• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

GAF's Best of E3 2013 Awards [Results In/Bandaid edition]

B

benny_a

extra source of jiggaflops
tywyI8Z.png


The voting period for Best of E3 2013 is over. Here are the winners:
Click to expand...

Game of the Show
Winner: The Division – 175


Runner's Up: Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain - 166 & Final Fantasy XV - 117

The Witcher 3 - 35
Infamous: Second Son: 30
Destiny - 30
Titanfall - 26
Click to expand...


Best PC Game
Winner: The Witcher 3 – 183


Runner Up: Titanfall - 86
Battlefield - 83
Mirror's Edge - 54
Click to expand...


Best PlayStation 4 Game
Winner: Infamous: Second Son – 272


Runner Up: Final Fantasy XV - 175
Destiny - 81
The Division - 51
Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain - 38
Killzone: Shadow Fall - 34
The Order: 28
Click to expand...


Best Portable Game
Winner: The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds – 154


Runner Up: Pokémon X and Y - 130
Super Smash Bros. - 107
Tearaway - 84
Killzone: Mercenary - 52
Click to expand...


Best Wii U Game
Winner: X – 206


Runner Up: Super Smash Bros. - 144
Bayonetta 2 - 106
Mario Kart 8 - 101
Super Mario 3D World - 50
The Wonderful 101 - 36
Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze - 21
Click to expand...


Best Xbox One Game
Winner: Titanfall – 299


Runner Up: Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain - 97
Quantum Break - 64
Dead Rising - 39
Below - 26
Click to expand...


Best Tech
Winner: PlayStation 4 – 179


Runner Up: The Division - 143
The Dark Sorcerer - 112
Final Fantasy XV - 66
Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain - 47
Battlefield 4 - 48
Oculus Rift - 29
Click to expand...


Explanation
Vire is currently busy that's why it's this year's results thread is the bandaid edition and not the full run-down. I apologize for this. I took the most popular votes in each category and accumulated them. Games that only got very few votes I didn't count (Like The Witness getting one vote), as the effort wasn't worth it. (I only just jumped in to help out.)

Thanks to Vire and everyone else that participated. Next year we need some different categories, I think. ;-)
Click to expand...

Voting thread
 
Winner of everyone's hearts: Octodad

Surprised about The Division winning. I forgot about it in minutes, but I guess it made an impression. The rest are all pretty predictable, except maybe LoZ: A Link Between Worlds beating out Super Smash Bros. 3DS.

Well done OP!
 
That's a pretty good Top 3. Not too crazy about The Division yet myself, but FFXV and MGSV were indeed the top games of E3.

A little surprised to see so little hype for Smash Bros. Brawl did have a better reveal though.
 
i think tearaway would be topping the portable charts if they'd shown the e3 demo at the sony press conference.

also not as enamoured with the division as the rest of gaf. love the graphics and scale but it does look just standard third person cover shooter at its core.
 
The Division's setting is what lost it GotS for me. A third-person MMO/RPG shooter is awesome. But a "military" shooter in NY? Ugh.
 
Idk, I don't see the fuss behind the division yet, potentially interesting but from about 8mins of gameplay it's hard to say; looks like a 3rd person Destiny.
 
The Division looks both really good and exceedingly dull. It's a shame they wasted all those resources on such a boring setting and concept.
 
The Division looks awesome, but for me FF XV was breathtaking, the best of the show with The Phantoms Pain.
And ALttP 2
 
What's good about The Division?
Did they release something beyond that trailer playthrough?

Because it wasn't that remarkable tbh.
 
Didn't get a chance to vote, poll closed too early. Oh well.

I also didn't really understand the voting criteria.
It skewed a bit too platform-focused and not content, which really is what E3 is about. Genre awards would have worked better.

Where would I have even been able to vote for some of the awesome games I played/saw at the show like Murdered, or Lords of Shadow 2 or any other third party title.
 
John Harker said:
Didn't get a chance to vote, poll closed too early. Oh well.

I also didn't really understand the voting criteria.
It skewed a bit too platform-focused and not content, which really is what E3 is about. Genre awards would have worked better.

Where would I have even been able to vote for some of the awesome games I played/saw at the show like Murdered, or Lords of Shadow 2 or any other third party title.
Click to expand...

Next year we will do genre awards. It'll be back and better than ever. :)

Also thinking about adding a long overdue indie category.
 
Oculus rift should have won best tech. hmph.. guess you have to experience it yourself before truly appreciate it.
 
Vire said:
Next year we will do genre awards. It'll be back and better than ever. :)

Also thinking about adding a long overdue indie category.
Click to expand...

I hear ya. All good.
Though I do find it funny. I've been to over 10 of these in-person, and it really always is about the content. It's about the games, and how they'll individually perform at retail, and trying to get the best PR and write ups you can, and whose doing what with what technology and etc.

No one really cares about platforms. Well, unless you work for MS, Nintendo or Sony I suppose. It's really the enthusiast media who play up the whole 'it's a major platform war, what side are you on?' stuff. Which I guess might be what people want to read, and why they push it so far, but E3 is more a game sales war than a 'hey what platform are you going to buy' battle.

cause really, everyone know,s the better they all do, the better everyone does
 
John Harker said:
Didn't get a chance to vote, poll closed too early. Oh well.

I also didn't really understand the voting criteria.
It skewed a bit too platform-focused and not content, which really is what E3 is about. Genre awards would have worked better.

Where would I have even been able to vote for some of the awesome games I played/saw at the show like Murdered, or Lords of Shadow 2 or any other third party title.
Click to expand...
You've raised a good point in the middle of the thread, and I agree with you. The OP needs to be upon submission have a set rules by which everyone must abide. (There are several people that said "I'm coming back later to edit my other choices" and they never did so they wouldn't know about changes in the rules.)

This forum doesn't have platform specific boards, so I think we should just list top 10 (or however many any person thinks are worth listing) and have a top 10 list, just like with our yearly GOTY awards.

Genres are getting so blurred, platforms are often meaningless. I think it should just be games.
Instead of platforms categories such as "best playable", "best trailer", "best concept" would be more valuable.

Vire said:
Next year we will do genre awards. It'll be back and better than ever. :)

Also thinking about adding a long overdue indie category.
Click to expand...
There are some that are of the opinion that indie shouldn't be confined to their own category. Games such as Bastion and Journey are comfortable hanging with the big budget stuff.
 
Vire said:
To be honest, I'm surprised it got as many votes as it did.

Sure it looks nice, but it's still same ole' Mario Kart.
Click to expand...

Mario Kart is always great, plus it looks gorgeous and Waluigi's back.

They added some anti-gravity gameplay too.
 
Gritty cover based co-op third-person shooter, probably the most complained about genre here, wins GAFs game of the show. Am I the only one that finds this absolutely hilarious?
 
benny_a said:
You've raised a good point in the middle of the thread, and I agree with you. The OP needs to be upon submission have a set rules by which everyone must abide. (There are several people that said "I'm coming back later to edit my other choices" and they never did.

This forum doesn't have platform specific boards, so I think we should just list top 10 (or however many any person thinks are worth listing) and have a top 10 list, just like with our yearly GOTY awards.

Genres are getting so blurred, platforms are often meaningless. I think it should just be games.
Instead of platforms categories such as "best playable", "best trailer", "best concept" would be more valuable.


There are some that are of the opinion that indie shouldn't be confined to their own category. Games such as Bastion and Journey are comfortable hanging with the big budget stuff.
Click to expand...

Sounds good, not opposed to a top 10 similar to GOTY voting with number 1, 2 ,3 being worth more.
 
Himself said:
Gritty cover based co-op third-person shooter, probably the most complained about genre here, wins GAFs game of the show. Am I the only one that finds this absolutely hilarious?
Click to expand...

Plenty of folks love these games but haters be loud.

edit: Just an opinion on the voting..

The best ps4, xbox1, nintendo games etc. I think should all be exclusive titles.

Otherwise say MGS5 would have won most all my categories since it is multi-pat
 
Vire said:
To be honest, I'm surprised it got as many votes as it did.

Sure it looks nice, but it's still same ole' Mario Kart.
Click to expand...
It just feels like the one Wii U game that steps above the PS3 and 360 to me. I've been waiting seven years for next gen to start and Mario Kart legit looks next gen.

Can't say the same for X or Smash.
 
benny_a said:
Lots of things I'm inferring but to me it seems like a DayZ without Zombies, but with RPG elements, quests and encounters by game designer and lots of polish.
Click to expand...

I think of it as a Modern Warfare version of Destiny. It's not an amazingly different concept. Tons of games heading in that direction.

And not sure how you can tell that it has a lot of polish when it isn't even playable.
 
JWong said:
And not sure how you can tell that it has a lot of polish when it isn't even playable.
Click to expand...
My polish comment was in comparison to DayZ. I don't think Ubisoft will release a jankier game than DayZ was when it was popular here on GAF.

I also disagree that it's like Destiny. Destiny is like Borderlands, where you don't have to care about staying hydrated and getting food. The RPG and weapon stuff is very close though.

AAK said:
These results don't make sense at all.

Division wins best of show yet is 200 points behind Second Son on bestofPS4 and doesn't even chart on bestofxbone? Doesn't make any sense to me at all.
Click to expand...
Check the voting thread. The categories are distinct and are independently tracked.
 
These results don't make sense at all.

Division wins best of show yet is 200 points behind Second Son on bestofPS4 and doesn't even chart on bestofxbone? Doesn't make any sense to me at all.
 
AAK said:
These results don't make sense at all.

Division wins best of show yet is 200 points behind Second Son on bestofPS4 and doesn't even chart on bestofxbone? Doesn't make any sense to me at all.
Click to expand...

People wanted to share the wealth, it would be boring if Division won every category.

Which is why we are changing the format next year.
 
Vire said:
People wanted to share the wealth, it would be boring if Division won every category.

Which is why we are changing the format next year.
Click to expand...

Then the categories don't have any meaning then. If you gave Division your best of E3, and you voted something different for PS4, then that vote you cast for PS4 isn't really your honest choice of the best game you saw for PS4.

EDIT: A solution could be "Special Mention Award for PS4" and "Special Mention Award for PC" etc. instead of "Best PS4 Game"
 
benny_a said:
My polish comment was in comparison to DayZ. I don't think Ubisoft will release a jankier game than DayZ was when it was popular here on GAF.

I also disagree that it's like Destiny. Destiny is like Borderlands, where you don't have to care about staying hydrated and getting food. The RPG and weapon stuff is very close though.
Click to expand...

That's just a resource system. It wasn't even really detailed in the walkthrough.

Did they say it's roguelike?
 
SolarPowered said:
It just feels like the one Wii U game that steps above the PS3 and 360 to me. I've been waiting seven years for next gen to start and Mario Kart legit looks next gen.

Can't say the same for X or Smash.
Click to expand...

I disagree, X looks more impressive than MK. The tracks in MK don't hold a candle to the environments in X.
 
jj984jj said:
I disagree, X looks more impressive than MK. The tracks in MK don't hold a candle to the environments in X.
Click to expand...

I think it comes down to preference, obviously Mario Kart is much more vibrant, runs at 60 FPS as opposed to 30, but isn't as detailed as something like X.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Steam Awards 2025 results
37
2K
Chukhopops replied
day of the devs game awards edition
1
203
rkofan87 replied
Famitsu Dengeki Game Awards 2025 Results (Silent Hill f wins GOTY)
16
686
Jinzo Prime replied
  • Poll
The best first party portfolio in the industry is...? (2026 Edition)
Platform  2
93
2K
MrCunningham replied
Black flag adds 90$ of cosmetics/weapons not included in Deluxe edition
2
99
523
Woggleman replied
Top Bottom