Ty4on & Trigger
Ty -
#90 - One of his first posts was in response to Ouro where he called him 'mildly townie' and to be honest I took that as a joke until he clarified here that it wasn't actually a joke. That seems really preemptive?? Then defends it from Crimson by saying it's
best to get reads by seeing other's reads
which I'm assuming means he was trying to simulate discussion. Just seems weird overall.
Ty has a lot of small 'nothing' posts. One word answers, discussion about Vote Tool, shitposts, etc.
Ty -
#227 - Questioning 'huh?' post to Sophia, never follows up or elaborates on it.
Ty -
#242 - Tries to pry into Natiko's pregame discussion with his partner. It's slight role fishing.
Ty -
#258 - Defense to the above; 'It's not fishing since they can just not say anything about PRs!'
Ty -
#263 - 'Vere is cool and Crimson/Sophia are kinda weird but i don't want to push it because meta.'
Ty -
#289 - Bringing up Natiko and Nomad because he is wary they could slip through the cracks. I'm curious as to why this pair was okay to chase but Sophia/Crimson was not?
Ty -
#294 - Ty -I've barely shitposted-4on
Ty -
#296 - IT WAS AN ACCIDENT OKAY. ; __ ;
Ty -
#305 - Tries to explain his shitposts and to reaffirms his early Town Ouro read. Not really scummy here but not feeling Town either, it's just a weird post overall.
Ty -
#355 - Prod vote to Fire
Ty -
#359 - New reads list, no real explanation on his changed read of Sophia/Crimson
Ty -
#430 - Just marking this to say he did question orb a tiny bit. First real questioning he's done all game and it isn't even a lot imo
Ty -
#448 - Votes Kitsune for some reason
Ty -
#492 - Light question towards Worthy
Ty -
#546 - Ty4on wins King of shortest Town reads on people. Town reads Muffin.
Ty -
#637 - more hard-hitting questions from Ty. /s
Ty -
#648 - Somehow Fireblend is better now
Ty -
#689 - Likes Orb for some reason and says he likes Worthy for Meta reasons.
Ty -
#694 - Says Ouro's read of Fire is weird considering Fire didn't do much to earn it. Really amusing coming from Mr. 'Ouro makes one post and I Town Read him for it'.
Ty -
#787 - Lack of vote movement, should bring up Crimson/Sophia to not let them slip but does nothin' about it.
Ty -
#998 - Wants a 'Town Circle' and his top town are Crimson/Sophia
Ty -
#1020 - Impromptu read on Worthy, probably the most in depth read he's made of anyone on Day 1.
Ty -
#1148 - Ty kinda likes Fire and Crimson/Sophia for some reason
Ty -
#1237 - SUDDENLY Muffin and Ouro aren't scum
Ty -
#1305 - Rewrites Darryl's post for some reason, talks to Sorian about he keeps talking about his scum behavior, and then answers one of Kark's questions.
Ty -
#1478 - Votes for Kit which kinda feels out of left field to me. Also asks why he shouldn't vote for them which is an odd question?
Ty -
#1583 - Doesn't like how the vote is now Kark/Xbro vs. Orb/Worthy
Ty -
#1620 - Actually would vote for Kark
Conclusion: Ty talks. A lot. Like I left out most of his posts here because he talks way too much. Thing is, despite all these posts, I'm still oddly 'null' on him. Not feeling scummy but not feeling Townie either. He asks easy questions and often doesn't follow up with them and instead makes light conversation about mechanics, general topics, comments, or how he has played scum in the past with not a ton of Scum Hunting. He also flops his reads around a lot for little to no explanation and calls out Ouro for doing the same exact thing he does in regards to Fireblend. I don't like how he brought up Crimson/Sophia being 'off' early on but never pursues it and suddenly highly town reads them later on. The one thing I will mark that he is consistent for is his Town Read of Orb/Worthy which is purely based on gut or meta reasons depending on which side of that Pair he is talking about.
I don't think he is the scummiest girl at the ball but I wouldn't trust him either.
Trigger -
#697 - Agrees with Darryl's posts but then says he disagrees with them? Fat4all as a null. Town Reads Fire but could see him being scum and then talks himself out of that line of thought? Town vibes from Kitsune vs WAMD but could also see scum. Lot's of wishy-washy, back-and-forth opinions here.
Trigger -
#715 - 'Should have proofread my reads more'
Trigger -
#731 - idk, I find 'haven't fully convinced myself of Vere being town' as a weird choice of words.
Conclusion: I did leave out a couple posts but I felt they were of no real consequence as they were light questions or comments. I do not like Trigger's early reads list that I quoted as it reads being extremely noncommittal to any one stance and he often contradicts himself or talks himself out of his own stance as the read goes on. Reads to me like Scum afraid to make a commitment.
The two combined lead me to a
Light Scum read, namely on Trigger's part and Ty's odd 'null' feeling he's giving me despite being a Top Poster as I expect more from him.
Royal & TsuXna
Royal -
#187 - First post, no comment on Ouro and just dislikes Vere out of the gate.
Royal -
#509 - Calls out Kark for a weird stance on 'No lynch', defends his activity by referring to other games, explains coasters.
Royal -
#517 - Calls out Natiko trying to normalize Nomad's behavior, jokes with Sophia, and more 'No lynch' funsies.
Royal -
#581 - More talk to natiko about Nomad. Pretty much 100% agree with him here and I really like this post.
Royal -
#679 - More Natiko talk ( which I agree with ) and some Dragonz questions.
Royal -
#921 - 'Let's weed out the coasters' post. Mostly a post looking at low post count players and giving thoughts on them. Lots of words but not a ton of stances which I find odd, mostly just being sarcastic and asking people to step it up more.
Royal -
#1436 - Some reads, a vote for kark, Darryl v. Sorian is not W/W, and a disappointed response to Nin's glorious return.
Royal -
#1452 - A good ol' 'who I will vote for vs. who I will not vote for' list. More shade thrown at Vere but does nothing with it.
Royal -
#1627 - First part of his Vere offensive. Comes right in before the End of Day ( seriously, it's in by a minute ) and just leaves his Kark vote where it is.
Conclusion: Since Tsu is a complete nonentity here it's really only on Royal. I really like Royal's early posts where he discusses Nomad with Natiko, they are logical, well thought out, and very concise. The one thing I don't like is his 'weed out the coasters' list as it's essentially a lot of nothing since he doesn't really go anywhere with it, it's just kinda there. He does throw shade at Vere and also never follows up with it until his last post where he begins a read but doesn't have time to finish for it. Also somewhat interesting is the fact that, despite voting for Kark, he never advocates for his lynch and ( what i assume ) instead takes his time beginning his Vere analysis and just lets' the vote be. Feels very much like he didn't care one way or another on how the vote went.
A
Very Light Town Lean. I very much like his early posts and, despite a faltering second half to Day 1, I generally like his tone throughout the Day Phase. He has logical and well thought out posts but I would still like to see more from him given how uncaring he seemed for the Day End vote.
