That's odd, Josh was really excited for the game when it was revealed, I wonder what happened. From what I've seen the game looks to be better than DKCR in every way (except loading times).
He might actually really like the game but he never shows it.
Most of what I have seen is him nitpick the music.
Opinions are opinions but when everyone is gushing over David Wise(me personally, I am not a blind David Wise fanboy), he makes a point to take jabs at the music.
Genuine or not, he seems to like to create waves.
It's just my sense of him: just like an opinion, it's neither right nor wrong.
(however, liking the music in Returns and being in the minority in that regard, I guess you could say I strongly disagree that the music in that game is better than this game's---this soundtrack seems to add a ton more)