-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Yoshida's top 10 games of the generation, is fan of Sony titles
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Omotesando
Member
Yoshida is boss.
List proves it. 80% my list right there.
List proves it. 80% my list right there.
20cent
Banned
Makes sense.
synchronicity
Member
Just like how a lot of users on this forum will never understand opinions.
SweetTeddie
Member
It's funny that Shu has Dark/Demon's souls that high on his list since he said he hated Demon's Souls when he played it at first.
http://www.computerandvideogames.com/335628/sony-initially-thought-demons-souls-was-crap/
http://www.computerandvideogames.com/335628/sony-initially-thought-demons-souls-was-crap/
Omnistalgic
Member
oh snap...think I teared up a little bit at the end...
Those feels...man...loved Journey too Yosh
Those feels...man...loved Journey too Yosh
IncandescentPrecept
Banned
I forgot where I read about it but he supposedly got the game when it was in a broken state so it can be understandable.
Lost Odyssey is a great game dragged down by obnoxious, tedious loading times (even installed to the HDD) on top of a fairly routine combat system that doesn't do anything special, and boring (also tedious) dungeons. Some of those moving tile puzzles at the end of the game were just awful. Go here, flip this switch, go there, flip that switch *yawn*.
TetraGenesis
Member
Wow guys. Don't go to the segment where he gets emotional talking about Journey unless you wanna experience...
I love that game too Shu.
I teared up just listening to him talk about it, reminiscing on my own experience.
I can honestly say that Journey was a once in a lifetime experience for me. I came out of that game a different person than I was going in.
Game of the Generation to me for sure.
Brofist
Member
It's like he read your mind!!
TetraGenesis
Member
This. Reading this thread has been obnoxious because of all the people saying "this list is horrible," "how could he not pick [blank]," etc.
These are his favorite experiences of the generation. You not agreeing doesn't invalidate his personal opinion.
Worst, almost nobody took the time to listen to that piece and hear the arguments made behind every choice. The podcast is really well done...
You should play more videogames...
Fried Food
Banned
I'm glad they ended the podcast when they did. We didn't need to hear their blabbering after the feels.
sublimit
Banned
Haha i thought the same as well.Also ending with Journey's main theme was a nice touch after Yoshida's comments.Made me listen to the whole ost again.
DracoBlade
Member
Journey is so hyped to me at this point I dont know if it can ever live up to my expectations now. Especially since I know the
twist
other player
SanguineShark
Member
I really need to get around to playing Journey sometime. Have to admit, it got me too. His response just seemed so genuine.
That is actually a very good and varied top 10. You have game mechanics focused titles like COD/DS, cinematic games like TLoU/Uncharted/GTA and unique/quirky like LBP/Journey/Sound Shapes.
I would probably put Killzone 2, GT5 or Marvel vs Capcom 3 in the list somewhere but thats just me.
I would probably put Killzone 2, GT5 or Marvel vs Capcom 3 in the list somewhere but thats just me.
Chuck Norris
Banned
Lol people are really salty that he didn't include Halo or Gears in this list, as if they are even top 10 games
Callibretto
Member
and I seem to remember Demon Souls not having a very favorable impression from it's first E3 reveal in neogaf too. many post saying slow clunky combat etc.
Callibretto
Member
they need to make game inspired by District 9, that movie is awesome. let GG made it and give Killzone a rest for awhile.
Shu you magnificent bastard.
Sinfamy
Member
Here is my list off the top of my head:
1. Demon's Souls
2. Dark Souls
3. Portal 2
4. Fallout 3
5. Persona 3 or 4 [They count as being part of this generation for me]
6. Ni No Kuni
7. Valyria Chronicles
8. The Last of Us
9. Journey
10. The Stanley Parable
Honorable Mention:
Bioshock (Only for the story, not gameplay).
1. Demon's Souls
2. Dark Souls
3. Portal 2
4. Fallout 3
5. Persona 3 or 4 [They count as being part of this generation for me]
6. Ni No Kuni
7. Valyria Chronicles
8. The Last of Us
9. Journey
10. The Stanley Parable
Honorable Mention:
Bioshock (Only for the story, not gameplay).
Tidus_Great
Banned
Pretty decent list other than COD4 and GTA5. My personal top 10 of this gen would be
Last of Us
Journey
Yakuza 3
Yakuza 4
inFamous 2
Bioshock
Mass Effect 1
Xenoblade
Vanquish
God of War 3
For the most part I like story focused games, but Vanquish is an exception I felt the gameplay was so great that the horrible story didn't matter. Overall I was disappointed in the lack of Great JRPGs, Xenoblade is the only JRPG of this gen I would qualify as great.
Last of Us
Journey
Yakuza 3
Yakuza 4
inFamous 2
Bioshock
Mass Effect 1
Xenoblade
Vanquish
God of War 3
For the most part I like story focused games, but Vanquish is an exception I felt the gameplay was so great that the horrible story didn't matter. Overall I was disappointed in the lack of Great JRPGs, Xenoblade is the only JRPG of this gen I would qualify as great.
ebullientprism
Member
Unless he is talking specifically about games that available on Sony platforms this is a terrible list.
Otherwise he has either never played anything made for the 360, Wii, 3DS, DS or the PC or just wont list them because he works for Sony. The former doesnt really make him much of a gamer and the latter makes him a big fat phony.
Otherwise he has either never played anything made for the 360, Wii, 3DS, DS or the PC or just wont list them because he works for Sony. The former doesnt really make him much of a gamer and the latter makes him a big fat phony.
Phoenician_Viking
Banned
Good list, and lol at the people butthurt over someone else´s opinion.
No it´s not a horrible list at all. He listed 3 multiplatform games, so much for Sony platforms. He is a gamer and he is entitled to his opinion.
No it´s not a horrible list at all. He listed 3 multiplatform games, so much for Sony platforms. He is a gamer and he is entitled to his opinion.
the blue lonegoon
Banned
That list is really full of great games but Journey being #1 is a joke. How far up your own ass do you need to be to say that's the best game of the generation? And I'm a fan of indie games, I enjoyed Journey for what it is.
Phoenician_Viking
Banned
Seriously GTFO. People like different things. How far up your own ass of you to judge other people´s choices.
Way to read my posts bro!
I said it was silly. You don't think it is silly to do something like a top 10 list, something you are meant to think about deeply and objectively about and yet fill it with decisions obviously decided by the company you work for?
Note just in case you miss it again, I said silly, not unethical, unprofessional, wrong, etc.
WrenchNinja
Member
People do platform/family exclusive lists all of the time. You're getting really bent out of shape over a top 10 list on a console manufacturers' podcast from the world wide studios president.
Austriacus
Member
Holy shit at the end, all them feels. Ima cry.
Haha wonderful.
Naked Lunch
Member
A laughable joke of a list. And for all the shit we give IGN and other sites over their lists, they got nothing on this one.
Why? Answer me that question. Why is this list, a man's personal top 10 games on the Playstation 3/Vita which was put out through the Playstation official podcast, a joke?
Jesus lol, it's the mans personal favourite games. No need to shit on him.
Edit: What RE_Player said.
Indeed. I wish I could go back and experience that game for the first time again and again.
Such a moving experience. Nothing else like it.