Dang, people on Twitter be salty about Emrakul.
I dunno, I think "I got frustrated by something that's been hashed out many times and demand it be fixed despite having no useful plan to do so" is at least kinda dopey. At least BBD's article offers a proposal, albeit one where the cure is worse than the disease, but usually when this comes up it's just people demanding that IDs be eliminated without considering any of the implications of that change.
Part of the problem with this debate in particular is that a lot of it is driven not by logical consideration of what would make events better, but by an emotional reaction to the perception of impropriety. People get mad that "collusion" or whatever is happening and insist it be stomped out, regardless of the actual impact thereof. I think in reality it's not very productive to take umbrage at people utilizing a well-understood system to their own benefit and the supposed moral failing is largely illusory.
