• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spring Anime 2013 |OT -7| My Giant CG Pony Can't Possibly Read This Much Baudelaire

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mangirl! 13

8XEDsYH.jpg

So this is now an anime about four girls who become editors at a manga magazine who gets an anime made about their struggles of being girls who become editors at a manga magazine.

My head hurts.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
Even at its worst Tamako was quite good and at the very least had good direction and solid visuals. There isn't a massive gulf in quality there.
Are we really going to do this? It's going to be silly.

For me there are worlds of difference between Tamako and Hyouka on both a narrative and visual level. Tamako is such a weird show for me. I have no idea what it is really trying to be as a whole. There is this big cast but most of them are kind of just completely forgotten or tucked away to never return. It rarely does much with what it has, and when it does it is even less likely to tie what its accomplished into the world being built.

Or just do the easy thing and pit their festivals against one another to see the dramatic difference between the two.
 

jbug617

Banned
Key Visual for Kuroko no Basket Season 2 is out but I don't know if I can post it because it looks like it's a magazine scan.
 

Shergal

Member
Or just do the easy thing and pit their festivals against one another to see the dramatic difference between the two.

This is a disingenuous argument. Hyouka is set on a gigantic school, where the cultural festival is one of its most striking characteristics and had been hyped since episode 4. The whole arc focuses around someone playing around with the festival.
Tamako never cared about the school, it was set on the market, and the single episode featuring the festival wasn't really dedicated to the festival itself, but to their performance and especially Midori's feelings. Which were related to the preparation of the performance, which happened before the festival.

I agree that Tamako looks much rougher than Hyouka, it had a really tight schedule, but that's not the way to prove it.
 

Theonik

Member
Are we really going to do this? It's going to be silly.

For me there are worlds of difference between Tamako and Hyouka on both a narrative and visual level. Tamako is such a weird show for me. I have no idea what it is really trying to be as a whole. There is this big cast but most of them are kind of just completely forgotten or tucked away to never return. It rarely does much with what it has, and when it does it is even less likely to tie what its accomplished into the world being built.

Or just do the easy thing and pit their festivals against one another to see the dramatic difference between the two.
I'm not saying one doesn't look better than the other, just that the gulf between Tamako and Chuu2 and Tamako and Hyouka are much different in size. Not like the number of '>' has any significance to begin with though.

Here, good sir.

The quality is unbelievable for the price and now I'm worried that I'm going to begin collecting anime artbooks.
Hmm, CD Japan has it for slightly cheaper. Will go with them probably as they are more versatile in shipping too.
 

7Th

Member
Chuu2 is easily the ugliest post-Lucky Star KyoAni show; the gaudy color design makes everything look cheap and artificial.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
I agree that Tamako looks much rougher than Hyouka, it had a really tight schedule, but that's not the way to prove it.
It was a joke.

Really though, the festival stuff in Tamako does still get set up, and the dumb baton club stuff was always building towards that in some way or another. I thought it was all handled pretty poorly. You can say the school doesn't matter but it comes up pretty often, and is formative to many of the show's relationships.

And even ignoring the school stuff most of the market events are kind of a drag. The show does a really bad job of establishing the market as a location, and its sense of space and layout are almost completely nebulous. Instead its propped up on a bunch of jokey and meaningless characters who fail to really imbue it with much personality.
 

kayos90

Tragic victim of fan death
Woke up to more Chuu2. Not surprised considering how it did in comparison to Hyouka and Tamako. Well.... it's not better than Hyouka but it is better than Tamako so I guess won partially. W/e.
 

OceanBlue

Member
Higurashi Nekogoroshi

I thought this was better than the show, weird!

5/10


Is the 2nd season also divided between separate chapters?
The second season isn't nearly as segmented. It also doesn't look like trash like the first did but it loses whatever charm that cheap look had, lol.
 

kayos90

Tragic victim of fan death
Chuu2 is easily the ugliest post-Lucky Star KyoAni show; the gaudy color design makes everything look cheap and artificial.

Really? I actually like the glow and the color. It looks nice. On the other hand I don't like Tamako over Chuu2. I think it's a preference of style in this case.
 

cajunator

Banned
Utah's lost chuuni childhood friend who is in love with him appears and becomes Rika's rival. I'm not even joking.

3.png

I like this development!

Key visual for Chuu2 S2:

cute. cheap but kind of creative.

Oh thank the lawd.

Can't wait for this.

Thank god Japan has good taste. Fuck ya Tamako fuck ya Hyouka, the best KyoAni show since Nichijou gets its rightful second season.

I love you. You're not afraid to tell people what you think, and you support the buttfumblers. Truly a brave man.

not bad, not bad.

/immediately hides all of it from view

Why on earth would you hide any of that? For that matter why does it seem like you are always ashamed of your fandom? fuck that. EMBRACE YOUR FANDOM. So what if people know you like anime?
 
Zettai Karen Children: The Unlimited End

Neat little side story that furthers Hyobu's character a lot more than I would expect a non-canon show would do. I do feel like they made him and PANDRA more sympathetic than their manga incarnation, but that happens when you give the leading role of a spinoff to an antagonist.

Keeping Saotome alive really shakes things up with the lore, which is why I'll be surprised if this is canon, especially when there's another Hyobu flashback going on in the manga right now.
Unless of course this takes place after where the manga currently is like the recent Hayate anime.

Anyway, there was some good action, good animation, AVGN and Nostalgia Critic, and other good stuff. I'll probably forget all about it when the year ends, but still one of the stand out shows of the winter season and better than Code:Breaker.
 
Chuu2 S2 announced; KyoAni must be in serious need of money.

I'm ok with this, but that doesn't mean I'll be ok with the drama that will ensue in the show. I just wanted awkward chuuni antics being somehow tolerated by normal people.

http://www.p3m.jp/

Persona 3 The Movie #1 - Spring of Birth

Opens Fall 2013 in Japan.

Main staff/cast on the site, and a new PV.

Adaptation of my favorite game, superb! Can't wait until next year when I get to watch it.

Strike Witches S2 - 06



Oh man, this Elia x Sanya episode was pretty damn good. I can understand now why fans hold these two to be the OTP of the show.

EILANYA FOR LIFE.

 

BluWacky

Member
The year is long...

I believe in Space Dandy!

And some true noitaminA shows!

And Yuri Bear Storm being both good and out in 2013!

And some other stuff coming out of nowhere to surprise me!

Admittedly Wolf Children was well good, so it would take a lot to top it, but still.
 

Metrotab

Banned
Looking back on the thread, it seems the Girls and Panzer finale is not something to be missed.

And I'm not liking the Chuu2 plot preview. Can't I just have my KeyAni? Is it so hard?
 
Sub-4,000 bluray and 617 DVDs.
I have to wonder if the prices they change for this stuff isn't the reason.

And that the huge prices simply aren't sustainable.

Here in the United States, you can buy DVDs for $5, and sometimes even Blu Rays for that price. And box sets are generally less than $50. While in Japan it is multiple times that. Many otaku I'm sure can't afford such prices.

I import manga all of the time because it is so insanely cheap, even with shipping around the price I pay for localized manga. But a lot of the anime is way, way out of my reach.
Sure, they'd get a lot less per copy if the charged less. But surely they would get a lot more customers, right?
 

Dragoshi1

Member
And DONE, all caught up with Naruto Shippuden. Thank you, Crunchyroll!

So many excellent fights, especially with the Sound 4 towards the end there.


The next episode seems to be a flashback, though. Hooray, Filler!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom