• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

American Idol Season 8 discussion thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
"I love Ryan, and I even picked out our children's names."

"We're going to make out after I get my gold ticket." "I think that's against the rules."

:lol :lol :lol

Definitely a different type of audition.
 
the new judge came across as a jealous bitch. Yeah, she can sing better, but she's a professional. The bikini girl is a nobody. And Paula is a fucking hack, how can she call anyone terrible?:lol
 
"I don't seem like I'm picking on the pretty girl..."
But you are... if this was some average looking girl you would have said yes in a heartbeat. Don't be so jealous.
 
agrajag said:
the new judge came across as a jealous bitch. Yeah, she can sing better, but she's a professional. The bikini girl is a nobody. And Paula is a fucking hack, how can she call anyone terrible?:lol
Click to expand...
New judge definitely shouldn't have gotten all crazy. She sang fairly well, especially for this level of the competition, so yes, she goes through.

Sorry you don't approve of her dress code, but deal with it.
 
Fantastical said:
"I don't seem like I'm picking on the pretty girl..."
But you are... if this was some average looking girl you would have said yes in a heartbeat. Don't be so jealous.
Click to expand...

Dude she was terrible. She was changing the tone of her voice by nodding her head.
 
RubxQub said:
New judge definitely shouldn't have gotten all crazy. She sang fairly well, especially for this level of the competition, so yes, she goes through.

Sorry you don't approve of her dress code, but deal with it.
Click to expand...

She's so fucking transparent. There were so many people much, much, MUCH worse than the bikini girl. But somehow she took personal offense to bikini girl's very existence and felt that she needed to humiliate her. And preface it with a disclaimer that she's not doing it because she's jealous of her body or whatever. Ok.

MIMIC said:
"It's spelled CHACOLATE!"

Poor, stupid Paula :(
Click to expand...

She was saying that they spelled it "chacolate" on his back.
 
SolidSnakex said:
Dude she was terrible. She was changing the tone of her voice by nodding her head.
Click to expand...
She was definitely not terrible. Yeah, the judge was better but that's unfair. She just exaggerated it, and they've let way worse through.
 
Simon just said yes as he was flipping her the bird :lol
 
Fantastical said:
She was definitely not terrible. Yeah, the judge was better but that's unfair. She just exaggerated it, and they've let way worse through.
Click to expand...

I find very few things musically more annoying than people that try to imitate people like Mariah, Whitney ect. when they don't have the voice to do it. And she didn't have the voice to do it. And it really showed when she was "battling" with Kara. Had she came in with regular clothes on every one of those judges would've said no to her.
 
No they wouldn't have. They would've let her through because she's decent enough to advance to the next round. This round is pretty meaningless, they just weed out the worst of the worst. Worst of the worst she is not. And regardless of what annoys you, she isn't terrible and didn't deserve to be humiliated just because the judge didn't like that she sang a song that was "too big for her voice" or whatever stupid reason she gave.
 
KibblesBits said:
I'm NOT liking this new judge at all.
Click to expand...
I don't think she was picked to appeal to the male demographic. She's not all that great to look at (odd nose) and she's clearly all hopped up on attitude.
 
SolidSnakex said:
I find very few things musically more annoying than people that try to imitate people like Mariah, Whitney ect. when they don't have the voice to do it. And she didn't have the voice to do it. And it really showed when she was "battling" with Kara. Had she came in with regular clothes on every one of those judges would've said no to her.
Click to expand...

Not to mention her whole attitude sucks. Sure, she's hot, but I bet she's a lousy lay.
 
RubxQub said:
I don't think she was picked to appeal to the male demographic. She's not all that great to look at (odd nose) and she's clearly all hopped up on attitude.
Click to expand...

I liked her at first because she's hot (imo) and she seems genuinely talented, but her attitude blows. She seems like she has a chip on her shoulder.
 
agrajag said:
No they wouldn't have. They would've let her through because she's decent enough to advance to the next round. This round is pretty meaningless, they just weed out the worst of the worst. Worst of the worst she is not. And regardless of what annoys you, she isn't terrible and didn't deserve to be humiliated just because the judge didn't like that she sang a song that was "too big for her voice" or whatever stupid reason she gave.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure she was the one who humiliated herself by coming to the competition wearing what she did and acting the way she was.
 
I can't find a single attractive picture of her online, and her nose is distracting. Not ugly, not celebrity hot.
SolidSnakex said:
I'm pretty sure she was the one who humiliated herself by coming to the competition wearing what she did and acting the way she was.
Click to expand...
Marketing, dude. Marketing.
 
SolidSnakex said:
I'm pretty sure she was the one who humiliated herself by coming to the competition wearing what she did and acting the way she was.
Click to expand...

I find what the judge did equally embarassing. She turned the show into Jerry Springer for a few seconds. Normally it is aslightly above that.
 
"That joke would be good if it made sense..."

:lol
 
yeah, she sucked pretty badly at that. But why are they all singing that song? It's not what any of those people sung in their auditions. Fucking staged shit.
 
SolidSnakex said:
:lol Notice that bikini girl is mixed in with all the bad singers?
Click to expand...

They don't sings these songs in front of the judges. The producers (or whoever) pick a song that everyone ruins and have all of the contestants sing it without the judges being present. All of the judges reactions are edited it.
 
agrajag said:
yeah, she sucked pretty badly at that. But why are they all singing that song? It's not what any of those people sung in their auditions. Fucking staged shit.
Click to expand...

They do this every season. They bring back the people they see as the worst from the cities competition and tell them to sing a song and this is the result of it.
 
Simon shouldn't have told that one guy that he couldn't do well in that competition since he was proven wrong when he said Taylor couldn't do well. He did well in the competition but did so terribly when he released his album that his record company dropped him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Silo - Season 3 Official Teaser
15
247
Bojji replied
Good Omens | Final Season | Official Trailer
6
169
Grenseal replied
Season 8 of Rick and Morty premiered today
2
69
4K
deriks replied
Beast Games Season 2
8
481
OccasionalPoster replied
King of the Hill returns 8/4 for a new season
2 3
116
4K
Toots replied
Top Bottom