• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

I really don't understand recharging the sixaxis.

It just doesn't make any sense. Why would you make a wireless controller that must be plugged into the console, when the console is on, just to recharge it? Let's look at some examples of common sense rechargeable controller design so you can understand where I'm coming from.

The Xbox360 wireless controller is a pretty good design because you have a removable battery that can be charged in it's own charger station. This makes sense because I NEVER need to plus the Xbox360 wireless controller into anything at all. I simply swap my dead battery out for a fully charged one.

The Sega Surfwave Dualshock for the PS2. Not only does it feature better rumble than the dual shock, it's also wireless via 2xAA batteries. The really great thing is that the controller can last around 1000 hours before you need to swap in fresh batteries. Also, it's connection is as good or better than the Xbox360 wireless controller mentioned above.

The Nintendo Wavebird for the GC was also a great wireless controller that could last around 100 hours on 2xAA batteries.


* I could use a charge station for the controller, but there are two problems with them. The first, and most obvious, is that they simply don't half work. The other problem is that I must leave the controller itself plugged into the charger. This sounds ok on paper, but in practice doesn't make any logical sense because you either have to go and get the controller from the charger, if it is in a different location than your coffee table, or you might as well leave the controller plugged into the PS3 since the charger needs to be on your coffee table anyway.

* The only option I can come up with that makes any logical sense would be to just purchase two controllers. Leaving one plugged into the PS3 at all times, then switching one out when needed. This technically makes your wireless controller about $100, but until Sony comes out with a better model it's the only viable solution I can think of.

So what have we learned in this thread? Hopefully NOTHING because most of us have enough sense to know that the Sixaxis wireless design is retarded. For those that don't... well, no offense.
 
Wait, the Sixaxis has to be plugged in while the console is on? What a waste of energy. They should have made a separate recharging dock.

EDIT: Never mind, I guess TC is wrong :D
 
I'm actually surprised that I haven't seen many complaints on this issue. When I had the PS3, I recharged the battery through my PC, but that's not really convenient. Though it's much better than having the PS3 on and charging it with the 4 inch USB cable.
 
Personally i think the ps3 has the best wireless power solution.

When the battery goes flat, you plug it in to the ps3 and can keep playing, when the batteries are charged , you can go wireless again.

I get pissed when my Wiimote is flat and iv already used every AA battery in sight so cant play at all till i charge some in my seperate charger.
 
I charge it via the USB port in my cable box which is always on. :)

Learn about the powers and advantages of the Universal Serial Bus!

I personally believe Sony has the best charging solution because I do not need to go out and buy charge kits or batteries. The only down side is that I'll need to toss out the controller when the Lithium On battery fails to take good charges. Fortunately, by then I can pick up the SIXAXIS with rumble :D
 
so you're basically saying you would rather have batteries?

I have no problem with charging it via usb. everything has usb these days, even cable/satelite receiver boxes.
 
goomba said:
Personally i think the ps3 has the best wireless power solution.

When the battery goes flat, you plug it in to the ps3 and can keep playing, when the batteries are charged , you can go wireless again.

I get pissed when my Wiimote is flat and iv already used every AA battery in sight so cant play at all till i charge some in my seperate charger.


last time i checked i played games more than 3 feet away from my console.
 
emacs said:
because this is pretty much a non-issue

I disagree completely. What happens if you run out of juice in the middle of the game? Please don't tell me you guys actually play a feet within range of the PS3 to charge and play

1 question, is the battery lithium or nickel?
 
I have no problems whatsoever with charging my ps3 controller. Between play sessions, I charge it, and I've never had it go low or die on me.
 
Bad_Boy said:
so you're basically saying you would rather have batteries?

I have no problem with charging it via usb. everything has usb these days, even cable/satelite receiver boxes.

Thank you. And if you have problem with it, why don't you run Folding@Home. Charge your batteries and serve humanity one DNA at a time... :)

Also, consider battery charges in 15 - 30 minutes, its never been an issue with me.
 
While I agree it's weird the PS3 has to be on (that is something they will hopefully address) ...


... you can charge them using anything with USB.
 
Wario64 said:
I disagree completely. What happens if you run out of juice in the middle of the game? Please don't tell me you guys actually play 4 feet within range of the PS3 to charge and play

1 question, is the battery lithium or nickel?

Lithium Ion which is a bit weird since Lithium Ion likes frequent charges and not the full discharge and recharge pattern of a typical gaming scenario. The only reason I could see as to why they chose Lithium Ion was for the size limitations.
 
The worse part is the 1 foot cable. If you're deep into a game and want to keep playing but your controller is about to die, you'll need to play from about a foot away from your PS3/TV while it's charging.


edit: beaten
 
Bad_Boy said:
so you're basically saying you would rather have batteries?

I'm just saying, yeah a removable battery with a charge station like the Xbox360 wireless controller would make sense. Using a USB port to charge it is just plain retarded because you have the same problem, wires. It's just an inconvenient, and redundant, solution to plug wires into a wireless controller.
 
goomba said:
Personally i think the ps3 has the best wireless power solution.

When the battery goes flat, you plug it in to the ps3 and can keep playing, when the batteries are charged , you can go wireless again.

I get pissed when my Wiimote is flat and iv already used every AA battery in sight so cant play at all till i charge some in my seperate charger.
1) how is that any different from the 360 with P&C (oh wait, other than the option of just swapping a fresh battery)?

2) how can you not see the obvious shortcoming of having a wiimote plugged into anything?
 
When I'm playing with one controller, the other is charging! If my system isn't on, I plug it in my laptop/desktop/etc. Holy shit - magic!

I'd rather not deal with batteries and shit you have to take out.
 
i bought a 5 meter usb extension cable, works like a charm and only costed me like 10 euros. plus i can extend any cable i want now, for later accesoires :)
 
MidgarBlowedUp said:
I'm just saying, yeah a removable battery with a charge station like the Xbox360 wireless controller would make sense. Using a USB port to charge it is just plain retarded because you have the same problem, wires. It's just an inconvenient, and redundant, solution to plug wires into a wireless controller.

I am not the only one who believes this is just knitpicking and being silly, am I? =/
 
No_Style said:
Lithium Ion which is a bit weird since Lithium Ion likes frequent charges and not the full discharge and recharge pattern of a typical gaming scenario. The only reason I could see as to why they chose Lithium Ion was for the size limitations.

Isn't it actually "better" to have a battery like that in a gaming scenario? I mean, I'd rather charge it anytime I can rather than having to wait for it to be fully depleted.
 
VALIS said:
The worse part is the 1 foot cable. If you're deep into a game and want to keep playing but your controller is about to die, you'll need to play from about a foot away from your PS3/TV while it's charging.


edit: beaten

people complain about the length of the cable, but you could pretty much go and buy a longer USB 2 cable and it will work, its not like they are expensive.
 
I do typically only play single player games, but I have two SIXAXIS controllers... so I usually swap them out. I also leave my machine on Folding when I'm not using it... I probably share controller charging duties 50/50 between my PS3 and my PC. Really, with the 360, Wii, PS3, and the various PCs in my house, there is always a free powered USB port handy... not to mention my wife's MP3 player has a wallwart USB charging port.

So yeah, whoever said this isn't really an issue... I'm with him.
 
Wario64 said:
I disagree completely. What happens if you run out of juice in the middle of the game?

pause the game. connect controller to my three (3) metre USB cable. resume game.


1 question, is the battery lithium or nickel?

last i read, it's lithium. most likely due to design / price consideration
 
VALIS said:
The worse part is the 1 foot cable. If you're deep into a game and want to keep playing but your controller is about to die, you'll need to play from about a foot away from your PS3/TV while it's charging.


edit: beaten


I agree.

That's why a while back when I happened to be making an Amazon order, I also ordered two long-ass USB cables ... they were under $10.
 
I usually just plug it in and charge it while I am watching a blu-ray movie, or through the PC. I've never had it run out of power to the point of having to play with it plugged in.
 
Greg said:
When I'm playing with one controller, the other is charging! If my system isn't on, I plug it in my laptop/desktop/etc. Holy shit - magic!

I'd rather not deal with batteries and shit you have to take out.

So you have to buy two controllers?
 
I'm sorry but you sound lazy as ****. Get a longer usb cable if thats the real issue.
It's actually pretty convenient to me that I don't have to replace AA batteries.
 
The Faceless Master said:
1) how is that any different from the 360 with P&C (oh wait, other than the option of just swapping a fresh battery)?
You don't need a proprietary adapter. Though being able to toss in a couple AAs or battery pack is very convenient.
 
shagg_187 said:
Also, consider battery charges in 15 - 30 minutes, its never been an issue with me.

Which scenario makes more sense.

Q. I'm in the middle of a boss fight and my battery is almost dead. What do I do?

A. Pause the game, then get up off the couch and plug my controller into the PS3 so I can wait for 30 minutes before I start playing again?

or

B. I was smart and have a USB extension cord so I can just plug the cable in while I'm sitting on the couch without missing a beat? (If your going to do this then why bother unplugging it in the first place?)
 
No_Style said:
Lithium Ion which is a bit weird since Lithium Ion likes frequent charges and not the full discharge and recharge pattern of a typical gaming scenario. The only reason I could see as to why they chose Lithium Ion was for the size limitations.

In my experience Lithium Ion works great for either scenario which is why most things now use LI batteries instead of the Nickel ones (which only like full charges).

As for the charging issue on the PS3. I believe a company has (or will soon) released a thing to plug into a wall outlet to charge PS3 controllers.

MidgarBlowedUp said:
B. I was smart and have a USB extension cord so I can just plug the cable in while I'm sitting on the couch without missing a beat? (If your going to do this then why bother unplugging it in the first place?)

I do this sometimes and the reason I don't keep it plugged in all the time is because I hate cables. HATE THEM. So I prefer going wireless but don't mind plugging in to charge and play.
 
goomba said:
Personally i think the ps3 has the best wireless power solution.

When the battery goes flat, you plug it in to the ps3 and can keep playing, when the batteries are charged , you can go wireless again.

Exactly like the 360 wireless controller, then, eh?
 
Like who doesn't have two controllers? Plug one in when its low thats all. With a little thought this won't ever be a problem, even when your playing against someone else split screen, or something. The more controllers you have, the more of a non issue this is.
 
MidgarBlowedUp said:
and plug my controller into the PS3 so I can wait for 30 minutes before I start playing again?


no.

when the controller is connected via USB you can use it normally because the power is drawn from the PS3. charging will occur while you play.
 
TTP said:
Isn't it actually "better" to have a battery like that in a gaming scenario? I mean, I'd rather charge it anytime I can rather than having to wait for it to be fully depleted.

For the average joe, not so much so. I mean, a lot of people probably do not even know that it is Lithium Ion based and they usually play until it is drained out which hurts the battery life.

For you and I, it is a great idea if you remember to keep it charged up. Relative, I guess.

Info about Lithium Ion charging here.
 
Bad_Boy said:
I'm sorry but you sound lazy as ****. Get a longer usb cable if thats the real issue.
It's actually pretty convenient to me that I don't have to replace AA batteries.

But if I get the longer cable I can't walk infront of my coffe table without tripping over the cord. And I'm not lazy, I just want convenience and practicality..
OK so I'm ****ing lazy, but my points are valid.
 
Karma Kramer said:
So you have to buy two controllers?
Greg said:
When I'm playing with one controller, the other is charging! If my system isn't on, I plug it in my laptop/desktop/etc. Holy shit - magic!
No, you have to have a USB slot somewhere - and since we all have computers, it's safe to assume that an open slot it available.

I've played some long PS3 sessions, and I have yet to come close to running the battery dead in one sitting. If you can run it dead in one session, pat yourself on the back and take a trip to the nearest USB port.
 
Also, consider battery charges in 15 - 30 minutes, its never been an issue with me.

Whaaaat? That's it? I just got my PS3 and have only had to change it the initial time, but it seemed to take forever to fully charge. After the battery gets worked in a bit, is 15-30 minutes all it takes?
 
MidgarBlowedUp said:
But if I get the longer cable I can't walk infront of my coffe table without tripping over the cord. And I'm not lazy, I just want convenience and practicality..
OK so I'm ****ing lazy, but my points are valid.



?
 
MidgarBlowedUp said:
But if I get the longer cable I can't walk infront of my coffe table without tripping over the cord. And I'm not lazy, I just want convenience and practicality..
OK so I'm ****ing lazy, but my points are valid.

:lol
 
No_Style said:
For the average joe, not so much so. I mean, a lot of people probably do not even know that it is Lithium Ion based and they usually play until it is drained out which hurts the battery life.

For you and I, it is a great idea if you remember to keep it charged up. Relative, I guess.

Info about Lithium Ion charging here.

Good point about the avarage Joe.

I'm actually used to keep them fully charged but I can see people charging them only when needed.
 
MidgarBlowedUp said:
But if I get the longer cable I can't walk infront of my coffe table without tripping over the cord. And I'm not lazy, I just want convenience and practicality..
OK so I'm ****ing lazy, but my points are valid.
:lol joke post?
 
Top Bottom