I'm still surprised at how desperate people are for silent hill, it had way more bad games than good.
Has there even been a good silent hill game since the PS2?
I thought Shattered Memories was pretty good although it definitely has flaws and isn't really an 'authentic' Silent Hill experience. Using the Wii Mote a a flash light is also very enjoyable.
I also like the rendition of the original Silent Hill story, but I get that not everyone likes the re-interpretation. Gameplay is pretty much a predecessor of games like Outcast. So a lot of walking, running and hiding. There are some cool puzzles, but not all are winners.
I think if they used the original pitch it would've turned out much better:
Preserving Details, Screenshots, Videos & more Lost Media for Silent Hill: Cold Heart [Wii - Cancelled Pitch] Help us to remember cancelled video games!
www.unseen64.net
... but apparently Konami didn't want that.