-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
1UP Yours - 08/30/08 - PAX Panel
- Thread starter evlcookie
- Start date
It's funny to see Shane haters constantly inventing reasons to dislike him. I mean if his more recent preview of Too Human he described it as mundane. Sure he didn't always use to word, but it's hardly the revisionist history that people are making up.
It's the same thing with the people who deliberately misinterpreted his Pendulem comments. He was right, period. he never aid that the annoucements would equal/neutralize FFXIII.
It's the same thing with the people who deliberately misinterpreted his Pendulem comments. He was right, period. he never aid that the annoucements would equal/neutralize FFXIII.
When I heard the question about the PS3 outselling the 360 I started thinking that maybe the 360 has reached market saturation at its current price point. New customer's are as willing to buy at that price, and all their hardcore fans have played every available game and are starting to buy PS3s as well to get games like MGS4. They at least are willing to shell out that much.
Rabbit Lord
Member
You sycophants.
Too bad this couldn't have been a full-length podcast. Luke was great on it, as was Adam Sessler. The length really killed any hope of a Braid throw-down with Jeff or a real discussion on Castle Crashers, which sucked.
Shane hate was dumb. Really seemed like a couple of dudes trying to be popular with the crowd. He adds a lot to the podcast in terms of games to talk about, and he's got hilarious quips and anecdotes.
Shane hate was dumb. Really seemed like a couple of dudes trying to be popular with the crowd. He adds a lot to the podcast in terms of games to talk about, and he's got hilarious quips and anecdotes.
D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
+1 for the Shane appreciation. I don't always agree with what he says, but he adds a lot of personality to the show and is one of the most entertaining people in the business. Fuck the haters.
TheGreatDave
Banned
It's easy to forget what Mangod means. Let's break it down; Shane is a God disguised as a man. His magnificence can not be downplayed.
The Bookerman
Member
+1 for Shane.
To me, luke comes off as a obnoxious whore, who has an apparent bias towards Xbox stuff.
Not that Shane isn't biased towards Sony(Or tries to be the secret biggest fan of everything) but Luke is just way too irratating for me.
To me, luke comes off as a obnoxious whore, who has an apparent bias towards Xbox stuff.
Not that Shane isn't biased towards Sony(Or tries to be the secret biggest fan of everything) but Luke is just way too irratating for me.
PuppetMaster
Member
Garnett is entertaining. But he is often not coherent enough to contribute something useful to the coversations besides humor. It's like he often fails to fully think things though before opening his mouth.
Skip is the opposite of Garnett in that he is way too shy and every sentence he utters is way too guarded. He needs to be less concerned about saying something stupid and just let it rip.
John is cool but he is not exactly much of a gamer anymore. But his knowledge and experience in the industry is worth something.
Luke, it was always hard to tell when he was trolling, and when he was being serious. But he did have some insightful things to say.
Shane I like a lot. You can tell games are in his blood. If you cut him, he would bleed games. He does come across a bit too dogmatic at times. And thats what hurts him the most when he is wrong about something.
Brian was just way too cool and good looking to be part of 1UP. He is just too charming and likeable. And all the girls want to bang him. Oh I hate you Brian!
Mark McD was awesome. Smart guy, witty, good all round knowledge of games. Just a class act. Best 4th chair ever.
Skip is the opposite of Garnett in that he is way too shy and every sentence he utters is way too guarded. He needs to be less concerned about saying something stupid and just let it rip.
John is cool but he is not exactly much of a gamer anymore. But his knowledge and experience in the industry is worth something.
Luke, it was always hard to tell when he was trolling, and when he was being serious. But he did have some insightful things to say.
Shane I like a lot. You can tell games are in his blood. If you cut him, he would bleed games. He does come across a bit too dogmatic at times. And thats what hurts him the most when he is wrong about something.
Brian was just way too cool and good looking to be part of 1UP. He is just too charming and likeable. And all the girls want to bang him. Oh I hate you Brian!
Mark McD was awesome. Smart guy, witty, good all round knowledge of games. Just a class act. Best 4th chair ever.
wolfmat
Confirmed Asshole
For those who didn't catch it, here's my public service again:
http://www.mediafire.com/?mnibj2mtekg
That is the PAX 1Up Yours filtered through an equalizer so your ears won't bleed.
http://www.mediafire.com/?mnibj2mtekg
That is the PAX 1Up Yours filtered through an equalizer so your ears won't bleed.
Zen said:
He was right about nothing, nothing whatsoever and that is exactly the reason his pendulum shifting comments were made fun of basically by his own colleagues and the likes of the internet gaming community in general.
It's like any other drivel comment that has come out of this mouth since this generation began and the list is long. Bu, bu, bu, but DMC4 will never come to the 360. Bu, bu, but it's a Dreamcast game in HD. Bu, bu, bu, but Bungie is working mulitplat. Ect, ect. Talk about questioning integrity in journalism this is where you start. He reaps exactly what he sows. He is good for the laughs, but not much more.
As for the show, awesome comments on Left 4 Dead from Shawn. Adam Sessler has got to be one of the best in business.
PuppetMaster
Member
Jtyettis said:
The fact that you care so much about someone being wrong on the internet is much more embarassing.
Embarrassment? Yeah, really embarrassed when Garnett told me in my ear that what I said was great. Really embarrassed when I and a bunch of other 1up dudes hung around with Shane and Garnett the following night and actually spoke about PSU and PSP. You have no idea what you're talking about. Mind your own business.Truespeed said:
Some of you guys take everything too seriously including things the 1up guys say and the jokes that get thrown around.
BenjaminBirdie
Banned
Rez>You said:
It's pretty open and shut. He's the only one on the podcast who's made Tim & Eric references.
The End.
To clarify I was being sarcastic. My "hate" was, "Why do you hate PSU when you were in it?"
It looks like some of you guys are confusing me for the kid I posted about earlier in this thread. (Wow, people not reading a thread as intended. I shouldn't be surprised actually.)
Regardless, that was some random kid who said the line earlier in the crowd by me. Some other kid told him he should have said it louder. From there on the kid must have been preparing it as his question.
Stop confusing me for him. I praised Garnett, messed around with Luke (who returned the favor later at the Bungie booth :lol ) and pointed out to everyone the little known fact that a character modeled after Shane, using his full name, was an NPC in Phantasy Star Universe.
It looks like some of you guys are confusing me for the kid I posted about earlier in this thread. (Wow, people not reading a thread as intended. I shouldn't be surprised actually.)
Regardless, that was some random kid who said the line earlier in the crowd by me. Some other kid told him he should have said it louder. From there on the kid must have been preparing it as his question.
Stop confusing me for him. I praised Garnett, messed around with Luke (who returned the favor later at the Bungie booth :lol ) and pointed out to everyone the little known fact that a character modeled after Shane, using his full name, was an NPC in Phantasy Star Universe.
PhlivoSong
Member
Blueblur1 said:
Well said. Lighten up people.
PhlivoSong
Member
Truespeed said:
Anyone who hasn't listened yet needs to listen to this one. It sounds significantly better. Thanks for cleaning it up a bit.
freethought
Member
When's the video going up?
lybertyboy
Thinks the Evil Empire is just misunderstood.
I'm in the office and capturing all video footage right now. From a cursory scrub through, the audio seems ok, but I won't know for sure until I go through the whole thing. BTW, it's going to be a couple hours before it goes up. I'll be splitting the show into two parts: Whatcha been playin/seeing PAX 08 edition and the audience Q & A.
Truespeed
Member
Blueblur1 said:
You were verbally smacked down by Shane while you were reading your script. What part of the recording indicates otherwise?
As for Garnett whispering in your ear. Well, Garnett is a bit of a lush and he probably thought you were a female, through his beer goggles, and wanted to pork you.
lybertyboy
Thinks the Evil Empire is just misunderstood.
I'm rendering out Part 1 (Whatch'a Been Playin?) right now. Part 2 will be up tomorrow. Although certainly not perfect, the audio in this should be better than the podcast version. I only have time to upload the mp4 into the flash player today, but I'll have downloadable versions uploaded tomorrow.
lybertyboy
Thinks the Evil Empire is just misunderstood.
1UP Yours PAX 08 Live 1/2 - http://gamevideos.1up.com/video/id/21253
Part 2 and download versions will be up tomorrow. If you want to download the .mp4 from the flash player I recommend using a Firefox extension called DownloadHelper.
Part 2 and download versions will be up tomorrow. If you want to download the .mp4 from the flash player I recommend using a Firefox extension called DownloadHelper.
rollingstart
Banned
lybertyboy said:
Thanks.
Shame the audio still isn't great, but seems better than before I think.
Zombie James
Banned
Trying to download it. GameVideos has been ass all day today.