• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

NeoGAF 2011 TV Show of the Year ~Results!~

Status
Not open for further replies.
R

RatskyWatsky

Hunky Nostradamus
All done by hand. :)

Top Ten

Breaking Bad

uJ9Djl.jpg


Game of Thrones

MtcyIl.jpg


Louie

AOuFMl.jpg


Homeland

CkGSSl.jpg


Community

Cb4Xzl.jpg


Parks and Recreation

3iXNjl.jpg


Boardwalk Empire

rLZYPl.jpg


The Walking Dead

4vNWIl.jpg


Curb Your Enthusiasm

zUIOml.jpg


Justified

xJk3el.jpg


FORMAT: Rank, Name, # of votes, # of points

01: Breaking Bad - 150 - 1361
02: Game of Thrones - 157 - 1299
03: Louie - 90 - 660
04: Homeland - 82 - 654
05: Community - 82 - 569
06: Parks and Recreation - 78 - 540
07: Boardwalk Empire - 68 - 502
08: The Walking Dead - 50 - 296
09: Curb Your Enthusiasm - 46 - 279
10: Justified - 36 - 250
11: Archer - 39 - 248
12: Fringe - 32 - 201
13: It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - 32 - 185
14: Modern Family - 30 - 143
15: Doctor Who - 16 - 115
16: Treme - 14 - 89
17: South Park - 19 - 87
18: Adventure Time - 13 - 86
18: Spartacus Gods of the Arena - 13 - 86
19: Happy Endings - 18 - 81
20: Dexter - 16 - 78
21: American Horror Story - 12 - 78
22: Sons of Anarchy - 18 - 75
23: Enlightened - 11 - 74
24: Beavis and Butt-Head - 12 - 67
25: Downton Abbey - 12 - 59
26: Luther - 11 - 56
27: Burn Notice - 9 - 55
28: Futurama - 9 - 53
29: Black Mirror - 7 - 50
30: The Good Wife - 12 - 49
31: American Dad - 10 - 48
32: Workaholics - 9 - 47
33: The Daily Show - 9 - 46
34: Once Upon A Time - 5 - 45
35: Person of Interest - 9 - 43
36: Psych - 6 - 41
37: The Vampire Diaries - 5 - 41
38: Misfits - 8 - 39
39: New Girl - 9 - 38
40: The League - 8 - 38
41: Suits - 6 - 38
42: Regular Show - 8 - 37
43: How I Met Your Mother - 7 - 37
44: White Collar - 7 - 36
45: Raising Hope - 7 - 35
46: WWE Raw - 4 - 35
47: Revenge - 7 - 34
48: QI - 5 - 34
49: Nikita - 6 - 33
50: Bored to Death - 5 - 32
51: Frozen Planet - 4 - 32
52: Shameless - 8 - 31
53: Supernatural - 5 - 31
54: Wilfred - 6 - 30
55: No Reservations - 5 - 29
56: The Office - 8 - 28
57: An Idiot Abroad - 6 - 28
57: True Blood - 6 - 28
58: How To Make it in America - 5 - 28
59: The Killing - 5 - 26
60: Californication - 5 - 25
61: Southland - 4 - 25
62: Portlandia - 6 - 23
63: The Colbert Report - 5 - 22
63: Entourage - 5 - 22
64: Top Gear UK - 5 - 20
65: Human Planet - 2 - 18
65: NCIS - 2 - 18
66: Alphas - 4 - 16
67: Sym-Bionic Titan - 2 - 15
67: Damages - 2 - 15
68: The Borgias - 4 - 14
68: Hell on Wheels - 4 - 14
69: Chuck - 3 - 14
69: Strike Back (Project Dawn) - 3 - 14
69: House - 3 - 14
70: Children's Hospital - 3 - 13
71: 2 Broke Girls - 3 - 12
72: Life's Too Short UK - 2 - 12
72: Jeopardy - 2 - 12
73: Castle - 3 - 11
73: Survivor - 3 - 11
73: Top Chef - 3 - 11
74: American Pickers - 2 - 10
74: Awkward - 2 - 10
75: Steins' Gate - 1 - 10
75: Ancient Aliens - 1 - 10
75: This is England 88 - 1 - 10
75: Tegenlicht (Backlight) - 1 - 10
75: TNA iMPACT - 1 - 10
75: My Little Pony: FIM - 1 - 10
75: Pretty Little Liars - 1 - 10
75: The Hamster Wheel - 1 - 10
75: Vampire Prosecutor - 1 - 10
75: Frontline - 1 - 10
75: The Ricky Gervais Show - 1 - 10
76: Lights Out - 4 - 9
76: Family Guy - 4 - 9
77: Warehouse 13 - 2 - 9
78: Superjail! - 1 - 9
78: Curiosity - 1 - 9
78: Andere Tijden (Different Times) - 1 - 9
78: iCarly - 1 - 9
78: Desperate Housewives - 1 - 9
78: The Shadow Line - 1 - 9
78: The Hour - 1 - 9
78: NFL Red Zone - 1 - 9
79: Bob's Burgers - 2 - 8
80: 90210 - 1 - 8
80: Fear Factor - 1 - 8
80: Ringer - 1 - 8
80: Prohibition - 1 - 8
80: The Universe - 1 - 8
80: Parenthood - 1 - 8
81: The Soup - 3 - 7
82: Pardon the Interruption - 2 - 7
82: Glee - 2 - 7
82: The Big Bang Theory - 2 - 7
83: Terra Nova - 1 - 7
83: Rizzoli and Isles - 1 - 7
83: Would I Lie To You? - 1 - 7
83: Sports Show w/ Norm MacDonald - 1 - 7
84: Mildred Pierce - 2 - 6
85: The Mentalist - 1 - 6
85: The Sing Off - 1 - 6
85: Ugly Americans - 1 - 6
85: Good Eats - 1 - 6
85: The Fabric of the Cosmos - 1 - 6
85: Boss - 1 - 6
85: Wheel of Fortune - 1 - 6
85: Young Justice - 1 - 6
85: Grey's Anatomy - 1 - 6
86: Leverage - 2 - 5
87: WWE Smackdown - 1 - 5
87: Thorn Birds - 1 - 5
87: Without You - 1 - 5
87: Suburgatory - 1 - 5
87: Skins UK - 1 - 5
88: Spooks - 2 - 4
89: The Closer - 1 - 4
89: Real Time w/ Bill Maher - 1 - 4
90: Being Human UK - 2 - 3
91: Shooting Stars - 1 - 3
91: Big Love - 1 - 3
91: Degrassi - 1 - 3
91: The Apprentice UK - 1 - 3
91: Jon Benjamin Has A Van - 1 - 3
91: Onion News Network - 1 - 3
92: The Simpsons - 2 - 2
93: The Fades - 1 - 2
93: Case Histories - 1 - 2
93: The Challenge: Rivals - 1 - 2
93: The Late Late Show w/ Craig F - 1 - 2
93: Eureka - 1 - 2
93: Ax Men - 1 - 2
93: Saturday Night Live - 1 - 2
94: In Plain Sight - 1 - 1
94: Restaurant Impossible - 1 - 1
94: The Next Food Network Star - 1 - 1
94: Greek - 1 - 1
94: America in Primetime - 1 - 1
94: Upstairs, Downstairs - 1 - 1
94: Pete Vs Life - 1 - 1
94: Top Chef Canada - 1 - 1
94: Up All Night - 1 - 1
 
Nuts, missed the voting for this. I would have gone Game of Thrones as #1, but the list overall is good, even though I don't care for comedy shows much.
 
Nice to see Justified make the list, Community has been pretty poor for a while now though.
 
Pretty great top 10 list, except for TWD and Justified (which I'm not shitting on, just haven't seen any of it past the pilot).
 
01: Breaking Bad - 150 - 1361
02: Game of Thrones - 157 - 1299
03: Louie - 90 - 660
04: Homeland - 82 - 654
05: Community - 82 - 569
06: Parks and Recreation - 78 - 540
07: Boardwalk Empire - 68 - 502
08: The Walking Dead - 50 - 296
09: Curb Your Enthusiasm - 46 - 279
10: Justified - 36 - 250
11: Archer - 39 - 248
12: Fringe - 32 - 201
13: It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - 32 - 185
14: Modern Family - 30 - 143
15: Doctor Who - 16 - 115
16: Treme - 14 - 89
17: South Park - 19 - 87
18: Adventure Time - 13 - 86
18: Spartacus Gods of the Arena - 13 - 86
19: Happy Endings - 18 - 81
20: Dexter - 16 - 78
21: American Horror Story - 12 - 78
22: Sons of Anarchy - 18 - 75
23: Enlightened - 11 - 74
24: Beavis and Butt-Head - 12 - 67
25: Downton Abbey - 12 - 59
26: Luther - 11 - 56
27: Burn Notice - 9 - 55
28: Futurama - 9 - 53
29: Black Mirror - 7 - 50
30: The Good Wife - 12 - 49
31: American Dad - 10 - 48
32: Workaholics - 9 - 47
33: The Daily Show - 9 - 46
34: Once Upon A Time - 5 - 45
35: Person of Interest - 9 - 43
36: Psych - 6 - 41
37: The Vampire Diaries - 5 - 41
38: Misfits - 8 - 39
39: New Girl - 9 - 38
40: The League - 8 - 38
41: Suits - 6 - 38
42: Regular Show - 8 - 37
43: How I Met Your Mother - 7 - 37
44: White Collar - 7 - 36
45: Raising Hope - 7 - 35
46: WWE Raw - 4 - 35
47: Revenge - 7 - 34
48: QI - 5 - 34
49: Nikita - 6 - 33
50: Bored to Death - 5 - 32
Click to expand...

Good job, GAF! Can't wait for the Primetime GAFies!
 
Good job, guys. Breaking Bad is no surprise, but it's deserving. Parks and Recs shouldn't be below Community, but aside from that it's solid. I'll have to check out Homeland and Justified.
 
Black Mirror breaks the top 30, fuck yeah. Whenever some channel eventually shows that, RoW-GAF, you need to watch it. Or at the very least, watch '15 Million Merits'.

Anyway, TWD aside, that's a mighty fine Top 10. Good to see Community-GAF outshine Parks-GAF. ;)

edit: who the fuck voted iCarly
 
Walking Dead in the top ten is EMBARRASSING. Game of thrones should be much lower and Enlightened should be top five notsry2say.

EDIT: btw, great job Ratskywatsky! :)
 
As decent a list as I was expecting! AHS is far too high, as is The Walking Dead. Happy Endings deserves a bump up. Portlandia and Southland and Onion News and Childrens Hospital all deserve a bit higher. But a good list nonetheless.
crimzonflame said:
This Louie show is good? I like CK but never watched his show.
Click to expand...
PLEASE GO WATCH IT RIGHT NOW. CAPS NECESSARY.
 
Great top 10, I started watching Justified after voting on it, I would have put it instead of The Walking Dead, which I don't think deserves a place in there, but the rest looks fair.

I'm a huge Louie fan, but Homeland should have gotten 3rd place!
 
Judderman said:
Wait, people hate The Walking Dead on GAF now? Damn I'm behind on my "What GAF hates" news.
Click to expand...

In all fairness, I have a tendency to carry on watching long after its gone down the toilet (I watched all of Heroes except the last series) and even I bailed out after S1.
 
Just started watching Breaking Bad and I'm only up to the third episode of season 3. Spoilers ahead...

And I'm pretty surprised at just how many people Walt is responsible for the death of. The first 2 drug dealers, the dealer that he made Jesse work on someone else's territory, Jesse's gf, 2 planes full of people

The body count so far

Walt=170 or so
Jesse=1 if you count Tuco as his
 
Judderman said:
Wait, people hate The Walking Dead on GAF now? Damn I'm behind on my "What GAF hates" news.
Click to expand...
People were disliking it starting with the second episode of the show, and justifiably so. The show has demonstrated over and over that it doesn't know how to pace out arcs or characterize properly/consistently. I will say that season 2 has made Shane very very interesting, but he's the only standout.
I H8 Memes said:
Just started watching Breaking Bad and I'm only up to the third episode of season 3. Spoilers ahead...

And I'm pretty surprised at just how many people Walt is responsible for the death of. The first 2 drug dealers, the dealer that he made Jesse work on someone else's territory, Jesse's gf, 2 planes full of people

The body count so far

Walt=170 or so
Jesse=1 if you count Tuco as his
Click to expand...
Continued breaking bad spoilers
Yeah, but don't tell some fans of the show that. There are people who still think Walter is a good guy. I feel bad for them; they're missing the entire point of the show.
 
Didn't even know this was going on, but good job gaf. Only of those in the top 10 is not like the others (and I'm not talking about Boardwalk which I've kind of decided isn't my cup of tea).
 
Green Scar said:
Black Mirror breaks the top 30, fuck yeah. Whenever some channel eventually shows that, RoW-GAF, you need to watch it. Or at the very least, watch '15 Million Merits'.

Anyway, TWD aside, that's a mighty fine Top 10. Good to see Community-GAF outshine Parks-GAF. ;)

edit: who the fuck voted iCarly
Click to expand...

iCarly is better than The Walking Dead.
 
Pretty good list. I wish I saw the voting thread and voted for Homeland, since it looks pretty darn close to the no.3 spot.
 
Breaking Bad and Louie are basically the best things to watch. Ever.
 
big ander said:
People were disliking it starting with the second episode of the show, and justifiably so. The show has demonstrated over and over that it doesn't know how to pace out arcs or characterize properly/consistently. I will say that season 2 has made Shane very very interesting, but he's the only standout.

Continued breaking bad spoilers
Yeah, but don't tell some fans of the show that. There are people who still think Walter is a good guy. I feel bad for them; they're missing the entire point of the show.
Click to expand...


Really? I haven't been following the BB thread, but you can tell from his mannerisms that Walt doesn't believe his own BS when he is trying to explain away his and Jesse's responsibility in these messes. It's one of my favorite parts of the show to see him do that.
 
I'm surprised by how few votes Boardwalk Empire got. Do people just not watch it or is it just not as accessible as something like Game of Thrones?

xbhaskarx said:
TV-GAF embarrasses itself by putting The Walking Dead into the top 10...
Click to expand...
Seriously. I wanted to like it. I really, really tried. But after season 2 proved to be just as bad, I had to bail. It just seems like the writers, producers, etc. must be relatively untalented. The writing is outclassed by pretty much everything else on AMC, HBO, FX, Showtime, etc.
 
Poor Archer, three points away from making the Top 10

With the exception of TWD, really have no qualms with the Top 10
since I only watch four of them, including TWD >_>
 
The Walking Dead shouldn't be on there, but 9 out of 10 is still a great list.

Pleasantly surprised to see Treme so close to the top 10. I thought GAF members didn't like the show all that much.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Jimmy Olsen + Gorilla Grodd TV series from American Vandal showrunners confirmed and shooting this year
2
216
DeafTourette replied
Goddammit Donut, we are gonna be a Peacock TV show!!!!!
7
470
falconhoof replied
Dark Angel TV Show... Opinions
14
979
SirKicksalot replied
Mayday - Apple TV movie
3
20
Spyxos replied
Europe chooses to die on the hill of no air conditioning for another year of record heat waves
6 7 8 9 10
466
2K
StreetsofBeige replied
Top Bottom