• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

TMZ: Carrie Fisher suffers cardiac arrest on plane (Up: in ICU, condition unknown)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Empty

Member
Also, re: TMZ's reporting - for as low as their reputation tends to be in almost all other aspects, the one thing they seem to have their shit almost 100% together on is celebrity deaths. Ghoulish as that is, they tend to be very accurate, and usually first, as well.

they basically run an intelligence agency in los angeles. there was a new yorker article this year that talked about how they have sources at most of the major hospitals, airlines, hotels, limo services etc who know tmz will pay well and reliably for scoops.
 

thebeeks

Banned
She came to Salt Lake Comic con and was absolutely amazing to fans. She sat at her booth for hours and made sure every little girl met Princess Leia.

Man this is rough.

She came to Dallas Comic Con last year but I didn't get a chance to see her.

I thought "that's okay, I'll see her next time around".

I thought I had more time...
 

Boke1879

Member
In a lot of cases, TMZ is paying people for these scoops. So it's not like they're uninvolved.

Also "just doing a job" isn't a thing.

I mean they are providing information that a lot of people digest. I do agree they go too far. I think there should be some sort of privacy in these situations, but they aren't doing anything illegal, and they are hardly the only ones to do this.
 

Raxus

Member
If she survives, she will most likely be a vegetable or very disabled. 15 minutes without oxygen to the brain is very scary.

Damn.

Keep in mind CPR circulates O2 in the blood while a patient is down and preserves tissue. Thankfully there were nurses on the plane to attend to her.
 

mjc

Member
Have faith in the medical professionals looking after her, it does no good to think negatively right now.
 

FaintDeftone

Junior Member
My dad suffered a stroke and stopped breathing for over 20min and still survived. He suffered from short term memory loss and confusion afterwards, but he lived for two years after. Hopefully she'll survive this with little damage.
 

m0dus

Banned
If she survives, she will most likely be a vegetable or very disabled. 15 minutes without oxygen to the brain is very scary.

Damn.

Don't make assumptions on what little relevant information is currently available.

Also changing the thread title, as 'heart attack' doesn't actually describe what transpired.
 

Ambient80

Member
Keep in mind CPR circulates O2 in the blood while a patient is down and preserves tissue. Thankfully there were nurses on the plane to attend to her.
While true, was it one person giving CPR for 15 minutes? Cause if it was, then I doubt it was particularly good CPR the entire time. It is EXHAUSTING to give CPR for too long. That's why in hospitals they usually have 2-3 very strong people rotating every couple minutes.
 
I'm hoping for the best. Unfortunately, have experience with this.
So do the people doing CPR

While true, was it one person giving CPR for 15 minutes? Cause if it was, then I doubt it was particularly good CPR the entire time. It is EXHAUSTING to give CPR for too long. That's why in hospitals they usually have 2-3 very strong people rotating every couple minutes.
I believe TMZ said "nurses"
 

m0dus

Banned
Dude. It's 15 minutes without proper oxygen supply to the brain. I don't like being pessimistic but there's no way someone can pull through "just fine" from this.

I've seen people go through worse, be coded longer, and come out just fine. I've helped resuscitate people after only a few minutes who have suffered permanent debility. The causes and outcomes are as numerous as grains of sand on a beach.

Don't make assumptions. Just wait for an update.
 
While true, was it one person giving CPR for 15 minutes? Cause if it was, then I doubt it was particularly good CPR the entire time. It is EXHAUSTING to give CPR for too long. That's why in hospitals they usually have 2-3 very strong people rotating every couple minutes.
Apparently, there were a couple nurses on board too. And you'd think there would be a few people with First Aid training on board as well. So hopefully they were giving good chest compressions the entire time.
 
V

Vilix

Unconfirmed Member
Don't make assumptions on what little relevant information is currently available.

Also changing the thread title, as 'heart attack' doesn't actually describe what transpired.

I wish we knew more. I'm upset no news source is covering this. It's all about Trump right now. Pfft.
 

TheYanger

Member
Don't make assumptions on what little relevant information is currently available.

Also changing the thread title, as 'heart attack' doesn't actually describe what transpired.

Unless the information we do have is flat out wrong, it's not an assumption. This is almost a certainty that she's going to be brain damaged at best :( Not saying she couldn't be ok cause who knows, but...you know that's not good.
 

Kindekuma

Banned
I've seen people go through worse, be coded longer, and come out just fine. I've helped resuscitate people after only a few minutes who have suffered permanent debility. The causes and outcomes are as numerous as grains of sand on a beach.

Don't make assumptions. Just wait for an update.

Right. I don't usually hold out hope for this kind of stuff, maybe I should just hold reservations until more updates.
 

MattKeil

BIGTIME TV MOGUL #2
?? They're talking about hiking up mountains and stuff. Did you really think that altitude affects the thinness of the air inside the plane? o_O

Air inside a plane at cruising altitude is about the same as air in Denver. Pretty thin compared to what most of us are used to.
 

Ambient80

Member
So do the people doing CPR


I believe TMZ said "nurses"

Ah, well that's at least somewhat reassuring. The few times I was involved in a code in med school I was usually on chest compression duty and damn it is ROUGH, lol.

EDIT: To give people an idea, I've had people say "If you're not legitimately trying to palate the person's spine through their chest, then your compressions aren't good enough." It is a very tough job. Broken ribs, punctured lungs, etc are not uncommon. I hope she pulls through ok :(
 

SuperSah

Banned
My thoughts go to her and her family. It's Christmas, a time for celebration and good times - this should not be how things go.
 

mjc

Member
Ah, well that's at least somewhat reassuring. The few times I was involved in a code in med school I was usually on chest compression duty and damn it is ROUGH, lol.

Yeah it can be pretty damn tiring, I imagine the nurses could have grabbed a few people to help coordinate and stand in if they got tired.
 

GJS

Member
CPR is not as effective as people have come to believe... That's also why DNACPR is a thing, the risk/benefit/success is quickly outweighed as people get older.

Depending on the studies you look at generally only around 2% to 10% of people survive after receiving CPR.
 

Roders5

Iwata een bom zal droppen
God damn it, poor Carrie. The impact the OT had on me cannot be overstated. I flew to London for Celebration this year and did whatever it took to meet her and get her autograph.
 
My uncle passed away from similar circumstances around this time two years ago. Heart attack and died after a short time in critical condition. Really hoping that Carrie will pull through, but from my experience it doesn't look good :/
 

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
Never had your ears pop on a plane? Never wondered what it was?
Well yeah, there's only so much cabin pressurization can do, but there's no way it's the same air pressure as outside at that same altitude, that's the whole point of cabin pressurization.

The air in a plane is around 11-12 psi. Approximately the same level as the air in Denver. Air is definitely thinner.
I see, didn't know it was that thin, I never noticed. I only notice how goddamn dry it is (or at least, my poor nose definitely notices :( lol).
 

the_id

Member
She had 30 mins down time before a return of circulation. 15 in the plane and another 15 on the tarmac. What I'm hoping is that throughout this time, she had 30 mins of good quality CPR by the bystander nurses and paramedics.
 

Ambient80

Member
My uncle passed away from similar circumstances around this time two years ago. Heart attack and died after a short time in critical condition. Really hoping that Carrie will pull through, but from my experience it doesn't look good :/

It's not the best news, but being a pathologist, I can say I've seen people go through some pretty crazy shit and end up being ok. All hope is not lost, we just have to wait and see.
 
CPR is not as effective as people have come to believe... That's also why DNACPR is a thing, the risk/benefit/success is quickly outweighed as people get older.

Depending on the studies you look at generally only around 2% to 10% of people survive after receiving CPR.

With all due respect to your professional assessment of the situation, please keep that doom-mongering for yourself as we all already know that she's in a severe condition right now...
 
I wish we knew more. I'm upset no news source is covering this. It's all about Trump right now. Pfft.
It's not being covered because it's a very fluid and private situation. Beyond "Carrie Fisher had a very serious heart attack", the next reliable news as far as the public is concerned is she's either OK or she isn't. We're not entitled to live updates.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom