• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

And now for the important stuff - Packaging

grap3fruitman said:
I hate the huge banners on every single game packaging ever. I'd like a small logo that doesn't take too much space away from the artwork. Is that too much to ask for?
The One Console Future is the only way this will come to pass. With a bunch of systems competing, you have to bludgeon the customer over the head to make sure they don't mistakenly buy for the wrong platform.

PS3 & PSP's new banner is pretty tiny in the scheme of things, though. Progress!
 
DidntKnowJack said:
And the overall winner (for me):
91fpe8.jpg

Funny. I just took a picture of the same spread yesterday, since I'm planning on selling the game. I disagree with PS1 cases though, they get banged up way too easily. I take care of my games, and almost all my PS1 cases have a few scuffs on them. I even had a few of them with broken parts when I bought the game.
 
kiun said:
The worst designed packaging has to be those PSPs UMD cases. All copies come with a damaged manual.
*grabs some random PSP games from the shelf and checks them*

...Nooo? They're all pristine on my end. The solution's the same as it's always been if you want stuff in new condition: Buy new.
 
DidntKnowJack said:
I also liked some of the early PS1 long boxes, like the first Resident Evil. It had some subtle and cool art inside the hard case.

29kw46p.jpg


Not so much the plastic ones which seemed to be carried over from the Sega Saturn. Those hard plastic clear ones.
In PAL-land we never had huge PS1 boxes like that but regular jewel cases, I can understand why we went with the better option :P
 
Best: Japanese Gamecube boxes
kbezv9.jpg

They are just so tiny.


Honorable mention: UK PS1 Amaray rental boxes
9r0xl5.jpg

Basically a DVD case cut in half, ridiculously sturdy but far less wasted space and plastic. Rather than cutting massive holes in the cases they should be using these beauties instead
 
Since we are on the subject "environmental friendly cases suck", anybody know a place where you can buy 360 replacements? I remember buying some on ebay back then...
 
Azure Phoenix said:
Best: Japanese Gamecube boxes
http://i40.tinypic.com/kbezv9.jpg[img]
They are just so tiny, shows just how much wasted space there is in those DVD sized GC boxes.[/QUOTE]
My favourite thing about the cases is the memory card holder bit actually works properly (it is easy to fit the card in there, in the way it is intended, the western ones always jutted out for me or ended up in a iron grip).
[IMG]http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y208/Starwolf_UK/NTSC_J_GCN_Box/DSCN0057-1.jpg
I also really like the style of the discs; it is a shame that Wii games had to use less tones (I think it went down to 1 or 2 plus the silver of the disc) and then went full colour...I liked the monochrome style
the only flaw is the cardboard can technically get tattered and 2 disc games I've heard have disc 2 on the manual side (I think in a mini-sleeve).

But I guess NoA went with DVD cases due to wanting reasonable sized text and (more importantly) shelf space.

Apart from that I like the design behind Wii cases and EU DS cases in the sense here are your games, the spine is white except for the text which is black. The only issue is the text itself SOME GAMES ARE IN ALL CAPITAL LETTERS while others use Both Upper and Lower case plus throw in font size/type differences (though you only notice when you're up-close)...
whyaretheydifferentfonts.jpg

Notice how the top font is slimmer and taller. Moving on, you also have games which use the logo instead (sometimes all of these things are done by the same publisher in a matter of months). I can understand why some would fault them as being bland (and the thick cases for the occasionally thick manuals) I prefer that to a explosion in the paint factory look spines of all difference background colours can look. Except when it ruins what would be a piece of art that starts on the front cover, continues to the spine and ends on the back cover but such things seem to be fairly rare.
 
Shig said:
*grabs some random PSP games from the shelf and checks them*

...Nooo? They're all pristine on my end. The solution's the same as it's always been if you want stuff in new condition: Buy new.

even new... check the top and bottom edges of your manual (not corner)
 
You know what I just realized...

Packaging a game inside a case kind of establishes value. I know it sounds silly but think about it.

When you frame a picture, you're doing so to make it look more special than it is. I think the same might apply to video games.
 
EatChildren said:
From generation to generation, all I want is colour in my manual.

Is that so much to ask?
dudes like atlus and aksys and even capcom are pretty good about this
ea and activision not so much
 
I always enjoyed the Fallout 3 Collector's Edition. The lunchbox is awesome in it's own right, but the Vault Boy Bobblehead really takes the cake.
 
I'ma have to agree on old PC games. Every time I bought a game I felt like opening a birthday present, even when the insides were just the CD and small booklet.
 
DonMigs85 said:
SNES, N64 and GBA game boxes smelled great in a way that Wii and DS game cases just can't compete with
In 10 years, you will be able to find a complete copy of a Wii or DS game in great condition with an ease that SNES, N64, and GBA just can't compete with.

Definitely worth the trade-off.
 
Shig said:
In 10 years, you will be able to find a complete copy of a Wii or DS game in great condition with an ease that SNES, N64, and GBA just can't compete with.

Definitely worth the trade-off.

It's especially helped for casual purchases. Like, collectors can make anything last forever, but imagine if GameStop was as big as it was now and used games were as big as they are now in 1994?

Seeing walls of SNES games, no manuals, no cases, with marker written on them. Ugh.
 
My favourite ever game packaging:

CannonFodder2.jpg


My second favourite:

Steam.jpg


I am guilty of only caring about the game.
 
talk to your brother
kill him with your gun
leave him lying in his uniform
dying in the sun





WAR!

(never been so much fun)
 
regarding the current generation, I have PS3 games from USA, Canada, Germany, UK (some are PEGI/Europe) and HK.
In terms of standard versions, at least for the first party games the last has almost perfect packaging out of all regions, followed by USA.

I have Siren, Aquanaut's Holiday, Hakuna Matata and Toro Let's Party as the english HK versions and all have nice inside coverart, quite a thick fully coloured manual (including artworks for whole almost text-less pages) made of thick quality paper, no age rating on the cover and an art on the spine. Though (and this is why I said "almost") not all have the title on the spine in the game's font (and there is some kind of colour code on the lower spine?).

sorry for bad picture:
2cf8qbl.jpg



Canada and the inconsistent PAL versions have some of the worst PS3 cases (=white spine with game title in black standard font, no inside art and a five pages b&w/grey manual).
One of the reasons I go more and more for CEs if available :lol
 
Shig said:
In 10 years, you will be able to find a complete copy of a Wii or DS game in great condition with an ease that SNES, N64, and GBA just can't compete with.

Definitely worth the trade-off.
I agree. earlier last year I wanted to buy all Castlevania GBA games, and it was a pain in the ass to buy them complete (manual, box) and in good condition.

Luckily, I found them all for under 50 bucks each. Along with the DS games, they look awesome in my drawer.

I remember some people converting their GBA boxes into DS cases, and the end result was pretty damn awesome. I wish i could find the actual thread where this is first bought up and discussed, but all i can find is Mejilan telling people how to do it (and not actually coming up with the idea)

Edit: Also, all my NES and SNes boxes are gone. They either got ripped apart, crushed or overall destroyed. I think on Mario Kart still survives. My genesis cases (which came in a hard plastic cover, like the DS ones) are all intact. I am also running out of space to keep them.
 
Yeah for GBA games you can order DS cases off Nintendo and many cases have been done into DS style at the cover project.

For other systems you can use something called a "Universal Game Case" and find some covers over at the site I previously linked to.
 
I wish games would come in a short digipack type case so I can store them easier, but then again I store all my game in boxes so I am probably the only person who would like that.
 
I'm a fan of the PS3/Blu-ray/HD DVD cases for discs. So neat and small. Hat eht eugly ass US super skinny ones though. LOVE the EU/AU thicker ones.

Also like the DS packaging. Don't get me wrong, it's a waste of plastic for such a small card, but it's still neat.

I liked how the AU/EU PS2 cases used to have the spot for the memory card. Did the US ones have it?
 
I hated the N64 packaging. It was nice when you first bought a game but after taking the cartridge in and out a few times something would ultimately always get ripped or crumpled. Perhaps it's just a symptom of how young I was at the time but I also disliked the PS1 packaging, found the cases were really easy to crack.

I actually quite like the PS3 cases on their own, I still kinda wish they were standard DVD size thought just for continuity sake. I have a tonne of 360 and PS2 games and only 10 PS3, they're a bit of a sore thumb on my shelves.
 
The bitGenerations boxes remined me of those awesome Famicom re-releases on the GBA. These are the ones I own (crummy picture, sorry).

DSC00564.jpg


One of my most hated ones are the European PSX boxes. Flimsy as all fuck and ugly too.
 
I'm pretty upset that most of the old boxes I had for games (before the ones that needed them like CD/DVD/blu-ray games) are gone.

and yeah, the Japanese Gamecube ones are great. I have a few Gamecube imports and they're great. The Gameboy Player disk also had one.
 
I love love love PS3 Game cases.

I mean the ones that have:
-Inside Art
-Colored Manuals

Feel so compact and full every time I pick up a new game.

Also the latest Pokemon Game has sweet packaging.
 
For me, It would probably have to be either the PS2 cases (when there WAS a memory card holder in the case) or the PS3 cases. The PS3 cases would be PERFECT, except, just like the PSP cases, the little tabs that hold the manual don't actually hold it in place, leading to situations where when I close the case, the edge of the manual gets fucked up. I also have had an issue with brand new PS3 games where the tabs that hold the case closed have broken, meaning I can't fully close it. I know, I'm completely anal about this stuff, but I love my game cases :/
 
AvidNobody said:
I love love love PS3 Game cases.

I mean the ones that have:
-Inside Art
-Colored Manuals

Feel so compact and full every time I pick up a new game.
Yes. Inside art on PS3 should be fucking law. So depressing when you open up a new game, and it's just white.
 
Metroid Prime Trilogy has the greatest packaging I've ever seen for a standard game (at least in the US, I heard the European packaging was standard stuff).

xp2a4osilpza93i65utguoq.jpg


img2868articleimage.jpg
 
I'm assuming that the answer is no, but I might as well ask: is there anywhere an American can order Japanese gamecube game cases without just importing Japanese GC games?
 
A Twisty Fluken said:
I'm assuming that the answer is no, but I might as well ask: is there anywhere an American can order Japanese gamecube game cases without just importing Japanese GC games?

Afraid not, unless NOJ used to sell them (ala. NOA) and someone has a bulk lot in storage you won't find anyway. It's not worth getting blank cases anyway since as far as I remember they have no front plastic cover to put artwork behind - since the JP boxes just used a cardboard slip case.
 
Azure Phoenix said:
Afraid not, unless NOJ used to sell them (ala. NOA) and someone has a bulk lot in storage you won't find anyway. It's not worth getting blank cases anyway since as far as I remember they have no front plastic cover to put artwork behind - since the JP boxes just used a cardboard slip case.

Ah, that makes more sense. Now to resist just rebuying my whole collection as imports :lol
 
I miss the giant cardboard PC boxes.

zl59pc.jpg


Especially the giant manual's that came with games like Baldur's Gate 2. So many pages, it had to be spiral bound.

1hqmfb.jpg

(only picture I could find of it on the internet)
 
Packaging and boxart is incredibly important to me. Sometimes as important as, or even more important than, the quality of the game itself. And I don't care if I'm called shallow for that. I have refused to buy good games due to bad boxart, and similarly bought average games because I liked the packaging art.

This is more of a recent development for me, probably when I became more of a collector and less of an actual gamer.

On the other hand, I love digital distribution of games. Since I find most western packaging to be ugly, I'd rather have no packaging at all.
 
Top Bottom