Support NeoGAF

[Mumei]

This has probably been the weakest top 3 show ever. It's like nobody really wanted in the finale.

Yeah. In every other top three I can think of, there was at least one person I would be happy with seeing win.

 

[Baconsammy]

I'm fine with Phil winning. I'm fine with Joshua winning. I'm not fine with Jessica winning merely because Randy's consistently called her one of the greatest singers in America when she wasnt even in the top 3 best singers on the show. Get Randy and Steven off the show next season. Since JLo is already gone, wipe the slate and start anew.

 

[JCX]

The new judges should be Michael Slezak, random Pop-Gaf GIFs, and a salty ex-contestant.

 

[Trigger]

The new judges should be Michael Slezak, random Pop-Gaf GIFs, and a salty ex-contestant.

 

[SecretMoblin]

The new judges should be Michael Slezak, random Pop-Gaf GIFs, and a salty ex-contestant.

 

[Mumei]

The new judges should be Michael Slezak, random Pop-Gaf GIFs, and a salty ex-contestant.

They'll get more interchangeable faces to recite their producer-written lines. Are you excited?

 

[Baconsammy]

Make the 3 runnerups from the prior season be the judges. Then we'll have a guaranteed batch of new losers each year.

 

[Haint]

Wish the finale were Joshua and Jessica but I think the white preteen voting bloc will put Phillip through. Any of these 3 winning is an improvement over the coronation of King Scotty but I want that J v J showdown.

Philip would be there even without any particular demographic's backing. Jessica simply isn't a very likeable character and her past few shows have been up and down averaging out at "ok". Josh is a likable character, but his over the top style of singing probably isn't hugely popular with a majority of people.

 

[Tunic]

This has probably been the weakest top 3 show ever. It's like nobody really wanted in the finale.

I definitely agree with you. I don't see any of the remaining 3 having much success at all. Disappointing season by far.

 

[krypt0nian]

I definitely agree with you. I don't see any of the remaining 3 having much success at all. Disappointing season by far.

Skylar has the best career out of all of them easily.

Watching tonight for Glambert!

 

[Trigger]

Philip would be there even without any particular demographic's backing. Jessica simply isn't a very likeable character and her past few shows have been up and down averaging out at "ok". Josh is a likable character, but his over the top style of singing probably isn't hugely popular with a majority of people.

This is a real problem. All my classmates on campus agreed that she was a diva. The judges save only increased this feeling. Unfortunate because I don't think she really is one.

 

[Satch]

lets get this show on the road

 

[MIMIC]

My source tells me Phil's getting the boot.

Spoiler

My source is my desires, lol

Ugh...Adam's back -_-

 

[Satch]

why do i get the sense that jessica and joshua dont like phil


edit: phil is dressed so pedestrian

 

[JCX]

This is a real problem. All my classmates on campus agreed that she was a diva. The judges save only increased this feeling. Unfortunate because I don't think she really is one.

I think she's the type of shy person who often gets mistaken for snobby when she really just has nothing else to say.

 

[Kisaya]

why do i get the sense that jessica and joshua dont like phil


edit: phil is dressed so pedestrian

They know he's gonna boot one of them

 

[JCX]

Phil must be really far ahead in votes, or else they would have trotted out the "This is a singing competition!" line this week.

Haha Phil never is in any ad.

 

[Delio]

Here for my fav gayclosetedman Joshua!

 

[MIMIC]

Jimmy: "I take 100% for possibly sabotaging Joshua"

The fuck?

 

[Satch]

hopefully JLo takes responsibility for sabotaging Jessica last night with that Messiah song

 

[Trigger]

Jimmy: "I take 100% for possibly sabotaging Joshua"

The fuck?

It's a set-up.

EDIT- lol, Phil's a douche.

 

[Satch]

what the hell is this ICE AGE MESS

 

[Delio]

Why is Hollie there?

 

[MIMIC]

Dat new-age cross-promotion

 

[Satch]

phil being a fuck-up as per usual

lol lisa-marie

#whenwillourfavs

 

[Trigger]

Why is Elvis's mom on stage?

 

[MIMIC]

I can't get jiggy with this shit!

 

[Mumei]

Bleh.

 

[Satch]

Why is Elvis's mom on stage?

iudsgfkhbjdgh;eroj/ldkf lmaooo

 

[Boss Man]

Are they trying to tell me to change the channel?

 

[Satch]

YOU AINT SEEN NOTHING YET
SO CALL ME MAYBE

 

[Delio]

What is this CALLING TO THE WILDS STAGE?

 

[Mumei]

YOU AINT SEEN NOTHING YET
SO CALL ME MAYBE

At least Call Me Maybe keeps me awake.

 

[Satch]

LOL @ the camera cutting to all the elderly in the audience

 

[Trigger]

GG that was terrible.

 

[Kisaya]

House is ending?! ;~;

 

[MIMIC]

LOL @ the camera cutting to all the elderly in the audience

Yeah, wtf was that about?

 

[Boss Man]

Maybe they just put her up there to transition into season 12 auditions? "Do you have what it takes to be on this stage? I bet you do."

 

[MIMIC]

Is Jimmy on crack?! He confesses to picking a shitty song for Jessica, too.

 

[Trigger]

Maybe they just put her up there to transition into season 12 auditions? "Do you have what it takes to be on this stage? I bet you do."

American Idol Season 12 |OT| Not Even J-LO Wants Anymore of this Shit

 

[Satch]

nicki minaj and drake are in that new ice-age movie??????


lordt

 

[JCX]

Mimic, I'd rather he be honest than be dumb like the judges.

 

[Satch]

donna

:'(

:'(

:'(

:'(


edit: adam's background singers <3

 

[Trigger]

Why did we need Rita Wilson's input on Donna Summer? Idol needs to learn the art of subtle product placement.

 

[MIMIC]

Mimic, I'd rather he be honest than be dumb like the judges.

I agree....but he's just showing how his advice sucks. He's better off giving the cold, hard facts than how anyone should improve.

 

[Satch]

i liked that


u betta werk adam

 

[Delio]

The new judges should be Michael Slezak, random Pop-Gaf GIFs, and a salty ex-contestant.

 

[Mumei]

i liked that


u betta werk adam

Not the biggest fan of the song, but ... at least he can sing.

 

[Boss Man]

Please send Phillip home right now, don't even bullshit and drag the show out.

 

[Delio]

Please send Phillip home right now, don't even bullshit and drag the show out.

You already know he has won.