Boss Doggie said:

would you consider Movie V Kirk a different Kirk altogether?

Click to expand...

I haven't watched V in a while, but Kirk, Spock and McCoy were about the only people who were still the same as before. Scotty was way too over the top, and Uhura... best just to forget about it.

Jellico was a great officer but a bad captain, strolling into a delicate situation like commander douchebag and stomping his shit down without any care to those he was upsetting. Not a good way to inspire loyalty and support from his crew. He got it done but only because the situation was dealt with before those around him had got the chance to mutiny.

dalin80 said:

Jellico was a great officer but a bad captain, strolling into a delicate situation like commander douchebag and stomping his shit down without any care to those he was upsetting. Not a good way to inspire loyalty and support from his crew. He got it done but only because the situation was dealt with before those around him had got the chance to mutiny.

Click to expand...

That's precisely why he acted that way though. He actually said he didn't have time for that kind of stuff with the cardassian situation. Jellico did a fantastic job for what he had to do. There was zero pride too, went straight to riker when he knew that would give the mission a better chance of success.

The Adder said:

From worst to best:

Early Archer
Movie Picard
Janeway
Late Archer
NuKirk
Kirk
TV Picard
Spock
Sisko

Click to expand...

Jump tos kirk above sisko and that's pretty much my list.

even in his last ever appearance in the dreadful Generations he still stole the show:

"Don't let them promote you. Don't let them transfer you. Don't let them do anything that takes you off the bridge of that ship because while you're there, you can make a difference."