I'm especially looking for things that are just spooky or scary, and not straight-up horror or downright terrifying (unless they're a bit out of place in an otherwise unscary game).
As an example,
This is Snacker the Shark from Banjo-Kazooie.
As a child I played this game thinking it was a whimsical adventure. But it's also quite scary in parts. Mad Monster Mansion, Gruntilda's taunting rhymes...the bizarre and terrifying Game Over cinematic...these are all frightful, but none compare to that feeling when you're swimming along for the first time in Treasure Trove Cove and the music changes (I think! It's been a while) and starts getting all forebording and Snacker moseys on up to take a bite.
Okay, have at it!
As an example,
This is Snacker the Shark from Banjo-Kazooie.
As a child I played this game thinking it was a whimsical adventure. But it's also quite scary in parts. Mad Monster Mansion, Gruntilda's taunting rhymes...the bizarre and terrifying Game Over cinematic...these are all frightful, but none compare to that feeling when you're swimming along for the first time in Treasure Trove Cove and the music changes (I think! It's been a while) and starts getting all forebording and Snacker moseys on up to take a bite.
Okay, have at it!