• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

10 Games - 10 Scores, What's you Prediction?

P

PayOffWizard

Member
It would also help a load if you could post your (Current Total Score - ##) via a new post or a edit of your original.


Also, if ive missed anyone who should be on the leaderboard give me a message and ill get it updated.

P.s.
Everyone is also allowed to update their original guess up until the embargo is lifted.
 
P

Playsage

Member
PayOffWizard said:
Update after Hitman -76

1) 24 Points
Playsage

2) 21 Points - Tied
petethepanda
padlock
Omotesando
Shambalakan

6) 19 Points - Tied
ricelord
DryvBy
TheSpaceBetween
GeordieMark
antitrop
zsynqx
Diancecht
prag16

15) 18 Points - Tied
butman
HF2014
RiverKwai
Lunarwhale


Ill update again for The division today or Monday, but its looking like 'Playsage' is going to crush it with 3 perfect guesses.
Click to expand...

Holy shit! The Division did actually drop to 81!
Wished I had this kind of luck in my everyday life lol
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
I've updated the first post with scores after the release of the Division (Meta 81).
I waited longer to score this game as the reviews came out a few days after the release, due to the online nature of the game

Here's the full leaderboard for anyone interested.
There's probably a couple of mistake as ive been staring at numbers for the past 30 mins but it should be mostly accurate.

36 - Points
Playsage

30 - Points
petethepanda

29 - Points
Dawnbuster
padlock

28 - Points
antitrop
GeordieMark

27 - Points
Kill3r7
TheExodu5
prag16
Oneself
Shambalakan
ricelord

26 - Points
Lunarwhale
hydruxo
seady
MODEYV3
notaskwid
Anticol
jabberwocker

25 - Points
zsynqx
tomhan
evi
CaptainLoveline
jimboton
GIANKRATOS
Lys Skygge
Slammin_Hammon
BashNasty
Jagsrock
RiverKwai
sector4
uncleslappy

24 - Points
Comrade Crunch
KingJ2002
heckmanimation
PayOffWizard
Wedzi
HF2014
Uzny
Toxi
vetrox
digitalrelic

23 - Points
FelipeMGM
diffusionx
tioslash
Timeaisis
pnutboy
XxRampage07xX
grosvenor_92

22 - Points
nbnt
daniel77733
AgentP
labx
oimori
PanicFreak
Diancecht
RespectThySole
Bl@de
GustyGardens
jesu
falconxcrunner09
Weltall Zero
tearsintherain
Toxi

21 - Points
Flyinmunky
oakenhild
eXistor
ekim
WeWereGiants
eso76
Itachi87
The Argus
Johndoey
OCDChewie
Captainbojanglesiii
Ocarina_117
Jayuk
Retro4ever
neurosisxeno
Wurdfurd
AmaterasuOkami076
Omotesando
IfAllElseFales
Spman2099

20 - Points
jjonez18
WooHooAlex
SicSemperTyrannis
Chobel
Nimby
apieceofstrange
Locust
DrD
backflip10019
A Link to the Past
kingellesar
Bl4ckSunsh1n3

19 - Points
LKSmash
Tambini
Dad
bounchfx
Zxrophantom
TheSpaceBetween
butman
brokentrain
AmaterasuOni
Gandalf
King Al B

18 - Points
Spieler Eins
Novel Mike
Violet_0
DryvBy
Acquiescence
Genio88

17 - Points
DKHF
slash3584
Markitron
Dangansona
Sulik2
Kenzodielocke
Grimsen
St3v3
waitwhat42
yuraya
Savinowned
Milijango
jnWake

16 - Points
zma1013
Elandyll
StaffyManasse
_SAKY_
weekev
MikeE21286
Forsaken82
ThatArcher
Dragonslayer_023
UnrealEck
Buburibon

15 - Points
Hanmik
Palmer27
nkarafo
Unaha-Closp
theecakee
GHG
kgb_abc

14 - Points
Minions
Salty Hippo
orthodoxy1095
Weebos
IvanJ
thaDeeg
Kayero
PhoenixWrong
Dalex

13 - Points
speedomodel
VE3TRO
StrawberryJam
Bolivar687
vitalogy11
swarley64
Stilton Disco
doorframe
EBreda
CyberPunked
ryanofcall
StrongBelwas
Ishan
pixellated_man
Shang

12 - Points
#sorrynotsorry
Fat4all
ALLseeingEYE
blackMamba1187
packy34
Mdk7

11 - Points
Thewonandonly
Spacejaws
BraXzy
Bitch Pudding
10
danowat
Quan
rafa
Kerned

9 - Points
Xumbrega
Goldberg
Volcane
Jpope
Last Prime

8 - Points
Daante
Suzzopher

6 - Points
The perfect Dark
halfbeast
Zhadgon

3 - Points
Genuflections
parcali

0 - Points
TheSinkingKnight
Gen X
 
P

pixellated_man

Member
Thanks for regularly updating this thread OP. My prediction for Quantum Break is way off...really surprised by some of the low scores it's getting.
Now I'm going to read through other peoples predictions for the game. Should be fun!
 
prag16

prag16

Banned
Almost nailed QB. Guessed 79. I'm pretty sure it'll be a 9/10 game for me, and a serious personal GOTY contender, but I definitely expected some outlets to shit all over it for (imo) dubious reasons, and I was right. That 11 points should shoot me very close to the top...
 
E

EBreda

Member
After the 3 first games I think I should have 19 points instead of 13?

Hitman: 5 points off (5 points)
FarCry: 4 points off (6 points)
Division: 2 points off (8 points)

Not that it matters though... playsage is nailing everything!
 
O

Oneself

Member
I still have hope I'll get to you before the end Playsage. ;)

Can't wait for the updated results including QB and DS3!
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
EBreda said:
After the 3 first games I think I should have 19 points instead of 13?

Hitman: 5 points off (5 points)
FarCry: 4 points off (6 points)
Division: 2 points off (8 points)

Not that it matters though... playsage is nailing everything!
Click to expand...

Unfortunately you posted your guesses after the Farcry Embargo had broke, that's why you didn't score any points, sorry.

I'm working on the Quantum Break (78) scores now and should be up either today or tomorrow.

Ill score dark souls after 50 ish reviews have been gathered as its score may still change.
 
A

Anticol

Banned
Hey guys I think my score is incorrect, it shows me at 26 but in fact I am at 30 unless I am doing the calculations wrong.
 
P

Playsage

Member
Oneself said:
I still have hope I'll get to you before the end Playsage. ;)

Can't wait for the updated results including QB and DS3!
Click to expand...
You might :) After Quantum Break
thanks, Giant Bomb! :(
I'm not that confident on my second half of predictions (except for Uncharted 4). If Dark Souls drops under 90, I'm going to feel petethepanda's breath down my neck!

I'll make a second post for my predictions after the Dark Souls 3 update. I can tweak the unreleased scores, right?
Thank you for your time, OP!
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
Anticol said:
Hey guys I think my score is incorrect, it shows me at 26 but in fact I am at 30 unless I am doing the calculations wrong.
Click to expand...

Anticol said:
Game 1. Hitman - 78
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 76
Game 3. The Division -80
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 85
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 83
Game 6. Quantum Break - 72
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 81
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 64
Game 9. Gears 4 - 74
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 75
Click to expand...

Game 1. Hitman - 78 - 8 Points
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 76 - 9 points
Game 3. The Division -80 - 9 points

26 total points.

The score for Farcry (77) was taken 4 or 5 days after the embargo had been lifted and the game had over 50+ reviews. A couple of days later more reviews were added and the score dropped a point.
Unfortunately I cant update everyones points for a shift in the metacritic score, so once ive given a game a final score, those will be the official scores used for this competition.
Which means for some like yourself you'll miss out on points. Sorry :(
 
D

DKHF

Member
Your graphic for QB says "PS4 Version"
jWNK6SL.png
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
I've updated the leaderboard with Quantum Break scores in the first post.

Let me know if anyone is interested in seeing the full list of everyone's scores and ill post that as well.

Dark Souls scores coming soon.
 
P

Playsage

Member
Alright! Time to make some course corrections!

Recap:
Game 1. Hitman 76 76 +12 points
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 77 77 +12 points
Game 3. The Division 81 81 +12 points
Game 4. Dark Souls III 91 89 +8 points
Game 6. Quantum Break 83 78 +5 points
Current Total: 49 points

Back to the race:
Game 5. Uncharted 4 94*
Game 7. No Mans Sky 77
Game 8. StarFox Zero 78*
Game 9. Gears of War 4 84*
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 78*
* updated

Hoping that my boy Uncharted 4 doesn't fail me...
COME AT ME, BROS!
 
T

theecakee

Member
Game 1. Hitman 72 - Actual Score: 76 +6 points
Game 2. Far Cry Primal 78 - Actual Score: 79 +9 points
Game 3. The Division 92 - Actual Score: 81 +0 Points
Game 4. Dark Souls III 89 - Actual Score: 89 +12 points
Game 5. Uncharted 4 95
Game 6. Quantum Break 87 - Actual Score: 78 +2 points
Game 7. No Mans Sky 88
Game 8. StarFox Zero 65 - Actual Score: 71 +4 points
Game 9. Gears 4 82
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee Delayed to 2017
Click to expand...

Total: 33 points

Well looks like my confidence in The Division and Quantum Break killed me.
 
P

PanicFreak

Member
PanicFreak said:
Game 1. Hitman - 75 (Actual 76)
Game 2. Far Cry Primal - 81 (Actual 79)
Game 3. The Division - 78 (Actual - 81)
Game 4. Dark Souls III - 89 (Actual - 89)
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 89
Game 6. Quantum Break - 88 (Actual 78)
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 82
Game 8. StarFox Zero - 74
Game 9. Gears 4 - 85
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Click to expand...

9+8+7+12+1=37

Quantum Break broke me but Star Fox Zero is looking promising.
 
pnutboy

pnutboy

Member
pnutboy said:
Game 1: Hitman- 73 (Actual: 76= +7)
Game 2: Far Cry Primal- 76 (Actual: 77= +9)
Game 3: The Division- 78 (Actual: 81= +7)
Game 4: Dark Souls 3- 88 (Actual: 89= +9)
Game 5: Uncharted 4- 92
Game 6: Quantum Break- 82 (Actual: 78= +6)
Game 7: No Man's Sky- 76
Game 8: Star Fox Zero- 70
Game 9: Gears of War 4- 83
Game 10: Yooka-Laylee- 80
Click to expand...

7+9+7+9+6= 38

Counting on Uncharted 4 to pull through for me!
 
O

Oneself

Member
Hopefully Starfox will drop 1% so I get a perfect score and live the fame of being no.1 (until Gears4 show up and finally is a better game than I thought).
 
P

Playsage

Member
I guess I should be at 53 in the leaderboard...

PayOffWizard said:
0qwLTbe.png

Exact Score = 12 points
1 point off = 9 Points
2 points off = 8 Points
3 points off = 7 Points
4 points off = 6 Points
5 points off = 5 Points
6 points off = 4 Points
7 points off = 4 Points
8 points off = 3 Points
9 points off = 2 Points
10 points off = 1 Points
Click to expand...

Playsage said:
Current Total: 49 points

Back to the race:
Game 5. Uncharted 4 94*
Game 7. No Mans Sky 77
Game 8. StarFox Zero 78* 71
Game 9. Gears of War 4 84*
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee 78*
* updated
Click to expand...

Still, Oneself just threw my starting lead off a cliff :'(
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
Scores have been updated after Star Fox Zero (71 final score).

Congratulations to Oneself for becoming the new leader after Playsage held the top spot for an incredible 5 games in a row.
 
O

Oneself

Member
PayOffWizard said:
Scores have been updated after Star Fox Zero (71 final score).

Congratulations to Oneself for becoming the new leader after Playsage held the top spot for an incredible 5 games in a row.
Click to expand...
Mission accomplished ;)

Now watch me dive down when Gears 4 gets a better rating than I initially thought.
 
Kssio_Aug

Kssio_Aug

Member
Game 5. Uncharted 4 - 92
Game 7. No Mans Sky - 71
Game 9. Gears 4 - 88
Game 10. Yooka-Laylee - Delayed to 2017.

Ps.: Thats a prediction of what I believe the media will follow, not my personal excitement for each game.
 
L

littlebigman

Member
Daaaaaaamn was I way off with most of my predictions. Was definitely expecting more than 9 points even without all the games being released yet.
 
M

Mdk7

Member
Love this thread and thanks to PayOffWizard for this whole thing, but I should have more points than 12... I mean I predicted the exact score of Quantum Break, plus I was definitely very close to others...
I should be at 48 points, if I didn't fuck up something. :d
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
Mdk7 said:
Love this thread and thanks to PayOffWizard for this whole thing, but I should have more points than 12... I mean I predicted the exact score of Quantum Break, plus I was definitely very close to others...
I should be at 48 points, if I didn't fuck up something. :d
Click to expand...

The list which has you on 12 points is an old update after only 3 game releases.
I have your current score on 41 which is just short of the leaderboard.
Unfortunately your guesses were entered shortly after the embargo for Far Cry had been lifted so i'm unable to award any points for that game.

Ill post a full leaderbord of everyone's scores after the Uncharted 4 update. - Probably on Monday.
 
M

Mdk7

Member
PayOffWizard said:
The list which has you on 12 points is an old update after only 3 game releases.
I have your current score on 41 which is just short of the leaderboard.
Unfortunately your guesses were entered shortly after the embargo for Far Cry had been lifted so i'm unable to award any points for that game.

Ill post a full leaderbord of everyone's scores after the Uncharted 4 update. - Probably on Monday.
Click to expand...

Thanks man!
I think I'm going to change my prediction regardin Yooka-Laylee... I smell a delay (but I'm still convinced about the score range). :D
 
P

PayOffWizard

Member
zsynqx said:
Is it getting updated with Uncharted 4 today?
Click to expand...

I was planning to but i think there is a strong possible that the score could change after the release of the multiplayer.
For this reason I've decided to postpone the final score until after the official release of the game.

Expect the update sometime between Wednesday - Friday.

p.s. I guessed 94 and the 12 points will probably push me onto the leaderbord, figers crossed it doesnt change :p
 
D

digitalrelic

Banned
Just want to verify... Is it okay to change my score prediction before a game is released? I was thinking of changing my Gears of War 4 prediction.
 
prag16

prag16

Banned
Shit. I came close to changing my 91 to a 94 for UC4, but didn't pull the trigger. That'll knock me down the leaderboard.

digitalrelic said:
Just want to verify... Is it okay to change my score prediction before a game is released? I was thinking of changing my Gears of War 4 prediction.
Click to expand...

I believe this has been allowed, all the way up until the embargo is up for each respective game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Metacritic's 14th Annual Game Publisher Rankings
20
1K
crackajack replied
Famitsu Review Scores: Issue 1842 — Rise of the Ronin Review Score: 9/10/9/9 [37/40]
Review
17
1K
killatopak replied
Famitsu Review Scores: Issue 1835 | Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth awarded a perfect score
Review
44
3K
Miyazaki’s Slave replied
I don’t understand why more reviewers don’t use a 5 star system
2
50
2K
Holammer replied
Top 10 indies?
2
55
2K
IAmRei replied
Top Bottom