• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

I really think Jim Sterling is on the brink of a psychological breakdown and needs help.

Calverz

Member
Exactly the same here.

His Jimquisition videos used to be good commentary on an issue in the game industry at the time but now they are just poorly edited rants where he repeats the same things over and over and over for 20 odd minutes. They could be half the length they are even without the random clips and skits thrown in.

He plays so few games now and has pretty much stopped playing bad games entirely. His best gaming videos were those of him playing terrible/broken games.

He doesn't even review games anymore which sucks. I always enjoyed his reviews even when I disagreed with them as they were his honest thoughts on a game. He didn't bow to pressure and give something a 9 or a 10 just because every other reviewer was.

I hope he pulls it all back together but he's been like this for so long now I don't think he will. It's a shame as we've lost one of the few critics who was genuine and didn't bow to pressure or care about consensus.
100% agree
 

j0hnnix

Member
I thought he fell off YouTube, use to enjoy his crazy videos. Really don't see him crawling back to his old days but hope he finds what he is looking for.
 

BreakOut

Member
No shit.. guy needs help right now something ain’t right.

edit: Just to piggyback and what you said about persecution/narcissistic behavior.. He overvalues himself a bit. He even made a video bragging about losing subscribers, I’ve always watched his stuff but lately I can’t do it. Has almost nothing to do with gaming anymore. For real though it seems like the pandemic has Really taken him.. I really hope it doesn’t end up with a short drop and sudden stop.
I love this old stuff, the digital homicide shit was amazing. And he has a lot of extremely good points on the industry, but at this point he’s just kicking a dead horse and I feel like halfway through his videos he forgets what he’s talking about.
 
Last edited:

Tschumi

Member
These guys aren't infallible. Look at the nature of what they do, about a decade now of constant pressure to reproduce but stay fresh, maintain a perspective without becoming monotonous, digest game after game, steep yourself in memes and such to keep in touch, maintain pantomime character.. i mean I'd get dog sick of it myself after a year at most!

I hope he retires and finds himself - around the same time he loses half his body weight.
 

nkarafo

Member
When he started wearing makeup and going on about being non binary I had to unsub, it just got too much. Plus he only whines about the same things over and over, his content is super stale.
Agreed. I wanted to unsub too but i'm curious to see how the channel will crash.
 
J

JeremyEtcetera

Unconfirmed Member
Exactly the same here.

His Jimquisition videos used to be good commentary on an issue in the game industry at the time but now they are just poorly edited rants where he repeats the same things over and over and over for 20 odd minutes. They could be half the length they are even without the random clips and skits thrown in.

He plays so few games now and has pretty much stopped playing bad games entirely. His best gaming videos were those of him playing terrible/broken games.

He doesn't even review games anymore which sucks. I always enjoyed his reviews even when I disagreed with them as they were his honest thoughts on a game. He didn't bow to pressure and give something a 9 or a 10 just because every other reviewer was.

I hope he pulls it all back together but he's been like this for so long now I don't think he will. It's a shame as we've lost one of the few critics who was genuine and didn't bow to pressure or care about consensus.

This is what happens with YouTubers/Game reviewers/Journalists who base their content around bad games, bad companies and bad trends. Yes, it's good sometimes to have someone put the negative shit on blast. However, focusing on negative shit nonstop can tire the fuck out of anyone, make them hate their hobby turned profession, show them that it's an endless cycle, and make them jaded as fuck to boot. He's not the only guy who's changed/retired/quit from it. I can name quite a few reviewers and personalities who people used to champion here/elsewhere and they're happier now that they're no longer in the business and no longer focusing on all of that negativity.

When you take a step back from it all, every entertainment industry is just businessmen with no morals constantly trying every little thing they can to game the system to make the most money from it. Every now and then their business just so happens to align with creative greatness, and that's when they can rest easy for a bit because the public is fooled into thinking it's for the art. Otherwise it's a constant chase to the top of profit. But when shit hits the fan, musical chairs is played with the suits and the creatives are left holding the bag of shit.

It happens over and over in different ways, because these industries are cyclical, and that's why at the end of the day it's better to just try and stay ignorant, just consume what you like, and be happy.

If he has reached a point where he hates reviewing and covering games, I don't blame him. A part of him is most likely happier that he stopped.
 

Godot25

Banned
I really liked Jim for a long time but he became insufferable during covid, so i unfollowed him on Twitter and YT and moved on...
 

Kamina

Golden Boy
Yes, he probably has a tendency to the character he is playing, but its mostly an act to get views.
 

Porcile

Member
I used to enjoy what Jim had to say about the industry but like pretty much every independent content creator these days, Jim just fell down the Patreon/Youtube commenter circlejerk. Doesn't matter what low-effort garbage they put out, once a Youtuber reaches a certain point they always have a number of fans posting in-joke memes and giving attention and money. I noticed this with Jim around the Breath of the Wild review, which got a big reaction and he gained a lot of loyal followers/stooges on his side, and he has just been playing the fool, egged on by his various subscribers, ever since.
 

McCheese

Member
I don't know.

He moved to the US to follow his dream of being a 1970s wrestling comedy act boglin enthusiastic trans videogame journalist, and seems to be wondering why people are unsubscribing because his content is too "niche" now.

His life sounds pretty fun, certainly more interesting than a desk job, but blaming YouTube algorithms rather than accepting this new Jim sterling is a very acquired taste is a bit sad.

I don't think he'll find the overwhelming success he was looking for, but also not sure he really gives a shit, he's still making a good income via patreon and doing what he loves.

So no, I don't think he's in any sort of trouble.
 
Last edited:
It’s his thing leave him be lol.

I can’t stand the guy but he obviously doesn’t like video games so why we discussing him? there are too many people in the gaming industry who do nothing but hate on it. I know he’s making money off fools but wtf?
 
Last edited:
It's been quite a decline. It's funny to think that all this time he's wanted to be a woman. And what a woman he is.

His 'capitalism is the root of all evil' shtick is really juvenile - he's way too old to have such simplistic opinions. I mean, capitalism seems to be doing pretty well for ole Jim, but I guess his poor audience shouldn't buy into the system and make a good living for themselves like he has.
 
Last edited:

small_law

Member
I actually liked his appearances on Destruction’s Office Chat. He was pompous, but offered up decent insight back then. It started going off the rails when he got into excoriating garbage steam games for being garbage. No one needs to be told dog shit smells bad.

I’m honestly surprised he’s still on YouTube. This is the first thing I’ve seen on the Internet about him in many years.
 

iNvid02

Member
I don't like Jim Sterling's videos at all since everything is "controversial", but even more I don't like psychology for dummies on the internet.

exactly, he is clearly portraying a personality/character, i am guessing he can sufficiently distinguish it from his real life, hes an actor (i have 2 psychology degrees :p)
 

Holammer

Member
I had no idea what was happening until I saw some tweets about it. Haven't watched Aunt Jemina's stuff for over a year as I got tired of his shtick.
Same day I learned about this I also saw that old ass webcomic RealLife Comics artist Greg Dean goes by Mae Dean nowadays. That thing actually made me feels some emphathy and I haven't read the comic in a decade.
 

Roni

Gold Member
CObfqyb.png


^^^^^ Yes, that's an actual picture of Jim Sterling, taken from his latest video, which devolves into an absolutely atrocious pseudo-cerebral political diatribe that blends overpriced GBA games, the destruction of fun in gaming, and an economic system which pits us all against each other.

vqcjgQa.jpg



^^^^^Yes, that's another picture of Jim Sterling, presumably roleplaying the purple version of Goldust, but looking like a fat rapist-murderer version of Bob Hope.

But he wasn't always like this. The Jim Sterling of old--at least the one I remember--had savage wit and could genuinely make people laugh. But now...I don't know what to make of him. Sure, he had some stupid dress-up gags, but the exception has become the rule.

Observable trends from "modern day" Jim Sterling:
  • Disconcerting weight fluctuations, ranging from excessively obese, to obese, all the way back to excessively obese.
  • Increasingly bizarre video openings that seem to hint at perverse childhood fetishes.
  • A clear hatred for gaming, especially AAA gaming.
  • A clear hatred of gamers, especially those that buy anything even remotely popular.
  • A clear hatred of developers, especially those that have had project delays, resulting in the most cruel fate known to mankind--"crunch time."
  • Embarrassingly amateur political rants that lead me to believe he hasn't properly fastened his Marxist training wheels.
  • Self hatred and guilt that manifests itself in weird monologues, one of which featured him apologizing for helping to embolden the patriarchy while he was working as a games journalist, culminating in his pansexual reveal in Spring/Summer 2020.
    • Maybe I'm missing a key event, but when in the blue fuck did Jim Sterling ever "embolden" the patriarchy?
  • Persecution complex/narcissism.
In all actuality, this is not a faux-concern thread meant to get cheap shots in at an easy target. Having worked with writers and various artists over the past few years, I've witnessed this degenerative behavior, and it generally starts like this:
  1. Artist consistently looks for their personal flaws, dwelling on them, and generally blowing them out of proportion.
  2. Artist's quality of work begins to suffer and clear signs of mania present themselves in their work.
  3. Artist latches onto a guru or movement and is easily manipulated.
  4. Artist is reborn as something or someone completely contrary to their previous identity, or a grossly exaggerated cartoon caricature, completely lacking the personal charm or positive traits that made you like them to begin with.
On Jim's Wikipedia page, there is this statement:



If any of that is true (and there is reason to doubt, unfortunately, given what I've outlined), it's undeniably tragic.

But even more tragic is the path he's headed on.
  • He recently moved to the American Southeast (Mississippi).
    • Apparently he moved out, but is now an American citizen.
      • He obtained citizenship in 2020--great year to come to 'Murica, Jim.
  • Took up wrestling in Ryse, a terrible federation with backyard matches
  • Spends a lot of time talking about his wrestling matches on his video game channel
    • His "shoots" are generally pretty bad, since he needs to abide by politically woke standards.
  • Cannot seem to crack the 1,000,000 YouTube subscriber mark, no matter what he does.
    • Think about how long his channel has been around for, and all the controversy and swirl around it, and yet....
  • His blend of humor seems to grow more and more fringe as the days go on, and a lot of it seems be inside jokes and stupid toy references that only his most staunch followers would get.
    • I actually ended up unsubscribing from his channel last week, a move which is petty and symbolic, since it doesn't cost me a damn thing to be a subscriber and nobody cares. Strangely enough, it still felt good.
-------------------------------------

TLDR: Jim is headed for a crash. And it's a matter of "when" and not "if." I truly hope someone stages an intervention, because if that doesn't happen, we're all bound to hear him rant and rave about the supremely evil United States healthcare system, and I don't think I'll be able to ignore his YouTube death rattle.

Jim, if you're reading this...you're not the video game version of John Oliver or John Waters, and you're not a good wrestler or even a good "bad wrestler." Please get back to your core, Jim. You were a good writer and an adept video game critic. I implore you to get back to that persona, and please, please, please dial down the hamfisted political cringe you think is so cutting and profound. It's not, and you sound like a nut job, a moron, and a hopelessly naive little boy.

Please, Jim. Do it for yourself.
This reads like any other post modern thread.

"This isn't X". You finish reading it, it's fucking X.

He's just chasing YouTube money and dressing up and ranting is much more profitable than serious content.
 
Last edited:

kyussman

Member
If I'm being honest I had got really tired of his "game devs are evil" tirades week after week.....then he rocked up in a wig and make up and I haven't watched one of his videos since....guess I'm a massive transphobe,oh well.
 

ULTROS!

People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks.
Conforming to the Twitter crowd will surely make you insane over time.
 

Life

Member
Isn't he just releasing...content...and making money from it? Tell his viewers to stop, and surely he will too.
 

Flutta

Banned
This is transphobia if I ever seen one.

She ( he if you are so triggered) don't give a fuck about loyalty or fanboyism and would say it as it is. I like her content and she still make game reviews (like hades and others).

And what's wrong with wrestling? You think WWE has no abuses against it's contractors?

She??? Wtf its a dude get your head out of your ass. Go learn some first grade biology ffs. This world has gone mad.
 

FunkMiller

Member
The poor fucker obviously suffered a great deal of abuse when he was younger, and that’s had a profound effect on his psychology as an adult.

Unfortunately, like so many others, this mental damage has led him down a path that he probably feels is right for him, but is so plainly wrong for a healthy outlook on life.

He‘s losing a lot of subscribers, so I hope for his sake he gets some proper help that sets him back on a more constructive, positive path. I unsubscribed some time ago, but if he returned to the inciteful games commentary he was known for in years gone by, I’d subscribe again.
 
Last edited:

sublimit

Banned
I unsubbed to him a couple of years ago. He became way too toxic for me and he always looked on the negative side of everything.

We all know that this industry is not full of saints and roses but it's also not as bad as someone would think if he only watched Jim's videos.
 
Last edited:

Zatzuken

Member
I was a big fan of his, i listened to podtoid, dismal jesters, even now i listen to bostons favorite son just for the surreal ramblings in those shows.

But i havnt watched any of his preachy shit, all he does is moan and it does me in, and he looks ridiculous, its a good job he had patreon to prop him up because he couldnt operate in the real world lookinbg like this.
 
Top Bottom