• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Guillermo del Toro confirms he will not be collaborating with Kojima on Silent Hills

Alebrije

Member
Meanwhile at 2016 :

lWHtb.png
 

Avatar1

Member
Wondering how many people going "Fuck Konami" are going to be throwing money their way when MGS comes out. Regardless of whats happening this might be their big cash out on AAA titles.

y5GKqwU.gif

The best way to support Kojima in my opinion is to buy MGS5, make it a success, then not buy the next Metal Gear (if there is one) and it tanks.
 
This Is the biggest god damn gaming travesty I've ever seen. It's so rough being a silent hill fan.

First they get our hopes so fucking high with P.T. and now they throw it all in the garbage like a dirty jizz tissue.

Fuck you Konami. Fuck you right to hell.
 

Toparaman

Banned

Perfect reaction.

Wondering how many people going "Fuck Konami" are going to be throwing money their way when MGS comes out. Regardless of whats happening this might be their big cash out on AAA titles.

y5GKqwU.gif

For me it depends on whether or not Kojima (or anyone else from KojiPro) sees any royalties from the game's sales. For all we know he may not even be receiving all that high a salary, since most of his income might just come from sales.
 

NIGHT-

Member
P.T. My favorite thing about this gen so far. It was just a huge surprise out of nowhere. Being a huge silent hill fan it just woke up some excitement in me that I haven't felt in many years. This is just sucks :/
 

Sn4ke_911

If I ever post something in Japanese which I don't understand, please BAN me.
Question: Can i add P.T. to my PSN account without having a PS4 or do i need the console for that?
 
Question: Can i add P.T. to my PSN account without having a PS4 or do i need the console for that?

Yes you can, log in to the ps store in a web browser and add it to your cart. So far, we don't know if after the date they'll remove the game from the psn or also from the server lists...
 

Sn4ke_911

If I ever post something in Japanese which I don't understand, please BAN me.
Yes you can, log in to the ps store in a web browser and add it to your cart. So far, we don't know if after the date they'll remove the game from the psn or also from the server lists...

Ok, thanks.
 
Yes you can, log in to the ps store in a web browser and add it to your cart. So far, we know that after the date they'll remove the game from the psn, but we don't know if they mean also from the server lists....
 
I actually wouldn't mind a Sony funded, Kojima del Toro developed PT that ditched the Silent Hills name. Just come up with a new name for PT. Or don't, keep it mysterious.
 
Has anyone tweeted Adam Boyes or anyone at Sony to hire Kojima, Del Toro, Reedus and the team to make Not-Silent-Hills?

If this project is really dead, there's no reason they can't just go and make their own game, right?

Well, anything to resurrect what can potentially be a really good horror game.
 

Sn4ke_911

If I ever post something in Japanese which I don't understand, please BAN me.
Even if you have it you need to install it on a PS4 because it will not be in your account when it's removed.

Ah goddamnit, so that means i have to buy a PS4 before wednesday or i'll forever miss out on it...
 

impact

Banned
yup, team siren. They're working on gravity rush 2

Such a waste of their talents

I know VitaGAF likes it because they've not got much else to like, but man that game completely pales in comparison to even Siren. New Siren on PS4 in non-episodic format would be pretty sweet.
 
Does anyone know if Sony could take over Silent Hills? I'm not really knowledgeable about how buying IPs work. I know it's just a dream but could Silent Hills still happen?
 

TriAceJP

Member
silent-5.jpg

silentHillDownpourLogoBanner001.jpeg

Silent-Hill-Book-of-Memories-banner.jpg

silent-hill-banner.jpg

silent-hill-rev-3d-banner.jpg


THIS IS PERFECTLY FINE?!


Because the first three don't exist, right?

My point is that they CAN make a good game without them. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have seen what Del Toro and Kojima could have whipped up. However, Kojima is not the end-all game director and there have been times in the past where games were made without Hideo Kojima, heavens forbid.
 

Easy_D

never left the stone age
A lot of work just for a PR stunt. I rather trust my magic 8 ball instead.

It's kinda weird how there's this gigantic bubble of suspended disbelief surrounding anything regarding Kojima.
There should be studies made on this phenomenon (If there are, someone please point them out, I'd love to read about it).

I wonder if it's the same thing as the "Elvis/Tupac isn't dead" stuff that just won't die.
It's all a ruse, it's all a ruse! Maybe it's just not wanting to let go of nice things, I guess.

If this has to die, I'd at least want another entry by Climax Studios. They did good their second time with Shattered Memories, didn't try to ape Silent hill 2, no "LOL PYRAMID HEAD IS HERE BECAUSE WE KNOW HE'S COOL AND A FAN FAVOURITE!".
 
Because the first three don't exist, right?

My point is that they CAN make a good game without them. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have seen what Del Toro and Kojima could have whipped up. However, Kojima is not the end-all game director and there have been times in the past where games were made without Hideo Kojima, heavens forbid.

But Team Silent made the first three.
Then they got disbanded.
My point is, since their disbanding, Silent Hill has NOT gotten along fine without them and KojiPro, Del Toro and Reedus were the best hope the franchise had, now it's gone.
 
Because the first three don't exist, right?

My point is that they CAN make a good game without them. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have seen what Del Toro and Kojima could have whipped up. However, Kojima is not the end-all game director and there have been times in the past where games were made without Hideo Kojima, heavens forbid.

Could you please point us to this dream team you have, where they can save the I.P. Remember that the first 3 games where made by Team Silent before they left and P.T was good because of Del Toro & Kojima. So who is left for the task at Konami? The guys that make PES?
 

TriAceJP

Member
But Team Silent made the first three.
Then they got disbanded.
My point is, since their disbanding, Silent Hill has NOT gotten along fine without them and KojiPro, Del Toro and Reedus were the best hope the franchise had, now it's gone.

I suppose I don't hold those three people anywhere near as important as the rest of GAF.

And Reedus? I don't get how he contributes in the positive light at all.
 

TriAceJP

Member
Could you please point us to this dream team you have, where they can save the I.P. Remember that the first 3 games where made by Team Silent before they left and P.T was good because of Del Toro & Kojima. So who is left for the task at Konami? The guys that make PES?

If MGS 4 and Ground Zeroes were a stamp of 'quality storytelling' and 'fun game design', I'm glad this has been cancelled. Those games were junk.
 

VladTepes

Banned
I suppose I don't hold those three people anywhere near as important as the rest of GAF.

And Reedus? I don't get how he contributes in the positive light at all.

Reedus is positive in that he's very famous right now and his face on the game almost guarantees it'll be a financial success, incase Del Toro and Kojima weren't enough.
 
D

Deleted member 80556

Unconfirmed Member
Ground Zeroes junk? I know it wasn't long and all, but it was pretty good for what it was.

And MGS4 did win GOTY here at GAF twice for a reason. Beats me what reason.
 

TyrantII

Member
Because the first three don't exist, right?

My point is that they CAN make a good game without them. Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have seen what Del Toro and Kojima could have whipped up. However, Kojima is not the end-all game director and there have been times in the past where games were made without Hideo Kojima, heavens forbid.

Given the vastness of space and time there's a world out there with flying pigs. That doesn't mean you'll ever see them in your lifetime.

Silent Hill 3 was released 12 years ago. The series peaked with 2, even longer ago. Sure they could, but this is konami we are talking about. The same people that screwed up their HD remaster and lost their archival code for one of their biggest franchises and had to use buggy alpha code and reverse engineering to put out a half assed product.
 

TriAceJP

Member
Reedus is positive in that he's very famous right now and his face on the game almost guarantees it'll be a success, incase Del Toro and Kojima weren't enough.

Throw in a 'hot topic' star to get attention over great gameplay? I... Don't see the importance.
 

TriAceJP

Member
Ground Zeroes junk? I know it wasn't long and all, but it was pretty good for what it was.

And MGS4 did win GOTY here at GAF twice for a reason. Beats me what reason.

Because GAF picks nothing but gold. If I haven't seen several topics in the past about how people disagreed with the GAF GOTY, especially the MGS4 win, I'd take it more seriously. The game was a tech marvel and gorgeous to look at, but that was pretty much it. It took back the MGS franchise considerably.

This is of course IMO so take it as you will.


Sorry for the lack of quote but I'm on mobile, but in regards to the comment if Silent Hill 3 being released 12 years ago, it's better to let some things die that pilfer their corpse again and again.
 
Top Bottom