Well, considering PT is lauded as one of the best survival horror experiences gaming has ever seen
I'm sorry, but do people actually believe this? I can't see PT being up there with the likes of Silent Hill 2 and other great survival horror games. Don't even get me started on its design (which yes, I know it was intentionally obtuse) which I can't believe would have someone even calling it a great game.
It was a great experience in gaming all together, what with the community working together and all that, but beyond that it as a game, survival horror or otherwise, it isn't deserving of the praise it gets. But then again I think Five Nights at Freddy's is terrible but some parts of the gaming community would gut me for saying that.
Also why is this happening? If you download/purchase content doesn't it remain on your download list forever (well, as long as the servers for the service remain anyways) with the publishers not being able to do a thing to take it from you? Why are people selling entire consoles instead of just PSN accounts? You could make a huge amount of PSN accounts and just download PT to them.