• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

FB worker living in garage to Zuckerberg: challenges are right outside your door

entremet

Member
Mark Zuckerberg’s travels throughout the United States to fulfill his 2017 “personal challenge” to “learn about people’s hopes and challenges” have seen him drive a tractor, meet recovering heroin addicts, don a hard hat and speak out against the staggering wealth inequality that his $68.5bn fortune so clearly represents.

But to Nicole, a worker in one of Facebook’s cafeterias, they have also raised an important question: “Is he going to come here?”

“Here” is just a few miles from Zuckerberg’s five-house compound in Palo Alto and mere blocks from Facebook’s sprawling Menlo Park headquarters. Here, on a quiet street of modest bungalows, Nicole and her husband Victor, who also works at a Facebook cafeteria, live in a two-car garage with their children, aged nine, eight and four.

“He doesn’t have to go around the world,” said Nicole. “He should learn what’s happening in this city.”

The family of five have lived in this cramped space next to Victor’s parents’ house for three years. Three beds crowd the back wall, while a couch and coffee table mark the front of the room as a living area. Clothes are hung neatly from the garage door tracks. The family goes next door to use the bathroom and kitchen. “It’s not easy,” Victor said on a recent morning. “Especially when it’s raining.”

“Our daughter continues to ask us when she’s going to get her own room, and we don’t know what to tell her,” added Nicole.

On Friday, the couple were among about 500 Facebook cafeteria workers who elected to join a union, Unite Here Local 19. They are the latest group of tech industry service workers to seek unionization in the hopes of achieving a better standard of living.

Neither Facebook nor the food service contractor, Flagship Facility Services, opposed the union drive.

https://www.theguardian.com/technol...-zuckerberg-challenges?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
 

shem935

Banned
What salary does she get?

Working at a Facebook cafeteria is an enviable job in many ways. Nicole earns $19.85 an hour as a shift lead, while Victor makes $17.85 – well above the $15 an hour minimum for contractors that Facebook established in 2015.

But in a region where software engineers earning four times as much complain about ”trying to make ends meet", the family is struggling.

They earn too much to qualify for state healthcare, but not enough to afford the health insurance offered by their employer. They frequently struggle to find enough money for basics like food and clothes for their children. Victor recently borrowed money from his mother to hold a birthday party for one of his daughters, and from a friend to pay for a dentist appointment.

”Back in the day, [the wage] would have been a great number," said Victor, ”but because of Facebook moving in, everything is so expensive. I have to get payday loans sometimes. We barely make it."

.
 
What salary does she get?

Working at a Facebook cafeteria is an enviable job in many ways. Nicole earns $19.85 an hour as a shift lead, while Victor makes $17.85 – well above the $15 an hour minimum for contractors that Facebook established in 2015.

But in a region where software engineers earning four times as much complain about “trying to make ends meet”, the family is struggling.

They earn too much to qualify for state healthcare, but not enough to afford the health insurance offered by their employer. They frequently struggle to find enough money for basics like food and clothes for their children. Victor recently borrowed money from his mother to hold a birthday party for one of his daughters, and from a friend to pay for a dentist appointment.

“Back in the day, [the wage] would have been a great number,” said Victor, “but because of Facebook moving in, everything is so expensive. I have to get payday loans sometimes. We barely make it.”

So above minimum wage but far below livable for that area, especially with rising costs.
 

OldRoutes

Member
“He doesn’t have to go around the world,” said Nicole. “He should learn what’s happening in this city.”

Oh how do I hate that... he can do both just fine. How entitled is she? He's already paying your salary.
 

snap0212

Member
"Neither Facebook nor the food service contractor, Flagship Facility Services, opposed the union drive."

I find it funny that this sentence has to be included. Glad being against joining a union is illegal here for the employer.
 

shem935

Banned
Like receiving pennies from a billionaire is some sort of privilege. They should make enough money with both parents working to not be in such financial distress.
 

efyu_lemonardo

May I have a cookie?
Minimum wage should be directly tied to cost of living. The fact that it isn't means money isn't serving its purpose on a conceptual level.
 

Wereroku

Member
Asking for enough money to not live in a garage is entitlement now.

I mean they are in a super expensive area. Even tripling their wages probably wouldn't allow them to afford a 3 bedroom house in that area. Most people would just live outside the city and drive in everyday.

He's paying them a pittance to live in one of the most expensive areas in America.

Well I mean they aren't forced to live next to the headquarters unless they said somewhere in the article they were.
 

OldRoutes

Member
Sarcasm or?

He's not doing them favors, they're working for their salary, wtf is this attitude? Holy shit...

Asking for enough money to not live in a garage is entitlement now.

Nah, he just doesn't have anything to do with this. It's between the contractors and Facebook at this point.

Neither Facebook nor the food service contractor, Flagship Facility Services, opposed the union drive.

So even Facebook is not resisting the union drive... What could Zuckerberg learn more than seeing heroin addicts and seeing other parts of the world?

That's the entitlement I'm talking about. Unionise, get a better deal and hopefully things will be better for her and her family.
 

shem935

Banned
Nah, he just doesn't have anything to do with this. It's between the contractors and Facebook at this point.



So even Facebook is not resisting the union drive... What could Zuckerberg learn more than seeing heroin addicts and seeing other parts of the world?

That's the entitlement I'm talking about. Unionise, get a better deal and hopefully things will be better for her and her family.

Mmmm yeah entitled to scrape by on payday loans. Such pretension on their part.
 

Lil Marco

Banned
They don't have to live in silicon valley, they can commute from the bay's outskirts where housing is cheaper. Sure the drive sucks but you'll actually be able to save money, pay for healthcare, not be broke, etc. wow isn't that great.
 

Paganmoon

Member
Asking for enough money to not live in a garage is entitlement now.

That quote doesn't even ask for that, it ask that Zuckerberg actually see the problems in his own neighborhood, and not having to travel around the country to see that there's inequality.

I'm cynical as fuck at the best of times, but this totally is Zuckerberg laying down groundwork for a presidential bid, so no wonder he travels around the country instead of looking locally.
 

Emerson

May contain jokes =>
17 dollars an hour is not a salary. Shit is too low to live on with a family. Regardless if both parents make it.

A lot of couples live on the salary equivalent of $34 an hour, even with a family. Just not in Silicon Valley.
 

OldRoutes

Member
Mmmm yeah entitled to scrape by on payday loans. Such pretension on their part.

Nah I don't think you understood what I meant -- he can safely travel the world and be concerned about how his own employees are treated.

She's talking as if he didn't give a shit and this article clearly states that Facebook and the service contractors aren't doing anything to prevent them from getting better conditions...
 
$20 an hour as a cafeteria worker seems pretty good. Are all of the 500 cafeteria workers living in a garage or worse?

Is that salary well below what other people doing similar jobs in that area make? And how is the standard of living for those people?

We don't know how that family handles their finances.
 

shem935

Banned
Nah I don't think you understood what I meant -- he can safely travel the world and be concerned about how his own employees are treated.

She's talking as if he didn't give a shit and this article clearly states that Facebook and the service contractors aren't doing anything to prevent them from getting better conditions...

You think he actually gives a shit about the people whose tractor he is driving or the meth addicts he is ogling? He's an empty suit who sees an opportunity now that the bar to run for president is on the fucking ground to make a bigger name for himself.
 

AndyD

aka andydumi
Seems like anywhere else that wouldn't be that bad, but yeah, living next door to Facebook HQ can't be a great place for anyone not making six figures.

Pretty much. It says they are within blocks. A living wage is a living wage, but a reasonable commute should be factorable too.
 
Hell yeah they are. There's a lot of poverty in East Palo Alto and east Menlo Park. 2-4 families to a single home, easily.

I'll give it to berg, he's donated a lot to the two cities, but if you ask me the greatest thing he can give is internships to the teenagers of these communities. He needs to help break the cycle.
 
Nah I don't think you understood what I meant -- he can safely travel the world and be concerned about how his own employees are treated.

She's talking as if he didn't give a shit and this article clearly states that Facebook and the service contractors aren't doing anything to prevent them from getting better conditions...

They aren't doing anything to improve their conditions either, which is why they unionized.

They aren't being paid a livable wage based on where they have to live to work there, that's textbook exploitation of labor. This is WHY these employees are unionizing, and I applaud their courage in doing so.
 

Lil Marco

Banned
17 dollars an hour is not a salary. Shit is too low to live on with a family. Regardless if both parents make it.

Depends on where you live. You can be a king on 17 in an underdeveloped red state or the shit-tier desert parts of california. In socal or norcal, not so much.
 

Wereroku

Member
Hell yeah they are. There's a lot of poverty in East Palo Alto and east Menlo Park. 2-4 families to a single home, easily.

I'll give it to berg, he's donated a lot to the two cities, but if you ask me the greatest thing he can give is internships to the teenagers of these communities. He needs to help break the cycle.

But even giving jobs to kids won't fix the problem of overpriced real estate. The only way to fix that would be to move the HQ out of California. Even people making six digit salaries are having problems finding housing.

They aren't doing anything to improve their conditions either, which is why they unionized.

They aren't being paid a livable wage based on where they have to live to work there, that's textbook exploitation of labor. This is WHY these employees are unionizing, and I applaud their courage in doing so.

Well I mean that is the argument. They don't have to live where they currently are to work there as far as the article says. They could probably find better housing if they would live away from their work. They are choosing to live so close to the headquarters should FB have to pay someone more just because they don't want to commute.
 
Can't really defend them, there already getting paid better then min. wage ..a job that not complicated ...don't want to come out as begin a dick, but it is what it is ...and they live in a high cost of living area ...yeah ...can't expect to get paid $25 an hr while some people with college degree barely make $25+ an hr
 

OldRoutes

Member
You think he actually gives a shit about the people whose tractor he is driving or the meth addicts he is ogling? He's an empty suit who sees an opportunity now that the bar to run for president is on the fucking ground to make a bigger name for himself.

Well I guess I do believe he gives a shit, yeah.

But my post isn't even based on whether or not he does -- they're creating an union and Facebook isn't even against it.

Beside finding another job, that's the best option they have right now. What do you want Zuckerberg to do about it?

They aren't doing anything to improve their conditions either, which is why they unionized.

What could they do?
 

TaterTots

Banned
The cost of living there must be disgustingly high given their income. However, having 3 children isn't doing one any favors financially.
 
The amount they are making together could actually be considered to be more than enough in some parts of the US. It's another reason why a nationwide $15 minimum wage doesn't make any sense. Living costs significantly vary depending on where someone is living.
 

studyguy

Member
I can't imagine trying to live in the bay for $17/hr.

Made that much during college out here in Southern California and you'd never make it anywhere.
 

collige

Banned
The amount they are making together could actually be considered to be more than enough in some parts of the US. It's another reason why a nationwide $15 minimum wage doesn't make any sense. Living costs significantly vary depending on where someone is living.

Nothing about raising the Federal minimum prevents states or municipalities from raising their own minimums above it to adjust for local costs of living.
 

shem935

Banned
Well I guess I do believe he gives a shit, yeah.

But my post isn't even based on whether or not he does -- they're creating an union and Facebook isn't even against it.

Beside finding another job, that's the best option they have right now. What do you want Zuckerberg to do about it?

Get them payed more as the executive of his company, something entirely in his ability to do? Why does he have to work through a contractor for this? Hire the current employees you are paying the contractor to serve food and whatever else, and pay them a wage that will take them out of this situation? He could do that out of his own damn pocket and not lose an ounce of sleep. Spare me.
 
Top Bottom