lol, of course Splinter is tunneling me. He is very smart and incredibly frightening as a scum player. Right now I am coming fresh trying to fill WAMD's shoes so I guess it is up to me to defense myself, right?
Splinter has been very aggressive from the very start and definitely feels like a town leader.
Kalor has been making few but very insightful remarks.
Kyrarunte was playing it very very safe at first and then got very very detailed later on, but his posts got better
Blarg was playing fairly tame, at least in my opinion. This is going to sound weird but I think I would have defended him if it was me playing on Day 1.
OceanicAir has been borderline coasting, but feels townie.
Sawneeks and Stanley are very similar players in my mind, they are heavily opposing Splinter with arguments, while still attacking everything suspicious. Sawneeks specially reeks of town to me.
Star is hard to pinpoint my feeling on her.
Christina feels townie and the few post she makes is to point out bullshit
Melon is playing a very good game in my opinion, even if she was voting WAMD constantly I believe she did because she feels I am scum and I can respect that.
CB has been going from town to scum and back several times since I started reading, but her last few pages make me believe he cares.
I didn't read as much into El Topo as I wanted because I have a really hard time reading him, I don't know why.
Town
2. [m] StanleyPalmtree
5. [f] Sawneeks
6. [m] OceanicAir
8. [m] Kyanrute
10. [f] StarSketch
13. [-] Christina Mackenzie
17. [f] melonrabbit
18. [m] CornBurrito
20. [m] El Topo
I love nin, he is a great Hermano, but he has given literally nothing of value to the game and he has not been self-aware enough to make me believe this is not in purpose.
Karkador has been playing incredibly fluffy and reactionary. He is all over the place and I believe he has been trying to misdirect townie votes into townies.
Kalor, as I said before, has been insightful but I honestly don't trust him, I feel he is playing town.
Ynnek7 is a new player, but has been very reserved and mostly, well, nice. Scum I say.
Scum
4. [m] nin1000
3. [m] Karkador
9. [m] Kalor
12. [m] Ynnek7
I believe Magnum and I believe he is harmless to town.
I think Splinter is also a Neutral and trying to get rid of everything. Something tells me he is going to be a dumb role that has to succeed on a weird condition and for that he is playing anti-town, with priority on surviving by getting all up in our face.
Neutral
1. [m] *Splinter
11. [m] MagnumBoy20xx (I had him as scum before reading his claim)
Now, to talk about WAMD and what it means for me. Fucking lol, you guys are taking her reactions way out of proportion. I would have defended the shit out of her on the first day, it was just such a silly mistake to make that its really only mistake because Splinter has a boner for GOTCHA moments.
And here is the thing, I don't think Splinter actually believes he got scum. What he got was an excuse and a crusade to successfully put a ribbon in his chest as a pro-town player. We all know when you are "caught" in a lie there is very little you can do to prove yourself, because it becomes a catch 22. "Oh, but you are lying, that is why you said a thing." "Oh, but you made a mistake, that is why you said a thing"
The silliest thing about it is that is this game we are so starved for information that I think its more worth it to see the reactions of everyone who latched unto the silly mistake and do a big deal out of it. My scum list is based on those who mostly took that and ran with it, but also who kept adding theories to it.
I know you are all skimming through this post, but here is the thing. You lynched Blarg because you took his mistake and ran with it. You lynched Dusk because he gave you info and ran with it.
This game is been so obviously run by scum that its amazing how, now on Day 3, instead of looking into the new given info you are all going directly for the only person left that made a silly mistake. And notice how is the same 3 players leading the charge.
Splinter
Karkador
Kalor
I'll be here if you need more answers. Also feel free to point out any mistakes I made and put quotes to back them up.
