Game 1. Hitman 71
Probably scores a little lower than it would deserve due to the messy production and episodic nature meaning a lack of initial content.
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 75
Fundamentally good game that gets some low scores due to the lack of guns and dialogue.
Game 3. The Division 69
The 'secret RPG' nature of the game and similarities to Destiny will end up hurting it I think.
Game 4. Dark Souls III 84
It's Dark Souls, most will love it, but a few will hate it enough to keep it out of the 90's.
Game 5. Uncharted 4 89
Should be a classic, but I expect a few well below average scores here and there (looking at you Polygon).
Game 6. Quantum Break 70
I just can't see the story living up to the hype, and I think the live action sections will really hurt it.
Game 7. No Mans Sky 79
Assuming it works, I can see it being very divisive, but I think the sheer scale and amount of options it will give players will be enough to keep its average score up in most reviewers eyes. Could easily see it going the other way and getting a far lower score than it deserves though.
Game 8. StarFox Zero 61
I expect this to be genuinely bad, but not so bad as to be a complete write off.
Game 9. Gears 4 89
The plot will probably be wank, but as long as they nail the controls, that will carry it to a damned good score alone.
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 84
Should be great but very old school, I can see a lot of silly complaints about it being too retro.