-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
I don't know how anyone can say the X1 looks better...the PS4 is CLEARLY a LOT better looking. Like holy shit. The increase in details is pretty damn obvious. One of my co-workers said he didn't see it...until I pointed out every single difference and his X1 fanboy self reluctantly agreed.
plagiarize
Banned
True 'fanboys' weren't going to switch anyways, but we know they only really make up a small percentage of the people buying either platform.
PS2 was the last of that gen I bought. Xbox 360 was my main console last gen. PS4 will be my main console this gen.
People who care predominantly about multiplatform games have every reason to switch from 360 to PS4. Losing backwards compatibility killed a huge advantage Microsoft would have had in leveraging the online 360 user base.
reasons not to switch... they're basically none existent. I have to make a new friends list. That's it.
Killroyskbg
Member
I quoted you the GIF i made and what they did to make the comparison differ the way it did. And the admitting part can be found if you took the time to read the first thing in this thread after the IGN comparison...
Off topic, but Scrarlett really does have some fantastic tits.
Curious as to why PC = Oko
TacticalFox88
Banned
Lol, and I can't get ANYBODY to switch. Almost had my best friend on the PS4 train but he just won't push the button. Madden, 2K and the Xbox controller...these dudes don't even play online much!
Marc
Member
Wow, trying to catch up on this thread is almost impossible. When you put it like that it is certainly a big gap, I wonder if the rumoured OS issues for Xbone is dragging its performance down as it shouldn't be that huge of a difference right? In real terms however, I would prefer better effects and such over extra FPS and pixels. Or both, yeah actually, I will have both please.
Anyway...
Gemüsepizza
Member
I think it just looks bad on screenshot, but looks better in motion.
Yeah, hilarious indeed.
velociraptor
Junior Member
I don't know about that. The level of difference is far greater than 360 v PS3.
Nevermind the smoother framerates and AA; the fact it's rendering at 50% more pixels says it all.
And yet no-one managed to build a complete PC rig that can compete with the PS4 if not for spending at least 600/700 dollars or more in the other thread with the PC comparison shots.
As someone who'd rather sit on the couch and play games on the big screen, this will do very nicely for 399$. Not to mention that it will only get better from here on out.
phosphor112
Banned
Racist!!!
Lol, we need all blacks, we can't let them suffer the fate of ignorance!
NTIETS13A_Superiority
Banned
Way bigger difference. Would be idiotic to say otherwise. If you care or not is up to you. There are HUGE differences and PS4 version comes on to of everything.
TheRealTalker
Banned
seems like JackFrags wasn't trolling about his opinion
since all videos are compressed and we are probably not going to get any less compressed vids for awhile I am looking forward to impressions from the people who had hands on times with the game
https://twitter.com/jackfrags/status/395046482266447872
since all videos are compressed and we are probably not going to get any less compressed vids for awhile I am looking forward to impressions from the people who had hands on times with the game
DICE has already said the XO version is missing many features, such as AO so it really isn't a good comparison to judge on.
velociraptor
Junior Member
What's a mid-range PC?
I dunno, it's kinda true...I wouldn't say these games look ~8x The last of Us in quality but then when I get KZ on launch day I might do a 180 on that comment!
Not what he defines as such.
NTIETS13A_Superiority
Banned
DF images should be removed altogether as they are not representive of anything than DF incompetence.
So, AO is "many" features now? Shit gets spun out of control here.
Can Crusher
Banned
People who don't care about MS exclusives clearly aren't Xbox fans. So yeah, those people are just better served getting a PS4 because it's cheaper and the ganes look better on it.
SirMossyBloke
Member
Jackfrags has put up more ps4 multiplayer videos. It looks gorgeous.
They said AO and sorta implied it wasnt the only thing thats being added. I'd assumed they would have been a bit more specific if its another "big" feature though.
Yeah, nothing about this is as small as the PS3/360 difference. Like, you could go into a store blind and know that you're getting the best version of a game if you pick up the PS4 version. DF comparisons will only be used to gauge just how much better the PS4 version is or to find out how a game performs.
captscience
Member
Do we know if the sharpening filter in the XBox One is a fixed function part of their scaler?
That look is going to really fatigue the eyes during long play sessions. And it's ugly.
That look is going to really fatigue the eyes during long play sessions. And it's ugly.
I'm just saying we should be expecting better after 8 years if sub full HD and we are still there. The hardware if these two systems should be that big of a learning curve considering the components they are using in them.
Read the rest of his tweets. He specifically states there are some other features still not in the review build on top of AO
https://twitter.com/repi/status/395181209619165184
amstradcpc
Member
If FXAA is so horrendous for IQ i wonder what solution Guerrilla used with KZ SF because compared to BF 4 the IQ in KZSF is manificient.
Well, I wouldn't call worse IQ (50% lower pixel rate), sometimes even sub 720p, worse framerate, aliasing issues, etc. ...... a win and I wouldn't walk away happy from this.. but hey.... to each his own.
Still. They only mentioned AO, and it becomes "many", which then becomes "tons", which then becomes "The day one patch will bump the res up to 1080 and the framerate to 60 with 16xMSAA guys!"
This weird game of telephone is getting out of hand.
I would "guess" that it's an optional part of the scaler. If it were a non-optional part of it.. omfgno..
CalvinCrack
Banned
Why doesnt Next Gen wait a year and give us 1080p? Those comparison vids are a bloody stool sample!!!!!!!!!
Wow, trying to catch up on this thread is almost impossible. When you put it like that it is certainly a big gap, I wonder if the rumoured OS issues for Xbone is dragging its performance down as it shouldn't be that huge of a difference right? In real terms however, I would prefer better effects and such over extra FPS and pixels. Or both, yeah actually, I will have both please.
Anyway...
Haha, this is awesome. Is it new?
TheRagnCajun
Member
I was buying PS4 anyways, but wasn't necessarily going to get BF4. However it looks like DICE did a pretty good job with the PS4 version, so maybe I'll pick it up.
I don't see them fixing the frame rate by adding more. If anything it will probably drop even more frames.
phosphor112
Banned
I just wanted to show the difference between their original picture and how it's a cock up compared to everything else. If you look at the X1 pictures in comparison with those, you can see the color range is literally exactly the same.
Bam Bam Baklava
Member
If they add AO to the Xbox version wouldn't there be a performance hit?
This question has probably being asked a million times but since there is like a million pages now I have to ask because I literally don't have time to read all of it, so I apologize for any inconvenience:
The blurriness compared to the One of the PS4 shots are not how it will look like right? there is something wrong with how it was captured?
Reason is because I HATE blurry IQ, I just HATE IT!!
It was one of the reasons I changed PS3 for a Xbox 360 after I got it.
Is very conflicting this stuff because I thought blurriness was caused by lower Rez but the PS4 version of this game is 900p, it should not look blurry.
KZ SF is sharp as all fuck compared to some of the shots.
The blurriness compared to the One of the PS4 shots are not how it will look like right? there is something wrong with how it was captured?
Reason is because I HATE blurry IQ, I just HATE IT!!
It was one of the reasons I changed PS3 for a Xbox 360 after I got it.
Is very conflicting this stuff because I thought blurriness was caused by lower Rez but the PS4 version of this game is 900p, it should not look blurry.
KZ SF is sharp as all fuck compared to some of the shots.
SO IS PC IKNORITE
"blurriness" in the comparison is because the xbone has a sharpen filter applied to its upscaler along with DF further sharpening the image (along with color and contrast changes on the xbone footage). PS4 (and PC) versions aren't blurry. XBONE version is artificially sharpened with a post-process effect. If that is the sort of thing that appeals to you, getting the PS4 version and cranking up the sharpness on your TV will accomplish the exact same thing. And no I'm not being snarky about it. That's literally the difference you are seeing on the XBONE footage.
NoirVisage
Banned
There was a thread where someone from DF gave an explanation of what happened, it got closed if I'm not mistaken, To my knowledge, the site hasn't officially mentioned any wrong doing, but the colors do pop out on the Xboxone version.
Dude they're on record as saying there is other stuff to tweak. Chill...
plagiarize
Banned
I'd really like to know this too. If it isn't optional currently, they need to make sure that gets patched in, even if they want to leave it on by default.
CoD2 looked way better on mid-range pc's than on 360 as well. When I played Stalker in 2007, there was nothing even close to it on consoles.
People need to stop pretending that it used to be different. Consoles have always been a power/cost compromise.
SwiftDeath
Member
Wow opinions are severely contrasting in here
I'm of the opinion that for the average gamer they won't care
PS4 is clearly the superior version though and that DF footage, oh my that DF footage
Curious if opinions will change any when playing these games on 40"+ screens?
I'm of the opinion that for the average gamer they won't care
PS4 is clearly the superior version though and that DF footage, oh my that DF footage
Curious if opinions will change any when playing these games on 40"+ screens?