A couple of things
- How long do you think the gen will last? 5 or 6 years? So 2 or maybe 3 games per team at most [probably 2]. If you think MS won't want as many Gears games as possible after paying through the nose for the IP you're mistaken. So for Black Tusk to get another shot at their new IP, they either need to spin up a second team or the 2nd Gears XB1 game needs to be made by another MS studio. In either case MS would need to setup a need studio or team and their move in this instance already signals that they are at least somewhat opposed to that lest they simply do it now instead of later
- Uncharted was an original IP made by ND. They were not being forced to make the 5th major game for a 8 year old franchise that was started by a 3rd party company. Comparing it to Uncharted is not a fair comparison.
- The most likely outcome from being forced to change direction entirely from a new in-house created IP to a rehash of an old IP serialized by a 3rd party is to create tension and disorient whatever unity already exists within the black tusk studio, not bring the team together. Many people are speculating this move will lead to people leaving the studio. Not the best environment for team-building
- Gears of war 4 [or whatever] can actually be good it really can. We'll see though but I hope they don't feel the need to pander to the already established fanbase which is a concern.
- Black Tusk was created to be MS's newest AAA studio and to make the next big "haloesque" game. That was always their initiative and the move to making the next gears is in many ways a downgrade in the level of trust and view of competency the studio received to make their own big new IP.
Let me ask you this then. You are working on a project you conceived for an entire year. Your boss comes to you and says that jenkins on floor 3 has a better premise for the project so you should shelf your idea completely and follow his because his previous ideas have sold well. That makes you feel good?
1. MS owns the ip now, they no longer have to rush the games out of the gate and can go all out. Create a gears tv series (like halo), continue the gears of war books and merchandise, and sell gangbusters when they release the next gears game. This isn't a short therm, make as much money as we can and drop it sort of deal. If there is another xbox, there will be a gears of war game on it.
2. Or you know, ms would trust black tusk with alternating between a new ip and gears of war after they prove themselves by making a high selling, and high scoring gears game.
3. You missed my point. Gears of war is now one of black tusks franchises. And I'm sure the next game will reflect that. But they aren't limited to only making gears of war games like 343 is with halo.
4. We'll see if they actually start to leave. They no doubt have known that this deal was coming for a while now and there have been no signs of unrest. If they were really forced to make gears of war games for the rest of eternity, they would be leaving by the droves as we speak. That's not what they applied for. The fact that no one is leaving points to a lot of people overreacting right now.
5. The only way they will have to cater to the fanbase is in the gameplay department (and even then, I expect a lot of needed changes). They will get to tell their own story and create their own conflict. They can make Gears of War theirs.
6. Imo the move shows that ms has quite a bit of trust in black tusk. They are being given microsofts second most profitable franchise. But an existing franchise can also be a great place for them to learn the ropes as a team so that when they finally make a new ip, they have a clear goal and can focus on making a game that will be good enough to be a multi-generation franchise.