• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Why the Sega Saturn version of Five Nights at Freddy's is superior

Deft Beck

Member
A lot of people debate whether or not there were any good interactive movie games released in the mid-90s. So many of them had the bare minimum of interactive elements, only serving to showcase the desire of film production companies to enter the scary medium of video gaming without bothering to make an actual game. But, Scott Cawthon, all by himself, managed to make one of the defining games of the genre back in 1996. The game was ported to the PS1 and the Jaguar CD, but I think that the Saturn version is superior due to the special qualities of the system.

The Saturn version is a technical showcase for the system; it rendered the environments in 3D, and lit them with an impressive occluded lighting algorithm; Quake's Saturn version had a similar use of lighting to achieve dramatic effect, and FNAF takes great advantage of this. The models of the robots are also fully redone for the Saturn's quadrilateral polygonal rendering. Several thousand polygons are used for each robot, and Freddy himself has a convincing Gaussian shading and irregular texture combination that makes him feel very realistic for the time.

Control-wise, it's very intuitive. The use of the mouse-like shoulder buttons to click between the security cameras is very immersive, and the superior d-pad allows easy access to many of the functions in the game. All buttons on the controller are used, and the cursor moves fast enough for everything to work well. If you happened to import one, you're also able to use a mouse and keyboard. Plus, If you have the 3D controller from NiGHTS into dreams... , you're able to control the bobbleheads on the desk, which I found to be a cute easter egg.

If there's one area that could have used some additional polish, it's in the sound department. To make the game fit onto the disk, they had to compress the voice clips. Though, if anything, it adds to the nostalgiac effect; it makes you feel like you're in some sort of manic environment where your perceptions are limited to that of your panicked, boxed-in state. Though some many find this to be a knock against this version, I find it to my taste.

It's a shame that the N64 version never came out, but there's a rumor that a collector bought a prototype off of Scott for about $5k, and that it'll be up at auction soon. Anyone on this forum have deep pockets?

I'm glad that this game is still remembered today.
 

Gravy100

Member
My cousins friend swore up and down he had the n64 version but anytime we went round his house it had mysteriously been loaned out to someone else. Great game on ps1 though, way better than the new versions.
 

Mask

Member
As good as the Saturn one was, I prefer the Dreamcast port of the second game with the bonus first one included.

Having to use the Dreamcast Mic to sing the puppet back to sleep was crazy, and that Japanese only CCTV Controller was intense. Shame it's sky-high on Amazon JP and eBay now.
 

Jebusman

Banned
I get this thread is supposed to be funny, but it just comes off as kind of.... sad?

I don't know. Like I feel like "pretending to discuss game that doesn't exist" jokes died off years ago and feels a little dated. Like I'm in elementary school trying to bluff my way through knowing a game that no one else does, even though I don't know it either.
 

Deft Beck

Member
I get this thread is supposed to be funny, but it just comes off as kind of.... sad?

I don't know. Like I feel like "pretending to discuss game that doesn't exist" jokes died off years ago and feels a little dated. Like I'm in elementary school trying to bluff my way through knowing a game that no one else does.

I guess I'll just go and play through my copy of Sonic Xtreme again.
 

fhqwhgads

Member
I remember back when it first came out, I was considering buying it but I didn't have enough, maybe I should check it out with a used copy. I put the cash I had to use though, went to see Shazaam instead. Man, what was Sinbad smoking when they filmed that?
 

Maximo

Member
Always liked The Witcher on the N64 myself.

witcher1_2.jpg.jpg
 

Jebusman

Banned
I guess I'll just go and play through my copy of Sonic Xtreme again.

Besides, you screwed up claiming it was ported to the Jaguar CD.

No one in their right mind would willingly port a game to that thing.

Suspension of disbelief, thrown right out the window.
 

Deft Beck

Member
Besides, you screwed up claiming it was ported to the Jaguar CD.

No one in their right mind would willingly port a game to that thing.

Suspension of disbelief, thrown right out the window.

Perhaps it should have been brought to the highly successful Nuon.
 
D

Deleted member 10571

Unconfirmed Member
I don't get the joke. Or I just don't find it funny. I can't decide.
 

Maxey

Member
FNAF was a decent porting job on the Saturn but it doesn't compare to the masterpiece of a porting job that was Crysis on the Dreamcast.

That they managed to port graphical effects that weren't possible on the OG Xbox version is nothing short of a miracle.
 

Shifty

Member
tbh the best version of steel battalion was the one they made for the tiger game com

the adapter for the controller kind of sucked though
 

Bossking

Banned
You know, it may not have been the prettiest game and it was a complete pain in the ass to actually play, but the Gameboy Advance port of FNaF was a technical marvel. I seriously can't believe they managed to squeeze that entire game into a GBA cart, even if they had to shoddily redraw all of it in (kinda terrible) sprite-art.

Leave it to GBA compressed audio to make Freddy sound creepier.
 
OP, I need you to make a thread when Sonic Mania comes out. Talk about how they put Sonic to rest after the Genesis era and are finally reviving the character again for an actual sequel game after 20+ years.
 
I don't know. Like I feel like "pretending to discuss game that doesn't exist" jokes died off years ago and feels a little dated. Like I'm in elementary school trying to bluff my way through knowing a game that no one else does, even though I don't know it either.

Jesus 64 joke was amazing, sucked in so many people. Doesn't work now as you can just google if a title exists.
 

Mask

Member
Who's the President of the United States?

If your answer ain't Deutscher, yeah, you're in trouble.

Ah shit, darkest timeline :(

Next you'll be telling me that Half-Life 4 will never be released after that epic cliffhanger at the end of the third game..
 

Deft Beck

Member
OP, I need you to make a thread when Sonic Mania comes out. Talk about how they put Sonic to rest after the Genesis era and are finally reviving the character again for an actual sequel game after 20+ years.

Of course! Anything to take a break from my essay series on the long lasting Bubsy series.
 
Top Bottom