• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

10 Games - 10 Scores, What's you Prediction?

Fat4all

Banned
Game 1. Hitman 81
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 69
Game 3. The Division 76
Game 4. Dark Souls III 91
Game 5. Uncharted 4 95
Game 6. Quantum Break 87
Game 7. No Mans Sky 84
Game 8. StarFox Zero 71
Game 9. Gears 4 75
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 80
 
Game 1. Hitman 68
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 80
Game 3. The Division 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III 86
Game 5. Uncharted 4 89
Game 6. Quantum Break 75
Game 7. No Mans Sky 82
Game 8. StarFox Zero 81
Game 9. Gears 4 85
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 90

Only ones I think could be delayed are Gears and Yooka Laylee (at least into next year) and right now I'm not thinking either are going to happen. Playtonic continues to post updates every few weeks for the YL and I think Microsoft will do whatever they have to to make sure Gears comes out this year as its unlikely they will have any other major holiday release outside of Forza.
 
Game 1. Hitman 80
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 76
Game 3. The Division 83
Game 4. Dark Souls III 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 95
Game 6. Quantum Break 85
Game 7. No Mans Sky 75
Game 8. StarFox Zero 76
Game 9. Gears 4 86
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 80
 
Game 1. Hitman - 79
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 84
Game 3. The Division - 81
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 95
Game 6. Quantum Break - 78
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 79
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 65
Game 9. Gears 4 - 79
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 68

This is going off of what I know about each game, and the things reviewers are likely to point out. No Man's Sky, I believe, will have scores that fluctuate quite a bit, but it's got a unique art style, which people love. It also is quite immense, which is also a plus. I think a common complaint is that there's really not much to do. I've done similar deductions for each of the games on the list.
 
Game 1. Hitman - 76
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 74
Game 3. The Division - 70
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 88
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 92
Game 6. Quantum Break - 85
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 75
Game 9. Gears 4 - 79
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 69
 
Game 1. Hitman - 88
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 84
Game 3. The Division - 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 93
Game 6. Quantum Break - 86
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 72
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 82
Game 9. Gears 4 - 86
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 76
 

rrc1594

Member
I think Uncharted 4 will top all the previous games but it wont reach the 96 Metacritic of Uncharted 2. I would say maximum 95 and minimum 92.

It will also start a infinite war among Naughty Dog fans: UC4 or TLOU, which one is better?

The real answer is
UC2
 

prag16

Banned
No Zelda? No Deus Ex?

Nevertheles...


Game 1. Hitman 74
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 77
Game 3. The Division 78
Game 4. Dark Souls III 84
Game 5. Uncharted 4 91
Game 6. Quantum Break 79
Game 7. No Mans Sky 86
Game 8. StarFox Zero 74
Game 9. Gears 4 77
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 78
 
Game 1. Hitman 71

Probably scores a little lower than it would deserve due to the messy production and episodic nature meaning a lack of initial content.

Game 2. Far Cry Primal 75

Fundamentally good game that gets some low scores due to the lack of guns and dialogue.

Game 3. The Division 69

The 'secret RPG' nature of the game and similarities to Destiny will end up hurting it I think.

Game 4. Dark Souls III 84

It's Dark Souls, most will love it, but a few will hate it enough to keep it out of the 90's.

Game 5. Uncharted 4 89

Should be a classic, but I expect a few well below average scores here and there (looking at you Polygon).

Game 6. Quantum Break 70

I just can't see the story living up to the hype, and I think the live action sections will really hurt it.

Game 7. No Mans Sky 79

Assuming it works, I can see it being very divisive, but I think the sheer scale and amount of options it will give players will be enough to keep its average score up in most reviewers eyes. Could easily see it going the other way and getting a far lower score than it deserves though.

Game 8. StarFox Zero 61

I expect this to be genuinely bad, but not so bad as to be a complete write off.

Game 9. Gears 4 89

The plot will probably be wank, but as long as they nail the controls, that will carry it to a damned good score alone.

Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 84

Should be great but very old school, I can see a lot of silly complaints about it being too retro.
 
Game 1. Hitman - 83 (no idea, really)
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 91
Game 3. The Division - 88
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 88
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 87
Game 6. Quantum Break - 86
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 78
Game 9. Gears 4 - 88
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 82

I lot of these scores are in the 80s, but most of them also have big teams that know what they're doing. I see Primal breaking out just because it's so different. Quantum Break SHOULD be in the 90s for as long as they've been developing it, but the added bloat of a TV show makes me nervous.
 
Game 1. Hitman 79
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 78
Game 3. The Division 80
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 96
Game 6. Quantum Break 88
Game 7. No Mans Sky 87
Game 8. StarFox Zero 69
Game 9. Gears 4 82
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 78

Hitman MC = 76 (3 points under)
Far Cry Primal MC = 76 (2 points under)
The Division MC = 81 (1 point under)
 

eso76

Member
Game 1. Hitman 72 Metacritic 76 4 points difference SCORE 6
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 76 Metacritic 77 1 point difference SCORE 9
Game 3. The Division 85 Metacritic 81 4 point difference SCORE 6
Game 4. Dark Souls III 84 Metacritic 89 5 point difference SCORE 5
Game 5. Uncharted 4 94 Metacritic 94 Woo ! spot on as of now SCORE 12
Game 6. Quantum Break 84 Metacritic 78 6 points difference SCORE 4
Game 7. No Mans Sky 77
Game 8. StarFox Zero 70 Metacritic 71 1 point difference SCORE 9
Game 9. Gears 4 86
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 76



Currently 39 Pts
51 Pts if Uncharted 4 stays 94

Changed uncharted 4 score from 91 to 94 on May 1st
 

Violet_0

Banned
Game 1. Hitman - 79 (7 points)
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 82 (5 points)
Game 3. The Division - 85 (6 points)
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 91
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 90
Game 6. Quantum Break - 75
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 75
Game 9. Gears 4 - 81
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 84

e: total score = 18

Yooka-Laylee is the only game on that list that actually interests me
 

Wedzi

Banned
Game 1. Hitman - 75
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 76
Game 3. The Division - 85
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 92
Game 6. Quantum Break - 81
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 87
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 70
Game 9. Gears 4 - 88
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - Delayed
 
Game 1: Hitman - 76
Game 2: Far Cry Primal - 80
Game 3: The Division - 85
Game 4: Dark Souls 3 - 93
Game 5: Uncharted 4 - 95
Game 6: Quantum Break - 79
Game 7: No Man's Sky - 82
Game 8: Star Fox Zero - 77
Game 9: Gears 4 - 87
Game 10: Yooka-laylee - 88

NMS and Yooka-laylee are the only ones that I could see getting delayed to next year, but I'll take my chances.
 

notaskwid

Member
Game 1. Hitman - 80
Game 2. Far Cry Primal- 75
Game 3. The Division - 81
Game 4. Dark Souls III 87
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 93
Game 6. Quantum Break - 82
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 65
Game 9. Gears 4 - 85
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 75
 

Xumbrega

Banned
Alright

Game 1. Hitman 84
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 83
Game 3. The Division 88
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 91
Game 6. Quantum Break 91
Game 7. No Mans Sky 78
Game 8. StarFox Zero 81
Game 9. Gears 4 89
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 84
 

butman

Member
Game 1. Hitman 75
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 78
Game 3. The Division 72
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 93
Game 6. Quantum Break 72
Game 7. No Mans Sky 70
Game 8. StarFox Zero 73
Game 9. Gears 4 84
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 85
 

Itachi87

Member
Game 1. Hitman - 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 83
Game 3. The Division - 80
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 86
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 90
Game 6. Quantum Break - 82
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 81
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 83
Game 9. Gears 4 - 80
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 81
 

HF2014

Member
Game 1. Hitman 75
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 78
Game 3. The Division 85
Game 4. Dark Souls III 93
Game 5. Uncharted 4 90
Game 6. Quantum Break 75
Game 7. No Mans Sky 65
Game 8. StarFox Zero 45
Game 9. Gears 4 80
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 75
 

Locust

Member
Game 1. Hitman 84
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 76
Game 3. The Division 80
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 90
Game 6. Quantum Break 81
Game 7. No Mans Sky 77
Game 8. StarFox Zero 71
Game 9. Gears 4 81
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 82
 

Quan

Member
Game 1. Hitman 80
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 86
Game 3. The Division 88
Game 4. Dark Souls III 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 93
Game 6. Quantum Break 84
Game 7. No Mans Sky 86
Game 8. StarFox Zero 77
Game 9. Gears 4 82
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 88
 

The Argus

Member
Game 1. Hitman 80
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 74
Game 3. The Division 83
Game 4. Dark Souls III 88
Game 5. Uncharted 4 95
Game 6. Quantum Break 89
Game 7. No Mans Sky 84
Game 8. StarFox Zero 65
Game 9. Gears 4 92
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 80

What's with all these low ball estimates for Quantum Break?
 

Oneself

Member
Game 1. Hitman 76
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 73
Game 3. The Division 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III 88
Game 5. Uncharted 4 93
Game 6. Quantum Break 80
Game 7. No Mans Sky 84
Game 8. StarFox Zero 71
Game 9. Gears 4 77
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 74
 

Johndoey

Banned
Game 1. Hitman 76
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 82
Game 3. The Division 75
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89
Game 5. Uncharted 4 87
Game 6. Quantum Break 86
Game 7. No Mans Sky 77
Game 8. StarFox Zero 74
Game 9. Gears 4 85
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 86
 

doorframe

Neo Member
Game 1. Hitman - 81
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 86
Game 3. The Division - 84
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 91
Game 6. Quantum Break - 88
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 83
Game 9. Gears 4 - 90
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 82
 
Game 1. Hitman - 7.8
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 8.3
Game 3. The Division - 8.2
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 8.4
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 8.8
Game 6. Quantum Break - 8.8
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 7.9
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 8.7
Game 9. Gears 4 - 8.2
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 7.9
 
Game 1. Hitman 75
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 77
Game 3. The Division 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III 86
Game 5. Uncharted 4 89
Game 6. Quantum Break 81
Game 7. No Mans Sky 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero 64
Game 9. Gears 4 77
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 72
 

jesu

Member
Game 1. Hitman - 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 80
Game 3. The Division - 84
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 86
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 94
Game 6. Quantum Break - 84
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 72
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 66
Game 9. Gears 4 - 79
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 82
 

_SAKY_

Member
Reserved while I figure out wtf yukalele (w/e) is.

Game 1. Hitman- 82
Game 2. Far Cry Primal-88
Game 3. The Division- 81
Game 4. Dark Souls III- 92
Game 5. Uncharted 4- 94
Game 6. Quantum Break- 90
Game 7. No Mans Sky- 75
Game 8. StarFox Zero- 82
Game 9. Gears 4- 76
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee- DELAYED TO 2017 (or over 9000)
 
Game 1. Hitman- 74
Game 2. Far Cry Primal- 72
Game 3. The Division- 83
Game 4. Dark Souls III- 85
Game 5. Uncharted 4- 93
Game 6. Quantum Break- 86
Game 7. No Mans Sky- 80
Game 8. StarFox Zero- 67
Game 9. Gears 4- 79
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee- DELAYED TO 2017
 

brokentrain

Junior Member
Game 1. Hitman - 82
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 81
Game 3. The Division - 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 93
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 92
Game 6. Quantum Break - 89
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 83
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 79
Game 9. Gears 4 - 91
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 78
 

BashNasty

Member
Fun idea!

Game 1. Hitman 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 76
Game 3. The Division 83
Game 4. Dark Souls III 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 90
Game 6. Quantum Break 84
Game 7. No Mans Sky 83
Game 8. StarFox Zero 88
Game 9. Gears 4 86
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 85
 
Game 1. Hitman 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 86
Game 3. The Division 81
Game 4. Dark Souls III 94
Game 5. Uncharted 4 85
Game 6. Quantum Break 89
Game 7. No Mans Sky 75
Game 8. StarFox Zero 85
Game 9. Gears 4 91
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 75
 

rafa

Neo Member
Game 1. Hitman - 83
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 87
Game 3. The Division - 78
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 93
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 88
Game 6. Quantum Break - 72
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 81
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 54
Game 9. Gears 4 - 77
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 73

I think No Man's Sky will get by with its ambition more than its implementation. I think the Division will disappoint due to lack of end-game content and support. Quantum Break will be serviceable, but not exceed anyone's expectations. People will wonder why Gears 4 exists even more than they already do. Yooka-Laylee will be divisive; a certain number of people will see it as the second coming, the rest will see it for what it is: a relic of the past before it's even released.
 

Jayuk

Neo Member
Game 1. Hitman - 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 80
Game 3. The Division - 85
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 90
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 94
Game 6. Quantum Break - 83
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 85
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 78
Game 9. Gears 4 - 88
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - Delayed
 

DrD

Member
Game 1. Hitman 80
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 74
Game 3. The Division 84
Game 4. Dark Souls III 91
Game 5. Uncharted 4 93
Game 6. Quantum Break 88
Game 7. No Mans Sky 86
Game 8. StarFox Zero 76
Game 9. Gears 4 84
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee Delayed
 
Game 1. Hitman 65
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 70
Game 3. The Division 85
Game 4. Dark Souls III 84
Game 5. Uncharted 4 89
Game 6. Quantum Break 80
Game 7. No Mans Sky 78
Game 8. StarFox Zero 62
Game 9. Gears 4 73
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 77
 
What's with all these low ball estimates for Quantum Break?

For me at least, it's because of Alan Wake, a phenomenal game that received an 83 (nothing to scoff at, but the game was deserving of far higher scores), I get the distinct feeling that QB will be the same, a game that will get pretty great scores, but will end up being better still than those suggest.
 

Grimsen

Member
Game 1. Hitman 71
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 69
Game 3. The Division 80
Game 4. Dark Souls III 84
Game 5. Uncharted 4 86
Game 6. Quantum Break 80
Game 7. No Mans Sky 90
Game 8. StarFox Zero 75
Game 9. Gears 4 80
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 85
 
Game 1. Hitman 75 - thinking middle of the road
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 79 - thinking pleasant surprise
Game 3. The Division 81 - doesn't live up to hype but solid
Game 4. Dark Souls III 88 - surprisingly awesome, reviewers say it's not bloodborne but still one of the year's best
Game 5. Uncharted 4 91 - goty for many. naughty dog is just too consistent to fail.
Game 6. Quantum Break 45 - guessing it's shorter in gameplay than The Order: 1886 and reviewers savage it worse than that game
Game 7. No Mans Sky 86 - will be divisive, some claiming goty, others getting bored. upper middle.
Game 8. StarFox Zero 69 - gameplay is too much of a throwback, gaming has moved on yet this franchise hasn't. predicting miyamoto isn't able to correct course in just one extra year.
Game 9. Gears 4 50 - guessing online issues. reviewers savage it partly because there's no Cliffy B, and because it's an excuse to slam MS for again being unable to transfer an external franchise to MS studios.
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 72 - will be considered pleasant throwback, but like most kickstarter games criticized for being too short

I'm consistently disappointed by most games lately, particularly from MS studios (everything not from Turn 10 and their smaller devs). So I know I'm being harsh and I'm hoping I'm wrong. But there are always huge disappointments every year and I'm treating this like a March Madness bracket, predicting upsets.
 

Josh5890

Member
Game 1. Hitman 81
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 78
Game 3. The Division 84
Game 4. Dark Souls III 87
Game 5. Uncharted 4 95
Game 6. Quantum Break 87
Game 7. No Mans Sky 75
Game 8. StarFox Zero 62 (But I hope I am dead wrong)
Game 9. Gears 4 83
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 88

I feel like I'm lowballing most of these.
 

Anticol

Banned
Game 1. Hitman - 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 76
Game 3. The Division -80
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 85
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 83
Game 6. Quantum Break - 72
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 81
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 64
Game 9. Gears 4 - 74
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 75
 
Game 1. Hitman -76
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 72
Game 3. The Division - 82
Game 4. Dark Souls III -91
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 93
Game 6. Quantum Break - 64
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 78
Game 8. StarFox Zero -67
Game 9. Gears 4 -87
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee -81
 

weekev

Banned
Game 1. Hitman - 81
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 84
Game 3. The Division - 79
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 88
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 94
Game 6. Quantum Break - 82
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 83
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 62
Game 9. Gears 4 - 88
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 83
 
Top Bottom