• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Is it inevitable that Pokemon Gold, Silver & Crystal will come to the 3DS e-Shop

Dimmle

Member
Pichu was a mistake.

image.php
 

L95

Member
I love Crystal, I haven't touched my copy, but the save worked last year lol. Kinda afraid to check....
 

Kinsei

Banned
At this point they're the only games you can't take your Pokemon from and then transfer them to Sun and Moon. I think it's inevitable that they'll be put up. Probably early next year.
 

NOLA_Gaffer

Banned
With Gold & Silver's in-game clock, how would that function with the 3DS VC's suspend feature?

If you stop playing at 10pm one night and pick the game back up at 2PM the next day, won't the in-game clock still say 10pm from the night before?
 

Chastten

Banned
I wouldn't mind, but I'd prefer them making HeartGold/SoulSilver/Diamond/Pearl compatible with Pokémon Bank.

HG/SS > G/S any day of the week and I actually have hundreds of pokemon in there that I can't transfer to 3DS.
 

Mr-Joker

Banned
I hope it does but I doubt that it will be release for the 3DS virtual console and probably be released for the NX.

With Gold & Silver's in-game clock, how would that function with the 3DS VC's suspend feature?

If you stop playing at 10pm one night and pick the game back up at 2PM the next day, won't the in-game clock still say 10pm from the night before?

They disabled the suspend feature for the gen 1 games, so they will likely do the same again.
 

Andrefpvs

Member
Technically speaking, couldn't one use the DS remakes to catch the Gold and Silver Pokémon and trade them to the latest version?

Yes, absolutely. But I don't think anyone is counting on the VC releases to help complete their Pokédex. I just think it's amazing that we'll soon be able to restore the broken link between the first generation(s, hopefuly), and the latest one.
 

Adaren

Member
I made my mom drive me to Target at 7 AM so that I could get Gold Version before school.

I was pretty hyped.
 

Nanashrew

Banned
I hope so. Game Freak and TPC now have even more people breathing down their necks in anticipation for the rest of the games to hit VC after finally releasing RBY after so many years of telling people no.
 

Neoxon

Junior Member
I hope so. Game Freak and TPC now have even more people breathing down their necks in anticipation for the rest of the games to hit VC after finally releasing RBY after so many years of telling people no.
But depending on how quickly they can get the games on VC, they may want to wait until the NX Platform to do the VC ports.
 

El Sabroso

Member
I remember reading somewhere how Nintendo apparently didn't want to re-release the old games because they were supposed to be meant for the platforms they were originally released in. But suddenly, money pours out! Hahahahaha!

I could count on this. Then RSE on NX VC. And so on.

that was said for mobile, you are getting it wrong
 

OmegaFax

Member
It'd be interesting to see how they approach Crystal. Since they went out of their way to include WiFi adhoc play in place of the GB Link cable for R/B/Y, would they go the extra step to include Crystal's original online feature?

Mobile_Adapter_unit.png
 
I'd hope so, I loved Gen 2. Never played Crystal either, it'd be perfect. Especially if they make it S/M compatible.

That said, I'd really hope they have improved Poke Bank features which allows access to R/B/Y Pokemon and the capacity to evolve them. Having to get another 3DS is one thing, but digital only games with Nintendo's shitty account structure is a whole other issue.
 

Thud

Member
When I owned all versions yes.

Crystal is so good. Seems silly now, but pokemon actually moved.
 

Melter

Member
I vividly remember when I bought Pokemon Silver. I remember thinking how vivid the colors in the forest and grass were. I played Pokemon yellow prior which was also in color but Silver was on another level. I was blown away. Also those chip tunes
 

Rob2K19

Member
I remember playing Silver and I had just got surf. I was surfing everywhere. Then I remembered that I got surf in the home town. So when i did it, I noticed that it was a long stretch of water, then I saw a fat guy on the bottom of the screen then went over to him. As soon as I got out the water, he jumped up and ran to me. After reading what he said, I thought I broke the game. I got so scared I turned off the game. It wasn't until I found out later when my friends told me I could actually go to Kanto.

I've never seen an anniversary this active.

A new generation, a rerelease of the first generation, and their big new mobile game.

Every long lasting IP should be treated like this.

Yu-Gi-Oh!: A new 20th anniversary movie, which is a sequel to the original manga. Arc-V combining every summoning method and then some. A rerelease of Yugi and Kaiba's(?) decks. New Black(Dark) Magician and BlueEyes cards and support. More new cards for Yugi and Kaiba's deck. New YGO games being released on PC, 3DS, and mobile(?) this year.
The only difference is that Pokemon has maintained it's popularity worldwide. Lol
 
You mean the "let's say that every game that has Luigi suddenly celebrates his anniversary" year?

Luigi's Mansion 2, New Super Luigi U, and Dr. Luigi all have Luigi as the main character.

Luigi is clearly the most prominent character in Mario & Luigi: Dream Team.

Super Mario 3D World included "Luigi Bros." as an unlockable.

SM3DW and Captain Toad had hidden Luigi sprites as Easter Eggs.

Nintendo released limited edition Luigi-themed 3DS systems, a Year of Luigi soundtrack CD, and a Year of Luigi golden coin.



How much more more should they have done for you to acknowledge it as a celebration?
 

Pokemaniac

Member
I wouldn't expect it to happen on 3DS. The Gen I Pokemon games are the only 3DS VC games that have released in the past year or two. They were a special anniversary release for an otherwise dead service.

Will probably happen on NX, though.
 

_h8bit

Banned
I hope this comes to pass. It's nice to play these old titles without having to worry about cracking open an old cart to replace the battery.
 

Velcro Fly

Member
i never really wanted to play the old games again

and then i played pokemon red for like 15 hours over the weekend and it was amazing

and now i suddenly would buy the gen 2 games too

it would be a cool thing to do and they'd make a decent amount from it but i'm not sure they will do it.
 
I wouldn't mind, but I'd prefer them making HeartGold/SoulSilver/Diamond/Pearl compatible with Pokémon Bank.

HG/SS > G/S any day of the week and I actually have hundreds of pokemon in there that I can't transfer to 3DS.

Why not? Not directly, but of course it's possible through normal means. All of my Soul Silver pokemon currently reside in Y after taking a trip through Black 2. Skipped that gen? Maybe you can borrow someone elses game for a little while to get it done?
 

ash_ag

Member
It'd be interesting to see how they approach Crystal. Since they went out of their way to include WiFi adhoc play in place of the GB Link cable for R/B/Y, would they go the extra step to include Crystal's original online feature?

Mobile_Adapter_unit.png

Even if they don't implement the online features (which they probably won't), including some of the PCC downloadable events either pre-loaded or via patches would be gold. They are largely undocumented, and many things remain a mystery to this day.

For example, Kurt's time-travelling granddaughter Chieko handing the GS Ball to the player isn't exactly a widely known event. :p
 

entremet

Member
They should as I see people playing the ROMs of these all the time on their smartphones during my commute.

Make the available legitimately.
 
I vividly remember when I bought Pokemon Silver. I remember thinking how vivid the colors in the forest and grass were. I played Pokemon yellow prior which was also in color but Silver was on another level. I was blown away. Also those chip tunes

Pokemon yellow mostly used a very slightly modified Super Game boy palette, which was limited to 16 colors. Gbc could display way more. Still never made sense to be that the gbc couldn't make use of existing supergb colors.
 

Pokemaniac

Member
Pokemon yellow mostly used a very slightly modified Super Game boy palette, which was limited to 16 colors. Gbc could display way more. Still never made sense to be that the gbc couldn't make use of existing supergb colors.

It's probably a complex technical thing. The implementation most likely relied on some sort of special API or registers provided by the Super Game Boy software/hardware. The key part is that the implementation of the colors themselves was likely outside the code from the Game Boy games themselves (or if it wasn't, was specific to the Super Game Boy hardware). Since the Game Boy line completely lacked an OS, as was typical for gaming hardware of the time, there was no "system" code running after the boot screen, and thus, nowhere to implement the special colors in software. Any implementation would have to be directly in hardware, and even that potentially could have messed things up depending on if Super Game Boy features were an all or nothing thing, since some of those things would be literally impossible to run on a Game Boy Color. Even if it was possible to just do the colors, you're adding stuff to the silicon, which is a non-trivial investment.

tl;dr: There was probably nowhere practical to slot in an implementation.
 

FyreWulff

Member
It's probably a complex technical thing. The implementation most likely relied on some sort of special API or registers provided by the Super Game Boy software/hardware. The key part is that the implementation of the colors themselves was likely outside the code from the Game Boy games themselves (or if it wasn't, was specific to the Super Game Boy hardware). Since the Game Boy line completely lacked an OS, as was typical for gaming hardware of the time, there was no "system" code running after the boot screen, and thus, nowhere to implement the special colors in software. Any implementation would have to be directly in hardware, and even that potentially could have messed things up depending on if Super Game Boy features were an all or nothing thing, since some of those things would be literally impossible to run on a Game Boy Color. Even if it was possible to just do the colors, you're adding stuff to the silicon, which is a non-trivial investment.

tl;dr: There was probably nowhere practical to slot in an implementation.

That's a pretty spot on take I'd agree with. Super Game Boy functionality depended on a lot of SNES specific features which games would expect - if the GBC identified itself to the game as a SGB, the game would expect more than potentially the color functionality. And developers still had the option to ship OG GB games at the same time Color was a thing, so for them it was better to still have the option to have separate SGB and GBC enhancement.

Interestingly, a couple of OG GB games, including Tetris, get a color upgrade in a Game Boy Color. Nintendo likely patches those games on the fly since they obviously couldn't account for hardware that didn't exist yet. Nice little feature.
 
I honestly hope so. I regret giving my copy of Heart Gold away. It was boxed, with everything that came with it, and I hadn't completed the game. I was in a Pokemon funk and decided I didn't want it anymore.

Then again, I'm also kind of glad I gave it away. Our cleaning lady (who we pay well because she's a friend of the family) has hard financial times, and she was thinking about buying her son a used 3DS for his fourth birthday. So, I said I'd give her a game and that was one that caught my eye. I picked it over Platinum, because I had more fun with what I played of that.
 
There's too much promotion for Red/Blue/Yellow at the moment with merchandise and limited edition systems, it isn't the time for Silver/Gold/Crystal. As others have said we'll probably see them on NX.
 

SerTapTap

Member
They'd be morons not to. I'm not re-buying gen 1 especially with still functional carts, but my GSC games are dead (due to the clock the batteries die way faster) and they're better games anyway.

There's too much promotion for Red/Blue/Yellow at the moment with merchandise and limited edition systems, it isn't the time for Silver/Gold/Crystal. As others have said we'll probably see them on NX.

Maybe if NX is the handheld AND NX launches this year. I kinda doubt both of those happen at once. All they need to do is wait a few months.

I hope so. Silver was the last Pokemon game I played.

You should really just play a modern pokemon game IMO. The improvements are pretty staggering. That was before the physical/special split, so Dark types are actually useful now. It's a bold new, functional world out there, as much as I loved the original games.
 

Onivulk

Banned
What's the consensus on the quality of heartgold/soulsilver?

I guess I can play those on my 3DS. For some reason crystal is the only pokemon game I've ever completed and as such I have more nostalgia for gen 2 than any other.
 

dc89

Member
What's the consensus on the quality of heartgold/soulsilver?

I guess I can play those on my 3DS. For some reason crystal is the only pokemon game I've ever completed and as such I have more nostalgia for gen 2 than any other.

They're really good remakes. I really enjoyed them.
 

dangeraaron10

Unconfirmed Member
I'd certainly love it.

Going back playing Pokemon Yellow makes me severely miss Dark types. Also EXP Share (although with more limited functionality back then as opposed to now) to cut down on the grind, which I found to be incredibly tedious in Gen I. Now don't get me wrong, I love me some Gen I, but Gen II will always be my favorite Gen since it basically took Gen I and improved on it in its entirety as a true sequel, even keeping the whole of Kanto.

I'd say Gen II was my favorite, hands down. So yes, bring it on. Maybe for NX virtual console though.
 

Bowl0l

Member
I'd certainly love it.

Going back playing Pokemon Yellow makes me severely miss Dark types. Also EXP Share (although with more limited functionality back then as opposed to now) to cut down on the grind, which I found to be incredibly tedious in Gen I. Now don't get me wrong, I love me some Gen I, but Gen II will always be my favorite Gen since it basically took Gen I and improved on it in its entirety as a true sequel, even keeping the whole of Kanto.

I'd say Gen II was my favorite, hands down. So yes, bring it on. Maybe for NX virtual console though.
Is there confirmation that Gen 2 will made available in the eshop?
Kindly share your source.
 
D

Deleted member 465307

Unconfirmed Member
I don't see this happening until the next generation, as I think they're going to focus all attention on Sun/Moon through 1H 2017, and I think we'll see a 3DS replacement (whether that's NX or something else) by the end of 2017. R/B/Y was a nice surprise and made sense given the gap year Pokémon took. Also, you can kind of already play Gen 2 on 3DS via HGSS.

Is there confirmation that Gen 2 will made available in the eshop?
Kindly share your source.

I agree with NormalFish. I think you may have misread or misinterpreted that post.
 
Remember when Marill was being marketed as the next Pikachu?

The sense of anticipation in the lead up to Pokemon Gold and Silver will never be topped. It was an insane fervor.

EDIT: But obviously, we'll get Silver for the 25th anniversary and Gold for the 50th, as is tradition.

When the anime was teasing gen 2 Pokemon early on, I always thought Marill was the shit.
 
Top Bottom