laughs.
MilkyJoe
Member
Going to have to wait for the DF to see if that is true, if so not sure it is worth the double dip on Xbone
CrowdChant
Member
I bought the Xbone version to play with friends. We all immediately regretted it once we saw the grass. We all wanted to play "Hide in the Grass" so we could pop up and scare each other. With this significant lack of grass, we can't do it. This was a waste of $59.99 plus tax.
Fuck this shitty, shitty, grassless game. Thanks for nothing Rockstar. Next time fucking add more grass. I've already asked for a refund for my digital purchase on the basis of low grass density.
Grand Theft Auto? More like GRASS Theft Auto.
Fuck this shitty, shitty, grassless game. Thanks for nothing Rockstar. Next time fucking add more grass. I've already asked for a refund for my digital purchase on the basis of low grass density.
Grand Theft Auto? More like GRASS Theft Auto.
geordiemp
Member
I would expect Ps4 to look better but Xb1 to stream better when new assets are added is just my guess.
It's not the Xbox One version, it's obviously the Xbox 360 version! The difference is minuscule!
While the performance gap between the XBO vs PS4 is real, this also shows how benchmarks are largely useless without context.
Similar threads
- Locked