• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Can we talk about old-school first person dungeon crawlers?

Hey all it's the fourth part of my mini-almanach. This time all the text is NOT MINE as I did not finish the titles below. Hope you enjoy this trip down the memory lane!

Part 1: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=469298
Part 2: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=36706516#post36706516
Part 3: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=36728077#post36728077

The Elder Scrolls: Arena

arena_019wkc5.png
arena_0295j1a.png
arena_03j9jus.jpg
arena_04cqj8j.png


Download here!: http://www.elderscrolls.com/arena/

GameFAQs mrtzeentch says:
The Elder Scrolls series has become pretty famous in recent times. Games like Morrowind and even Daggerfall saw pretty big success. But most people forget about Arena, the game that started it all. At the time of its release (and even today possibly) it was the biggest world ever created for a game. It had thousands of towns, dungeons, and thousands more items and spells. It was absolutely enormous. In more recent games, you've been confined to certain areas of Tanriel (the game's world) In Daggerfall, you were confined to Highrock and Hammerfell, but in Arena, you could travel to ANY part of the world. In those days, technology was not what it is now, obviously, so most areas seemed generic, but in truth there was alot ot them. Each area's native people had their own attitudes and bias. Example, when travelling in Morrowind, a High Elf was not always treated with a whole lot of respect. The game centered around you searching for pieces of a staff that had been broken. The typical RPG quest in most respects, but this one had you travelling all over the world. You've got alot ot do too. You don't have to do the main quest of course. You can always just roam around collecting treasure. There are tons of items to be found too. Artifacts (unique items) are definitely present here. You'll see alot of them, but they are much harder to find than in Morrowind.


The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall

daggerfall_0176k3q.jpg
daggerfall_02bekaw.jpg
daggerfall_03qkjox.jpg
daggerfall_04v5kgt.jpg


Download here!: http://www.elderscrolls.com/daggerfall/

GameFAQs Zamble says:
TES: Daggerfall is simply one of the most amazing RPGs of all platforms available. It's just as complete as a computer game can be, but, unfortunatelly, it is also one of the games with the biggest number of bugs ever released - just like Ultima Online. Daggerfall is a first-person solo RPG with a good storyline. You are in a secret mission given by the Emperor himself to you, with the objective of investigate and exorcise the hauntings of the City of Daggerfall, where the ghost of the former King of Daggerfall screams "Vengeance!" every night. Also, the Emperor has sent a letter to the former Queen of Daggerfall years ago, and he wasnts you to find out if it was ever delivered or whatever happened to it. Nice, isnt it? Then you are sent in a boat to the Kingdom of Daggerfall...but a strange storm sinks your ship and you end up in a dark cave, from where you have to get out and then resume your mission.

The downsides of the game are also big. It's full of bugs. You'll be walking around in a dungeon and, all of a sudden, you'll penetrate the floor and won't be able to come back! Or you may notice some items disapearing from your inventory with no explanation... the list of bugs go on. Many paths have been released to solve them, and most of the logical bugs have been fixed (like not being able to spleep inside of your own house) but the problems with "falling to the void" like mentioned beffore remain, as well as random crashes. Also, Bethesda Software didn't keep their promise on all the features they said the game would have, like the clothes your character is wearing influencing NPC reaction. Anyway, if you can live with the bugs, you'll love the game as much as I did.


Descent to Undermountain

descent_03awjy8.jpg
descent_042qkj6.jpg
descent_01juk7r.png
descent_021qjbu.jpg


eBay

GameSpot says:
It seemed like such a great idea when we first heard about it nearly three years ago: Combine the fantasy world of AD&D with the award-winning Descent engine. The concept sounded tantalizing, so much so that many thought the result would surely be an experience that would do nothing less than completely revitalize the ailing fantasy role-playing genre.

But somewhere along the line something went horribly wrong, and now gamers are asking themselves two questions. The first arose merely out of befuddlement: How could the company that produced Fallout also be responsible for one of the lousiest games to come down the pike in quite a while? The second, though, addresses a much more serious issue: Why did Interplay ship the thing when it wasn't even close to being the sort of cutting-edge product the hype machine had led us to believe it would be?

There's probably no way to learn the answer to the first question, but - thanks to some very frank members of the Descent to Undermountain team - the answer to the second is now common knowledge. The game went out when it was scheduled to go out (in time for a Christmas release) even though it wasn't ready. That's not just me speculating; that's precisely what a member of the DTU team stated in a recent post on Usenet.

Descent to Undermountain is set in the AD&D Forgotten Realms world, but judging from the game's visuals it should probably be renamed "Forgotten Graphics." I haven't seen a major game title that looked so dreary, so blocky, and so downright unappealing in years. It's tempting to lay the blame on the 256-color palette, but I've seen plenty of games using only 256 colors that looked a damn sight better than this mess.

Nearly every location - or at least all the ones I visited during the time I endured the game - is awash in brown, giving everything a samey look that only adds to the monotonous feeling that settles over you from the moment you begin your first quest. And pixels? Man, you ain't seen nothin' until you've roamed around a bit in DTU - these blocks are as big as a baby goblin and twice as irritating. The worst part, though, is that at Interplay's DTU web site you'll find all sorts of claptrap about how many textures are used and how advanced the graphics are. They've even got the nerve to compare this wretched mess with Quake! I guess there's nothing quite as intoxicating as the wings of hubris fluttering about your head in a time of crisis....

But the horrors don't end there. A lot of the monsters you meet seem to have learned how to defy gravity itself: Giant rats float in midair, bats that have been hacked to death hover several feet off the ground, and even an undead skeleton can somehow manage to stay three feet off the floor. I guess that getting rid of all the zero-gravity stuff in Descent was just too much of a stumbling block for whomever it was who "rewrote" the Descent engine for this game.

Even if everything in DTU were picture-perfect, this would still be a derivative game, treading the same path of all the AD&D computer games that inundated the market from the late 1980s into the early 1990s. But if it looked good and played smoothly there'd at least be some happy AD&D fans right now; as it stands, no one's happy, and in fact, a lot of people are downright angry. The lesson to be learned should be obvious: If you're gonna ride the hype machine, you'd better deliver the goods. Sadly, DTU doesn't even come close - and the worst part is that sometime over the next year or so we'll probably see this same story played out all over again.

So what have we learned today? That pushing a product out the door before it's ready makes loyal customers angry; that game developers should keep at least one eye on what's going on in terms of technology when working on a new game; and that if you buy Descent to Undermountain after reading this, you get what you deserve.


Wizardry VI: Bane of the Cosmic Forge

wizardry6_01fbkxp.gif
wizardry6_02ksjpl.png
wizardry6_03seko8.png
wizardry6_046tkbq.gif


GameFAQs Jitawa says:
Bane of the Cosmic forge marks a turning point for the Wizardry series, and is the first game in the "trilogy" started by D.W. Bradley. All told, Wizardry changed little from 1 to 5, and this title made an attempt to distinguish the series from its peers.

Story is where this game really shines. Consider that the majority of rooms you walk into are going to look exactly the same. Flavor text is present for pretty much every area of the game that serves to set up the particular room or area you may have just entered. Your characters aren't given any default personality, and so the text serves to assign a fairly objective (if slightly cynical and bemused) perspective to the player's party. The descriptions of the Queen's bedroom and stashed clothes are fairly amusing for example.

The story itself is fairly original for the time, and the manner in which the drama unfolds piece by piece, character by character is very satisfying. You start the game digging in the past, and eventually find yourself embroiled in the present political situation of the area. The game affords you multiple endings, which was also rather unusual for the time. Better still, the endings can be used to import your characters to the sequel with unique ramifications and starting area depending on which ending you got.

This game was a massive overhaul from the previous Wizardry games. Instead just a few stock fantasy races and classes -- the roster was expanded to include 4 main schools of magic and several new races and classes. The classes were expanded to include a caster for each school (basically, there was the classic mage/priest and the added alchemist and psionic). All told there were 11 races and 14 classes. Gender played a fairly minor roll in the game, with a very few items being gender specific, and only one class having that restriction (Valkyries had to be female).

I must confess that I have a certain bias for the classic western RPG. Wizardry is a series that created the mold for early RPG incarnations like Might & Magic or Bard's Tale. This game expands on basic wizardry, and really lends itself to replay with different sets of classes and such (Much like Final Fantasy I, but with more options). I've personally beaten it over ten times, and I wish I could go back to the first time I won it when all the battles and puzzles were still brand new. If you're considering or have played Wizardry 7, consider playing this one first and bringing your party through the games in order. In terms of story and gameplay - this is truly an RPG classic.


Wizardry 8

wizardry8_01fik2n.jpg
wizardry8_02u0jo4.jpg
wizardry8_03e0j4n.jpg
wizardry8_040qjgq.png


eBay

GameFAQs Kujila says:
In the world of RPG series there are three juggernauts - Origin's "Ultima", New World Computing's "Might and Magic" and Sir-Tech's "Wizardry". These three produced games with many descendents and even spin-offs of the fantasy world.

Now, the Wizardry series has always been aimed more at 'hardcore' RPGers. Crusaders of the Dark Savant lacked the alluring graphics of Ultima and Might and Magic, but instead delivered the most challenging RPG ever created. The game faced you against innumerable foes more powerful than yourself, had you cross the world of Guardia in search of an artifact known as the Astral Dominae. Wizardry, like Might and Magic, fused technology with fantasy with fantastic results. The battle against the technology of the Dark Savant never seemed contrived or ludicrious. Magic clashed against technology as rival factions battled on Guardia and NPCs travelled freely, affecting the entire thread of the game.

However, after Wizardry 7, the series seemed to have ended. Unlike Ultima and Might and Magic, new games were not being churned out on an almost annual basis, although many gamers were still grappling with the T'rang and the Savant. Then Sir-Tech finally released Wizardry 8, and unlike Origin and New World Computing, they have finished their legacy with their greatest game ever.

And what a great game it is.

Wizardry 8 is born in a time where RPGs are gaining lustre and losing substance. Pretty-but-shallow games like Neverwinter Nights are now the face of the RPG genre. Morrowind is almost legendary merely because it has the graphical edge that the superior prequel Daggerfall could not use to attract customers. They are slowly but surely melding with the other genres, losing the challenge and depth that RPGs were defined by.

It seemed that the days of the truly great history-defining RPGs like Wizardry 7, Ultima VII and Might Magic III were gone. Certainly a few great games rose here and there - the Fallout series, Sir-Tech's own 'Shadows over Riva', and Planescape: Torment (which I have not played yet have heard nothing but praise for.) But until Wizardry 8, it seemed that the great RPG was not what it used to be.

I don't give games 10/10. 10/10 means perfection, and in my opinion no game is perfect. I'm the sort of reviewer that reserves 9/10 for the best games and will never even consider 10/10 - but this is different. Because I truly believe that Wizardry 8 is such a rare and wonderful game that it deserves this unattainable reward. If you played Crusaders of the Dark Savant, then this will be an almost spiritual experience. Or maybe I just need to get out more.


Dungeon Master

dungeon_011aj9r.gif
dungeon_02xfkwx.gif
dungeon_03yhkxj.gif
dungeon_04pjkmj.gif


eBay

Internet user Reup says:
Dungeon Master isn't just a game, it's a religion. Even though the game was made in 1987 for the Atari ST (and a PC port was made two years later) the fanbase is quite big today. This 'mother of all rpg's' was certainly groundbreaking when it appeared, both in gameplay and graphics. The 3D first person perspective was still rather unheard of in those days, as most games were side- or topview. The fact that you'd have a team of 4 characters that you could each specialise and the huge dungeon to explore made it an instant hit. The sheer amount of ports for this game for every operating system and 3d engine you can imagine proves that Dungeon Master isn't forgotton at all!

There's not much to explain about this game. Everything that's in a decent RPG nowadays is also found in Dungeon Master, only a bit more primitive. After you've chosen your Champions you start to search the dungeon, venturing deeper and deeper. Each character has an inventory with plenty armor and equipment slots as well as a large enough packback. They need to eat, drink and sleep now and again to regain there powers. You can find food in many rooms, and in the remains of some enemies, and water from fountains all over the place.

This is a must-have for any RPG or dungeon crawler fan, but everyone else should give it a try as well. Read the background story in the manual to get in the mood and the technical details about spell-casting and you're ready to go! The game 'only' gets a four, because I really missed some moody music in the background. It was probably left out due to memory limitations back then, but still it's a shame. If for some reason you want to try the game in a more modern jacket, you can play one of the many clones (some of which have been made using high-tech 3d engines) or the Java version which is an accurate copy of the original, only with better graphics and sound-effects.

Legend of Grimrock

grimrock_016ukqw.jpg
grimrock_02b2kgd.jpg
grimrock_03kfk7h.jpg
grimrock_04vgj61.png


Hey a 2012 title!

Buy it here: http://www.grimrock.net/buy/ (and I mean it!)

UK IGN review says:
As a kid, I grew up rolling d20s, charting out hand-scrawled labyrinths on graph paper swiped from math class, and concocting elaborate fantasy worlds to explore. And when I wasn't sitting around a table with my pals debating the finer points of casting Magic Missiles instead of Delayed Blast Fireballs, I spent my free time affixed to a clunky old PC playing games like Eye of the Beholder and Dungeon Master. Digging into Almost Human's shiny new take on hardcore old-school dungeon crawlers is a warm fuzzy trip down memory lane, but one of the most impressive things about Legend of Grimrock is the way it showcases how well the classic formula holds up after so many years.

Hand-picking your four-member party is preferable to diving in with the pre-made group, and there's a good balance between accessibility and depth in the character crafting menu. While class selection is sadly limited to fighters, rogues, and mages, cool racial perks and selectable bonus traits add enough variety to the mix to keep things interesting. Insectoids, for example, make great back-line spellcasters due to their heightened intelligence and naturally hardened carapace, while burly minotaurs are solid front-row combatants that get an attack boost for every human skull they're holding in their inventory. Leveling-up characters earns you skill points to dump into a broad range of weapon, armor, spell, and ability specializations, unlocking new perks and boosting your combat prowess in the process. Since the real fun comes from diving into the dungeons to amass powers and gear as you go, I appreciate that it only takes a minute or two to lock and load your crew without sacrificing depth in the character customization department.

Only a few steps into the first dungeon level, it's easy to get swept away by the thick, potent atmosphere of Grimrock's underground realm. The dank moss-and-root entwined stone walls feel ancient and almost alive, particularly as the warm torchlight casts shadows across their crisp detailed surface. Other nuances, like mysterious earthquakes, strange voices that appear in your dreams, and the foreboding sound of scurrying creatures stalking you in the distance add to the tension that slowly builds as you explore. There's something ominous afoot, and it feels like it could emerge at any second to destroy you. You also never know what you'll encounter when rounding the next corner or opening a locked door, and the eerie vibe plays well off the need to scour every nook and cranny for invaluable loot.

Underneath its gorgeous sheen and striking atmosphere, Legend of Grimrock is an unapologetic nod to PC gaming's earlier days. Playing it reawakens those same feelings of excitement I had back when I got into early dungeon crawler RPGs for the first time. There's something magical about the skillful way the dev team takes such antiquated game design and makes it feel new and fun again, pushing all the right nostalgia buttons in the process. But more importantly, everything about this well-crafted romp through deadly dungeons comes together to pull you into its mysterious realm and hold on.


Mazes of Fate

mazes_016ckhs.jpg
mazes_0203k7x.jpg
mazes_03jhkco.jpg
mazes_04epk9f.jpg


eBay

GameFAQS clarkisdark says:
The first console my family owned was a TI-99/4A. At my young age, it was hard to enjoy any of the games we had, but one I always came back to was Tunnels of Doom. It was an RPG dungeon crawler that frustrated me to no end. The game expected me to remember what I named my characters, but I always gave them long and complicated names, and I'd forget who was who when it was time to tell somebody to pick up an item. I didn't touch the dungeon crawler design again for several years. In fact, I'd forgotten all about it. So it's somewhat refreshing and nostalgic to come across Mazes of Fate, a game whose design is firmly rooted in the RPGs of old.

But Mazes of Fate's main draw is its first-person dungeons. First-person anything on the GBA has rarely worked out, but the effect here is handled flawlessly and recreates the feeling of an old-school dungeon crawler without any hitches. The monsters within are also drawn with the same care as the game's human characters, but their animations are a tad stifling. With only one or two basic animations per monster, it's kind of distracting when compared to the rest of the game. But when compared to the rest of the genre on the GBA, I'd say Mazes of Fate is doing very well.

The dungeons here are complicated, sometimes spanning three or four floors with all the dead ends and locked doors you hoped you'd never see in an RPG. I spent almost two hours in the first big dungeon, and it about drove me crazy. Granted, there is a map screen you can consult which shows you every hallway and room you've previously seen. So backtracking or finding areas you haven't visited yet is convenient. It's just that these dungeons are so big. It all looks the same, too, and it can get pretty tiring spinning around in circles and constantly relying on a map. Monsters are a frequent threat in the meantime. But this isn't like your usual RPG where monsters pop out of nowhere to challenge you in yet another random battle. Monsters roam freely through the dungeons, and you can just as easily confront them as you can turn and run the other way. There is no concrete battle system where you have to select "flee" to escape. If you want to attack, you go up to them and do it. But in typical RPG fashion, attacking means selecting which monster to focus on and hoping you get a hit instead of a miss. A defeated monster will sometimes drop an item, but it also gives you experience points. Yes, you still have to level up, but it is entirely up to you how it is done. Each time you reach a new level, you are given three points to assign to any category, be it your lock-picking skills, magic ability, accuracy using a one-handed weapon, or even the rate at which you heal yourself.

If you only like your RPGs Final Fantasy style or not at all, this game won't do much for you. It's absolutely nothing like Final Fantasy. Mazes of Fate is, however, a great throwback to the days of "ye olde dungeon crawler." If you have ever played one of those, you'll feel right at home. The retro feel is recreated perfectly yet offers a bit more familiar RPG substance (which is integrated very, very well) for those spoiled by modern adventures. You can even alter certain aspects of the game depending on what you say to people, and that's an awesome feat few other RPGs have bothered to incorporate. Dungeons can be hard to stomach sometimes, but I think you'll find Mazes of Fate to be a fun and refreshing "last gem" for a dying Game Boy.
 

AutumnAve

Member
Ah, awesome! I recently bought the new Wizardry PSN game for $15, because I remember how much I loved The Bards Tale and Wizardry for the NES. Man, oh man, I don't know if I've gotten soft on modern RPG games, but, I was not prepared for how hardcore this new Wizardry is; no auto-mapping, no easy light sources in the dungeon, no easy healing, hardly get any loot off fallen enemies, have to get loot identified back in town, ect, ect. Still love it, but fuuuuuuuuu
 

Xander51

Member
Grimrock is even better than I was expecting and has re-ignited my need to play some of the older games my 10-year-old self sucked at but still loved.

I'm thinking of getting Might and Magic 6 on GoG. I'm a little ashamed to admit I played some of 7 back in the day but never played 6.
 

RedSwirl

Junior Member
Any talk in this thread about oldschool console first-person dungeon crawlers? They did exist.

Technically the original Phantasy Star counts. Most of the old Shin Megami Tensei games were also first person dungeon crawlers of a similar ilk. You also have King's Field and Shadow Tower on the PlayStation - the predecessors to Demon's Souls and Dark Souls.
 

Gattsu25

Banned
Any talk in this thread about oldschool console first-person dungeon crawlers? They did exist.

Technically the original Phantasy Star counts. Most of the old Shin Megami Tensei games were also first person dungeon crawlers of a similar ilk. You also have King's Field and Shadow Tower on the PlayStation - the predecessors to Demon's Souls and Dark Souls.
Eye of the Beholder was on the SNES

I heard it was a pretty amazing game :)
 

kswiston

Member
I disagree strongly with the OP (the dungeons in 7 are much better, particularly in the endgame which is where M&M6 starts to fall apart with these giant enemy horde dungeons that get boring) on his ranking of the latter M&Ms, and I suspect my opinion is not the minority when I say that 7>6>>8>>>>>>>>>>9.

Your opinion is not unheard of, but not the majority either. Might and Magic VI had the best reviews, and from what I have seen is the most well regarded of the later M&M games.

I can see how people would prefer M&M7 over 6. There are more spells, skills and character classes. They actually give you racial choices for PCs, and there are light and dark game paths (with their own class upgrades) that add to replayability. Arcomage is also fun.

However, M&M7 really restricted secondary skill progression between classes. Most of the skills can only be Grand-mastered by a single class, and some classes can only reach basic/expert level in a given skill. This is a pain in ass for things like Alchemy, Item ID, Mnoster ID, etc. Sorcerers already have enough skills to level with 4 primary schools of magic, light or dark magic, learning, and meditation, yet they are responsible for item ID and probably monster ID as well. Knights/Paladins and Clerics become even more of a necessity than they already were since they are the only ones who can grandmaster repair item and merchant. Also, if you want the extremely strong black potions for your party via alchemy, you need to take along a druid which is a class I personally don't like (I prefer rolling a thief as my fourth character).

Since your party members all receive the same number of skill points (not counting horse shoes), you end up with some classes who are starved for skill points until late game, and others who are swimming in skill points. Also, you are locked into either light or dark magic.

Might and Magic VI had way more flexibility. You can spread your secondary skills around easily, and aren't forced to take a class you don't want just for the sake of a useful secondary skill.

I liked the dungeons and scenarios of both games. Might and Magic VII's scenario is a little more creative than VI's. The scavenger hunt at the beginning provided you with a neat little tutorial island. I think VII's morailty system was a tad more realistic as well. I may be remembering incorrectly, but I don't think you could be a complete bastard and then just donate your way to sainthood like you could in M&M6. I used to slaughter all of the peasants in the starting town of M&M6 for some quick cash, and then make a few donations to the local church to reset my reputation/karma.
 

Link1110

Member
This thread made me try Sword of Vermillion. It's decent with two problems

1. You walk way too slowly in towns
2. The 3d graphics, rather than being single walls, look like individual pillars or trees do that it's impossible to see where you can turn

A shame, because there's a decent game under there. The Phantasy Star fan in me wants to love it, but the game holds itself back.

I also have Wizardry 7 for ps1. I might pull that out of my backlog and see how it is,
 
Well since I bought that M&M6 pack a few months ago on GOG this thread inspired me to fire up Mandate of Heaven and give it a proper crack. 6 hours later... oh god where did my night go. Having so much fun. Just went with the default party the game chose of Paladin/Archer/Cleric/Mage and so far it's all working out pretty good. The realtime/turnbased combat is pretty fun and I've just started getting decent AoE damage for dealing with the god damn HORDES of enemies the game likes to throw at you. All up I'm enjoying this much more than most recent WRPGs i've played eg. Skyrim.

And, if memory serves, you want to get everyone the ability to shoot arrows.

Remembered reading this and did as soon as I found the bow trainer. Damn good idea.
 

Victrix

*beard*
M&M 4-5-6 are fucking amazing

I have so many fond memories of M&M2 on the Mac (Forward into battle!)

And the M&M series has too many quotable lines in 4-5-6 (Lookin to train? GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGgggggggggggggggg......gggggggggggggg (x25 more) good job!)

Wizardry 6 was another amazing experience - one of the first games I read a strategy guide for (which was awesome)

I've been playing Etrian Odyssey the last week or two... I must finish it :p
 

KKRT00

Member
Anyone knows how to resize window in window mode in Might and Magic 8?
I dont like full screen and window is too small [640x480] to be playable. In DosBox You would just need to change one parameter to get bigger window, but here i cant do nothing ;\
 

deim0s

Member
Dusted off the old family Apple //e a couple weeks ago to revisit one of my all-time favorites of the genre:

apple2ebt.jpg

How you stored the hardware and that copy of Bards Tale is astonishing. I remember asking my dad to pick-up another copy of Ultima VII and Wing Commander - since the disks are pretty much demagnetized or basically unreadable when we stored it after 2 years.
 

Songbird

Prodigal Son
Hey StoppedInTracks! I never got to say to you how awesome your thread is. Thanks for taking the time to put it all together, especially with the images.
 

Philia

Member
Thanks to Legend of Grimrock and shortly after I beaten it, I got hit with nostalgia for old school. I fired up Shining in the Darkness as a part of UGC for 360.

I've never beaten this game and always had wanted to. And I finally got into playing some ways in. I sure felt pretty dumb lol. See, the first two times I've played this over a decades ago, I've obviously missed out on the fact that the armorer sells helms and shields. I've been wasting my hard earned gold on subpar armor upgrades lol when I should had been adding instead. Yes, the hero's def is pretty much shit, and the armor was meant to complement that. But yeah thanks to the similar interface, I've assumed the "helms" and the "shields" icons were for "deals" and "sell". xD So my first two attempts were just too darn HARD lol.

Anyway, because this game is pretty old school, I went with PnP mapmaking. And my god, decent graph paper is SO hard to find. I didn't like the 4 squares per a inch because they're still too friggin large. Finally found a 6 pack at Staples for 20 dollars. Its worth it though, I missed PnP mapmaking. I've done a bunch when I was a kid. :D

DuV0l.jpg


And yes, I write incredibly small and I like tiny squares that way.
 

Narag

Member
hah after I bought Grimrock and saw the old school mode on startup, I went to buy graph paper for it. Never did it when I was younger but the Etrian Odyssey games convinced me it's part of a proper experience.
 

Philia

Member
Ah. Yeah I had plenty of experience as a kid. I used codes I'm familiar with for stuff. Stairs with 3 lines (descending size indicate which direction, longest at top for the descend, smallest line at top for upstairs), chests with boxes. Blackened spots are pits. Arrow would indicate entrance etc. :D I'd normally label the chests with whats in it but eh, so far the treasures aren't noteworthy lol.

I'd try to label other stuff as I'd know to catch when I'm trekking through for quicker familiarity. IE dots in the lines would indicate torches in the halls or W for water puddles. I also shaded all that stuff because on a quick glance I'd get lost in the lines lmao.
 
^^ hand-drawn maps.

What a coincidence. When I was cleaning my attic today I encountered the self-made Ishar maps I mentioned earlier.

Folks, this is pure ancient history. Almost 20 year old maps! They mean so much to me:

p1040519q8j5a.jpg


p104052026jni.jpg


p104052164jm1.jpg


p1040522e5k3v.jpg


p1040523ngj3r.jpg


Demon's Souls box for size comparison :)
 

Gattsu25

Banned
Hey all it's the fourth part of my mini-almanach. This time all the text is NOT MINE as I did not finish the titles below. Hope you enjoy this trip down the memory lane!

Part 1: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=469298
Part 2: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=36706516#post36706516
Part 3: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=36728077#post36728077


Dungeon Master

dungeon_011aj9r.gif
dungeon_02xfkwx.gif
dungeon_03yhkxj.gif
dungeon_04pjkmj.gif


eBay

Internet user Reup says:
Dungeon Master isn't just a game, it's a religion. Even though the game was made in 1987 for the Atari ST (and a PC port was made two years later) the fanbase is quite big today. This 'mother of all rpg's' was certainly groundbreaking when it appeared, both in gameplay and graphics. The 3D first person perspective was still rather unheard of in those days, as most games were side- or topview. The fact that you'd have a team of 4 characters that you could each specialise and the huge dungeon to explore made it an instant hit. The sheer amount of ports for this game for every operating system and 3d engine you can imagine proves that Dungeon Master isn't forgotton at all!

There's not much to explain about this game. Everything that's in a decent RPG nowadays is also found in Dungeon Master, only a bit more primitive. After you've chosen your Champions you start to search the dungeon, venturing deeper and deeper. Each character has an inventory with plenty armor and equipment slots as well as a large enough packback. They need to eat, drink and sleep now and again to regain there powers. You can find food in many rooms, and in the remains of some enemies, and water from fountains all over the place.

This is a must-have for any RPG or dungeon crawler fan, but everyone else should give it a try as well. Read the background story in the manual to get in the mood and the technical details about spell-casting and you're ready to go! The game 'only' gets a four, because I really missed some moody music in the background. It was probably left out due to memory limitations back then, but still it's a shame. If for some reason you want to try the game in a more modern jacket, you can play one of the many clones (some of which have been made using high-tech 3d engines) or the Java version which is an accurate copy of the original, only with better graphics and sound-effects.
FYI: RockPaperShotgun: You Could Be Playing Dungeon Master Right Now

Download here: http://dmweb.free.fr/?q=node/851
 

larvi

Member
^^ hand-drawn maps.

What a coincidence. When I was cleaning my attic today I encountered the self-made Ishar maps I mentioned earlier.

Folks, this is pure ancient history. Almost 20 year old maps! They mean so much to me

Nice! Those are works of art compared to my pathetic maps, here's one of mine from the Apple II version of M&M 1 circa 1986 or 1987:

Scan10005e.jpg


At college on the Plato system we actually had map editor programs so we could transfer our hand drawn maps to something more legible and multiple people could edit and share their findings. This was always one of my favorite maps from the multiplayer dungeon crawler Avatar circa 1982:

Scan10006e.jpg


To this day I'm not sure who KOR is but he/she must have invoked the ire of the mapmaker :)
 
Nice maps guys. I wonder if in the far future people will come upon these maps thinking they lead to some ancient mysteries. Or everything we have found so far in archeology was just people playing an ancient pnp game.

Cool that some of you have all that stuff. I would have liked to look at my old crude maps and notes.
 

larvi

Member
that looks like exactly what I have... or a pretty decent knockoff of what I have.

Thanks, I just bought one in decent shape from ebay for $45 to use for my handheld dos machine, it looks like it will work just fine without having to activate it with Verizon and pay for service.

Edit - Got Dosbox working and it works great for games like Bard's Tale that can be controlled with the keyboard:

DSCN0519e.JPG


The only issue I have so far is with the sound being a bit off, but it's just PC speaker beeps and boops so I don't miss it much when I turn it off
 

Jokeropia

Member
^^ hand-drawn maps.

What a coincidence. When I was cleaning my attic today I encountered the self-made Ishar maps I mentioned earlier.

Folks, this is pure ancient history. Almost 20 year old maps! They mean so much to me:

http://www.abload.de/img/p1040519q8j5a.jpg

http://www.abload.de/img/p104052026jni.jpg

http://www.abload.de/img/p104052164jm1.jpg

http://www.abload.de/img/p1040522e5k3v.jpg

http://www.abload.de/img/p1040523ngj3r.jpg

Demon's Souls box for size comparison :)
Awesome.
 

ToxicAdam

Member
I loved the MM:Xeen games so much. I don't think I ever beat the second one, but definitely played through the entire first one. I can't believe it's almost 20 years old now. Such a charming world and characters.

I admire the ambition of MM6 ... but it was just too much game for me. I don't think I ever got very far into it and was burnt out on the genre.

-- // --

The game that brought me back was actually Mazes of Fate (on the GBA). A terrific little game that was challenging but not frustrating. I was hoping for a sequel, but I don't think it ever came.
 

nonadventurer

Neo Member
Thanks for this thread. One game I haven't seen mentioned here yet is Dark Heart of Uukrul. I was just reminded about the game yesterday by a retrospective article at the RPG Codex (http://www.rpgcodex.net/content.php?id=8320), and I recall it as one of the best old school dungeon crawlers I've played. Pretty brutal, though, as far as both combat and puzzles are concerned. I don't think I even beat it back in the day; perhaps a replay is in order.
 

vocab

Member
Hey, thanks for this thread. very informative. I'm trying to get into them my self, but they are very daunting, and some of the older ones are hard as hell, long, and have an old interface. I wish this thread had some updates to the main pages, and maybe any mentions of future first person dungeon crawlers.
 

Mr_Elysia

Member
Great thread. Add me to the camp that used to map everything out on paper, though mine are long since lost. It's too bad this seems like such a niche genre and the barrier to entry so high. But with that I suppose we do get some enthusiasts making the games that truly care about it. I would echo the sentiments here and would be interested in the state of future releases and perhaps a few less hardcore options as the commitment it takes for some of these old school ones is astronomical.
 
Wanna make an entry for Etrian Odyssey IV and Soul Hackers?

Sure man you don't even have to ask. Let's make this thread a community deliverable. I will try to create entries for games not released yet for example: Legend of Grimrock 2 as well as those missing in the list for example: Eliminage for the PSP.
 
The Realms of Arkania trilogy was fantastic. Definitely a game that one should not approach lightly however. If I recall, characters died not only from combat, but from hunger, disease, temperatures as well. Made you tread very carefully throughout the game(s).

My younger self enjoyed manually mapping and recording every dungeon and city -a joyful time-sink. But I doubt I would have the patience, or time now to give these games the attentions they deserve.

Great games nonetheless. (Great thread as well)
 
Elminage Original and Unchained Blades are games every dungeon crawler fan should try if they get a chance. i finished them both.

just to mention a few recent ones if you want to support the genre.
 

Sinatar

Official GAF Bottom Feeder
The Realms of Arkania trilogy was fantastic. Definitely a game that one should not approach lightly however. If I recall, characters died not only from combat, but from hunger, disease, temperatures as well. Made you tread very carefully throughout the game(s).

My younger self enjoyed manually mapping and recording every dungeon and city -a joyful time-sink. But I doubt I would have the patience, or time now to give these games the attentions they deserve.

Great games nonetheless. (Great thread as well)

You'd probably be interested to know that they are remaking Realms of Arkania.
 

vocab

Member
So I beat lands of lore. Overall, good game. Not the biggest fan of the last dungeon or the enemies that burn your armor or the fuckers who earthshake your gear. Inventory can be a bit of a pain, but as someone who played it in 2013, I think it holds up really well.

I'm playing world of xeen now. I don't expect to beat the whole thing because the game is huge, but if I beat cloudside, ill be more than satisfied.
 

Gorgon

Member
Thread subscribed! May I add some stuff? Some are not exactely first person dungeon crawlers, but I think they are too good to ignore. They deverve recognition.

Big pics incoming!


HardNova1.jpg

HardNova2.jpg



1273319876-00.jpg

1273319877-00.jpg



1185127516-00.jpg

964773476-00.jpg



Space1889.jpg

Space18893.jpg



WhalesVoyage.jpg



BATII.jpg

BATII2.jpg



BAT.jpg

BAT2.jpg



MegatravellerII.jpg

MegatravellerII2.jpg



Immortal.jpg

Immortal2.jpg



darklands.jpg

darklands2.jpg
 
A lot of those appear to fit the "dungeon crawler" aspect but completely miss the "first-person" aspect, judging from the backs of those boxes. I mean, The Immortal is totally an isometric third-person game.
 
Top Bottom