• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

EA shuts down Visceral, moves Star Wars game to EA Vancouver/others

TheXbox

Member
Terrible mismanagement over there. EA secured the hottest property in pop culture and have produced fuck all, save for one middling Battlefront reboot and its lootbox-infused sequel. The entire sequel trilogy will have passed before EA releases one Star Wars game not named Battlefront. Pathetic.
 

Boke1879

Member
Terrible mismanagement over there. EA secured the hottest property in pop culture and have produced fuck all, save for one middling Battlefront reboot and its lootbox-infused sequel. The entire sequel trilogy will have passed before EA releases one Star Wars game not named Battlefront. Pathetic.

"middling" reboot that sold 16 million units and it's sequel can easily sell over 10 million while still making money.
 

Trey

Member
This. People act like game developers weren't shuttering and the B-tier wasn't disappearing long before GAAS became trendy.

Game devs are still shuttering, the B-tier doesn't exist in any firm capacity, and GAAS is beginning to annoy "core" gamers. We'll see where this all goes, feels different than how these sorts of discussions usually go.
 

Audioboxer

Member
Respawn and Bioware right now


LBzdzZl.gif

TcFY9XB.png


D3Bn2s2.png
 

Marcel

Member
Game devs are still shuttering, the B-tier doesn't exist in any firm capacity, and GAAS is beginning to annoy "core" gamers. We'll see where this all goes, feels different than how these sorts of discussions usually go.

Core gamers on the internet are annoyed which are a separate audience from core gamers who paid for the GaaS/microtransaction future we're now in.
 

Gamezone

Gold Member
I don't get it. Didn't linear story games like the Last of Us almost reach 10 millions copies sold? Shouldn't that be enough? Star Wars would probably do way better.
 
Yes though EA is their publisher (both Titanfall games as well as the upcoming Star Wars game by Stig)

If EA were unhappy with their titles performances and decided to end publishing agreements with them it could be really hard on the studio
Oh of course. I just mean that EA can’t shutter Respawn
 
Yes though EA is their publisher (both Titanfall games as well as the upcoming Star Wars game by Stig)

If EA were unhappy with their titles performances and decided to end publishing agreements with them it could be really hard on the studio

I think Microsoft would step in and help them out before they we're hit hard.
 

Elfstar

Member
It's almost funny how perfectly-tailored this news is to being a GAF nightmare. "Despised AAA publisher shuts down beloved single-player game developer that was working on an Uncharted-esque Star Wars game in favor of making it into a GaaS". Condolences to those who were hyped, and congratulations to Jim Sterling's patreon revenue.

Next ones:

-"Activision buys CD Projekt Red and turns Cyberpunk into a loot-box based f2p moba"

-"Konami buys From Software and makes them develop Dark Souls pachinkos"
 
That's so EA.

What a fucking bummer.


Welp. It is a big company and a huge license. I guess they are trying to play it as safe as possible.

I would love to play a linear action adventure game in the Star Wars Universe. Does EA still have an exclusivity deal for the games?
 

Bumhead

Banned
The entire sequel trilogy will have passed before EA releases one Star Wars game not named Battlefront. Pathetic.

Interesting viewpoint actually.

Does Disney have any say in this at all? Like nothing major enough to reverse this decision or anything, but are they potentially looking at EA's output here like "what the fuck are you doing?"
 

Nesther

Member
Terrible mismanagement over there. EA secured the hottest property in pop culture and have produced fuck all, save for one middling Battlefront reboot and its lootbox-infused sequel. The entire sequel trilogy will have passed before EA releases one Star Wars game not named Battlefront. Pathetic.

Yeah, it's an absolutely pathetic showing on EA's part. I wish another company had secured the rights to the property, or better yet no company.
 

JarrodL

Member
Ugh.

In a few years every big game is going to be a microtransaction-filled slot-machine with some gameplay and story tangentially attached, isn't it?
 

Majora

Member
Thank God for Nintendo and Sony at this point. Bethesda too but I can definitely see them pivoting to the service model in the future given their string of single player flops.
 
Personally I find all this games as a service stuff to be monotonous and boring. Really don't like the way the industry is heading, more shills than ever repeating their rubbish, more ways to squeeze the players wallets with that loot box shit. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if the online pass came back into play for used games soon.
 

shimon

Member
Terrible mismanagement over there. EA secured the hottest property in pop culture and have produced fuck all, save for one middling Battlefront reboot and its lootbox-infused sequel. The entire sequel trilogy will have passed before EA releases one Star Wars game not named Battlefront. Pathetic.

Unfortunately that middling game sold 16 mil and the sequel will also sell pretty good I predict. So yeah...
 

TheXbox

Member
"middling" reboot that sold 16 million units and it's sequel can easily sell over 10 million while still making money.
Two perspectives:

1. As a Star Wars fan, and a video game fan, these Battlefront games aren't doing it. Sorry.

2. As the sole license holder, EA have squandered years of potential on home consoles. Maybe Galaxy of Heroes and two Battlefront games are enough for them to not care? But they're pretty much all hands on deck with their major studios. Visceral is defunct, Respawn is years away, Dice/Criterion/Motive are Battlefront machines. Episodes VII, VIII, and IX will have come and gone, and EA will have released only two major Star Wars games -- one of which doesn't even have a story.
 
Ugh.

In a few years every big game is going to be a microtransaction-filled slot-machine with some gameplay and story tangentially attached, isn't it?

Every game from EA, Activision, Ubisoft, and Take Two, yes.

The other publishers will fill in the voids in the market.
 

Kolx

Member
It's amazing how one news turned the general opinion from "best year for sp games in a long time" to "sp games are doomed" on gaf.
 
This game is being transformed from an Uncharted-like singleplayer game to something more akin to Mass Effect or Destiny with a semi-open world structure with hubs. Lootboxes/Microtransactions will also appear in some form. Mark my words.

Yeah. Probably true, and really disappointing. Was looking forward to what it was. :(

Even if they couldn't microtransaction it to hell, this still should have made a good amount of money as a huge single-player cinematic SW game, but even that's not enough for EA I guess.
 
I don't get it. Didn't linear story games like the Last of Us almost reach 10 millions copies sold? Shouldn't that be enough? Star Wars would probably do way better.
That was loved by fans and critics alike though. Plenty of Star Wars games have flopped in the past as well.
 
Top Bottom