hey_monkey
Banned
So we focused a lot on Ouro but not much on kingkitty. kitty's posts are hilarious and there's some analysis there, but it's thin and a lot of it is couched in "bellygut" or broad strokes. The readlists are long and look like a lot but there's a lot of hemming and hawing and joking and not just substance. Which, whatever, they're early. But are they scumhunting?
A few things stick in my craw:
After Kark posted his post-count bit, kitty said he was keeping his vote on Ty but would be okay with a Kark death. An hour and a half later, says nah, Kark shouldn't be killed because the gambit was too lame. But not a whole lot changed between those posts. kitty changed his vote to Orb at that point based on his reads, but this was the read:
This is what I'm talking about. There's a lot of words here but not a lot of substance. Orb and TWE didn't seem like much? Well, yeah, they didn't post much. Dragonz at one point said kitty was being pretty obvious (with another observation) and he struck back saying her reaction was weird. But this stuff is basic. And "weird" is kitty's most common descriptor, which... see below.
There's this, too:
Partly, this is the danger of doing early readlists (I've done it, too); everyone is null or little things become big. But everyone being suspicious? But I feel like this is a scummier position than not. Scum wants to keep the suspicion spread out, keep town pointing fingers and yelling.
This is kitty's vote on d2. Wasn't around for day end, which is fine, lots of people haven't. But it just seems like so much air. There's some analysis in there but it's largely summary and feelings.
Now, this post actually has some analysis, and it touches on the silencer (and scenarios with Kark and Sorian and Ty). I wonder if kitty has any updated thoughts since they've reported being hit with it.
A few things stick in my craw:
After Kark posted his post-count bit, kitty said he was keeping his vote on Ty but would be okay with a Kark death. An hour and a half later, says nah, Kark shouldn't be killed because the gambit was too lame. But not a whole lot changed between those posts. kitty changed his vote to Orb at that point based on his reads, but this was the read:
This is what I'm talking about. There's a lot of words here but not a lot of substance. Orb and TWE didn't seem like much? Well, yeah, they didn't post much. Dragonz at one point said kitty was being pretty obvious (with another observation) and he struck back saying her reaction was weird. But this stuff is basic. And "weird" is kitty's most common descriptor, which... see below.
There's this, too:
Partly, this is the danger of doing early readlists (I've done it, too); everyone is null or little things become big. But everyone being suspicious? But I feel like this is a scummier position than not. Scum wants to keep the suspicion spread out, keep town pointing fingers and yelling.
This is kitty's vote on d2. Wasn't around for day end, which is fine, lots of people haven't. But it just seems like so much air. There's some analysis in there but it's largely summary and feelings.
Now, this post actually has some analysis, and it touches on the silencer (and scenarios with Kark and Sorian and Ty). I wonder if kitty has any updated thoughts since they've reported being hit with it.
