Amazing trailer. Can't wait to play it, think I overall enjoyed TNO more than the new Doom even.
I always feel like a crazy person whenever a Wolfenstein thread is made, because I feel like the only person of GAF who didn't like New Order and Old Blood.
I mean, I can't deny the story and characters are great. They are and its the best thing about these games.
But the shooting and combat mechanics felt fucking dreadful. Like I genuinely found playing both games felt like a slog and was a miserable experience. None of the combat encounters felt interesting. The locations in New Order felt drab (I know, Nazi Super Concrete aesthetic). Old blood had more interesting locations, but the combat design still felt mediocre.
They feel like games that don't know what they want to be. It's inclusion of a mediocre stealth system makes the game feel like some amalgomation of modern and classic design that feels at odds with itself. Even its health system makes no sense to me with the worthless overcharge mechanic
Honestly, the only reason I have not touched DOOM is because how much I disliked playing both of Machine Games Wolfensteins.
People have said it might be because I played both on console, but honestly I can't get excited for this game.
Will probably just watch the cutscenes on youtube or something.
I can cosign not liking some parts of it. Like you I think the game loses a bit of punch because its blend of stealth and run n gun isn't that smooth. Then there's the XP system which is at best ok when you ignore it but hides some powerful stuff behind challenges that aren't fun. It really feels like an addition that was made because modern games have to have unlocks instead of something that improves the game. I'd sack all of it tbh. Some of the later levels go too hard on making enemies just soak a lot of damage which doesn't make them difficult, just dragged out and with worse hit reactions.
But other than that, I like the combat
a lot in TNO. Good weapon variety, the weapons themselves feel good, there's lots of options for engaging enemies your way including going in heavy instead of peeking behind cover. When the game is about the act of shooting itself I think it excels, especially in the first two thirds of the game.
Anyway, it's fair that you don't like it but I'd suggest that you don't let a sour impression of TNO stop you from playing Doom. They're different games, by different teams. Doom removes all the attempts at mixing the genre with clumsy stealth and the combat pace is faster. Not that it's flawless, even Doom cannot escape the forced unlock systems of modern games except now there's bloody four of them.